This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/5373862.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Decision over pathologist's cases | Decision over pathologist's cases |
(10 minutes later) | |
The government could review all cases involving a Home Office pathologist who resigned from the register after criticism at a disciplinary hearing. | |
The forensic pathology watchdog ruled that Dr Michael Heath's inadequate post-mortem examinations on two women led to their partners' murder trials. | |
The attorney general will now decide if all his cases should be reviewed. | The attorney general will now decide if all his cases should be reviewed. |
Examinations he has conducted include the Lin and Megan Russell murders and the death of Stuart Lubbock. | |
Mr Lubbock's body was found in the swimming pool at entertainer Michael Barrymore's home in Harlow, Essex, in March 2001. | |
An open verdict was recorded at an inquest and no-one has been charged in connection with the death. | |
It will be a matter for the attorney general's office to now decide whether all his cases should be reviewed Home Office | It will be a matter for the attorney general's office to now decide whether all his cases should be reviewed Home Office |
Dr Heath has conducted hundreds of examinations since being appointed to his role in 1991. | |
A Home Office spokeswomen said the Advisory Board for Forensic Pathology had been due to reconvene on Monday. | |
"But Dr Heath informed the members that he was resigning from the register," she added. | "But Dr Heath informed the members that he was resigning from the register," she added. |
"The hearing has now been cancelled. | "The hearing has now been cancelled. |
"It will be a matter for the attorney general's office to now decide whether all his cases should be reviewed." | "It will be a matter for the attorney general's office to now decide whether all his cases should be reviewed." |
Dr Heath was unavailable for comment on Saturday. | Dr Heath was unavailable for comment on Saturday. |
Questions raised | Questions raised |
The six-week hearing in London was told that Dr Heath refused to back down on his view that the two women had been murdered despite mounting evidence to the contrary. | The six-week hearing in London was told that Dr Heath refused to back down on his view that the two women had been murdered despite mounting evidence to the contrary. |
In one case, Steven Puaca, of Lowestoft, was jailed at Norwich Crown Court in 2002 for killing Jacqueline Tindsley, 55. Mr Puaca was later cleared by the Appeal Court. | In one case, Steven Puaca, of Lowestoft, was jailed at Norwich Crown Court in 2002 for killing Jacqueline Tindsley, 55. Mr Puaca was later cleared by the Appeal Court. |
The second involved Kenneth Fraser, who faced an Old Bailey trial, also in 2002, for murdering Mary Anne Moore, 56, but was cleared by a jury. | The second involved Kenneth Fraser, who faced an Old Bailey trial, also in 2002, for murdering Mary Anne Moore, 56, but was cleared by a jury. |
Charles Miskin QC, for the Home Office, told the hearing that in neither case was there any substantial evidence of unlawful killing, except Dr Heath's testimony. | Charles Miskin QC, for the Home Office, told the hearing that in neither case was there any substantial evidence of unlawful killing, except Dr Heath's testimony. |
Following the trial of Mr Fraser, the Home Office received a letter from three leading pathologists who disagreed with Dr Heath's assertion that Miss Moore had been battered to death. | Following the trial of Mr Fraser, the Home Office received a letter from three leading pathologists who disagreed with Dr Heath's assertion that Miss Moore had been battered to death. |
All three agreed Ms Moore's injuries were consistent with falling down the stairs. | All three agreed Ms Moore's injuries were consistent with falling down the stairs. |
The board had found that, in both cases, Dr Heath's professional performance fell short of the standards required of forensic pathologists. | The board had found that, in both cases, Dr Heath's professional performance fell short of the standards required of forensic pathologists. |
It also upheld 20 disciplinary charges against him. | It also upheld 20 disciplinary charges against him. |
Dr Heath had been suspended from the register pending the panel's decision. | Dr Heath had been suspended from the register pending the panel's decision. |