What a leftwing leader needs to do to earn credibility
|
Version 0 of 1. Readers respond to an article by Owen Jones in which he says the left needs a figurehead who can bring back alienated voters and avoid culture wars Owen Jones makes the case that a credible leftwing leader needs to win over alienated voters and dodge culture wars (The left needs to halt the UK’s slide into Farageism. This is the kind of leader who could do it, 3 April). That starts by rejecting the terms left and right – where people sat in revolutionary France’s national assembly does not accurately define today’s politics. The leadership team of any new political movement must convince voters of two things. One: “I trust these people to run the country.” Two: “They have got my back.” Economic credibility requires exploding the austerity myth. Speaking as someone who ran an arm of government – successfully – I found that when you make the case, people, including businesspeople, think it’s common sense. That keeping kids in poverty is economically illiterate. That investing in health and education makes us all wealthier in the end, and happier too. That public ownership will lower utility bills and improve services. That the climate crisis is real, and we must invest in a resilient future or see our economy crippled. Having someone’s back means saying that we won’t throw you under the bus for an easy headline. We will put your right to a secure home above your landlord’s right to make a quick buck. We will put your kid’s mental health above the right of global corporations to avoid regulations. We will fight your corner when you’re victimised for being disabled, or black, or LGBTQ+. There is a truth to why governments can’t afford to invest. Money flows to very, very rich people. They make 8% to 12% a year from parking money in big tech, utilities, property, finance and care homes, while the rest of us do the work and actually generate the wealth. That money needs to be taxed to pay for the safe, sustainable, prosperous society that everyone needs.Jamie DriscollFormer North of Tyne mayor Owen Jones is right to some extent – a populist left with a charismatic front person is badly needed. However, his suggestion of Mick Lynch as such a leader is laughable. A new populist left alternative needs to think radically and organise broadly, connecting with and building alliances between social actors who are philosophically and/or theoretically critical of Labourism and the labour movement, especially the macho, workerist tendency that Lynch and others represent. Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s La France Insoumise is a good example of a project with some populist potential that is failing to break out of such a straitjacket. We should learn from this.Tony SamphierBeckenham, London I agree with Owen Jones that Mick Lynch would be the ideal candidate to take on Labour from the left and stave off the sinister threat of Reform. However, I would suggest that, in the absence of Mr Lynch wanting to take up this mantle, the Independent Alliance should form into a political party and merge with the Greens and those seven Labour MPs recently suspended from the party for voting against the retention of the appalling two-child cap. Such a new party would not only be 15 MPs strong – three times the size of Reform’s parliamentary presence – but would represent those predominantly middle-class former Labour voters who have turned to the Greens in disgust at Starmerism, and the traditional white working-class demographic in the “red wall” seats and other similar constituencies. Only such a unified party of the left can hope to stave off Reform and provide the “broad church” that Labour likes to tell us it is but so woefully is not, as the party’s lurch to the right under Keir Starmer leaves us in no doubt as to where its priorities now lie.Michael WaltonBath Do you have a photograph you’d like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please click here to upload it. A selection will be published in our Readers’ best photographs galleries and in the print edition on Saturdays. |