This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cz0303vkg7ko

The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Minister threatens to override new sentencing rules Minister threatens to override sentencing rules in 'two tier' row
(about 1 hour later)
The government has threatened to override the body advising judges in England and Wales in a row over how ethnic minority offenders should be sentenced. The government has threatened to override the body advising judges in England and Wales in a row over how ethnic minority offenders should be sentenced, days before new rules are set to take effect.
It comes after the Sentencing Council refused a request from the justice secretary for it to rethink new instructions for judges due to take effect next week. It comes after the Sentencing Council refused a request from the justice secretary for it to rethink new instructions for judges due to begin on Tuesday.
Under the rules, judges will be expected to consider the lives of offenders from ethnic minority and other backgrounds before deciding on punishment.Under the rules, judges will be expected to consider the lives of offenders from ethnic minority and other backgrounds before deciding on punishment.
The guidelines have prompted a "two-tier" justice row, with critics arguing certain groups of people will be less likely to go to prison for a crime.The guidelines have prompted a "two-tier" justice row, with critics arguing certain groups of people will be less likely to go to prison for a crime.
'Differential treatment''Differential treatment'
Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said she was "extremely disappointed" the council had refused her request for the guidance to be changed. Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said the guidelines would lead to "differential treatment" of offenders by courts.
"All options are on the table and I will legislate if necessary," the Labour minister said. Downing Street said Sir Keir Starmer was "disappointed" the council had refused to change the guidance and "all options" were being considered in response, including passing legislation to block the changes.
"I have been clear in my view that these guidelines represent differential treatment, under which someone's outcomes may be influenced by their race, culture or religion," she added. But shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick, a vocal opponent of the new guidance, said the threat to legislate was "too little too late".
Conservative Shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick, who also opposes the guidelines, said the threat of passing a new law had come "too little too late". "From Tuesday, [Mahmood] will preside over a sentencing system she conceded is two-tier," he added.
The updated guidance, due to come into effect on Tuesday, says judges should normally request a pre-sentence report on offenders from an ethnic, cultural or faith minority before deciding on their sentence. The row began earlier this month when the council, which advises judges and magistrates on prison terms and community punishments, issued new guidance on when a court should order a pre-sentence report into an offender's life.
The guidance also said the reports should be commissioned before sentencing other groups, such as young adults aged 18 to 25, women and pregnant women.
These reports contain information about an offender's background and are intended to help judges decide what sort of punishment is appropriate.These reports contain information about an offender's background and are intended to help judges decide what sort of punishment is appropriate.
But Jenrick hit the headlines earlier this month when he argued the new guidelines would make prison sentences "less likely" for ethnic minorities - something the council denies. The updated guidance says judges should normally request a pre-sentence report on offenders from an ethnic, cultural or faith minority, and other groups such as young adults under 25, women and pregnant women.
Mahmood had a meeting with Lord Justice Davis last week and set out in a letter that government policy opposes "differential treatment" based on race or ethnicity in the courts. The council argues its new guidance is intended to remedy a "disparity in sentence outcomes" between white and non-white offenders.
But after the Conservatives argued it would lead to a "two-tier" approach to sentencing, Mahmood said she would request it was changed.
She also echoed that "there will never be a two-tier sentencing approach under my watch".
In correspondence published on Friday, council chair Lord Justice Davis said the council has decided the guidelines "did not require revision".In correspondence published on Friday, council chair Lord Justice Davis said the council has decided the guidelines "did not require revision".
"The council respectfully disagreed with the proposition that the list of cohorts in the guideline represented an expression of policy. He added the guidelines had been subject to a four-month consultation under the previous Conservative government and the "overall response to the consultation was positive".
"In providing a list of cohorts, the council was and is only concerned with judges and magistrates being provided with as much information as possible." He said the council saw no reason to re-run the consultation, although it would now include "clarification" on the language in the guidelines to "correct the widespread misunderstanding which has emerged in the last few weeks".
He said the council agreed any systemic issue relating to ethnic groups is a matter for policy, adding: "Any judge or magistrate required to sentence an offender must do all that they can to avoid a difference in outcome based on ethnicity. An "explanatory statement" would also be added to the council's website, he added.
He added that although it was not for judges to introduce "overarching policies to redress the imbalance" in sentences, they must "do all that they can to avoid a difference in outcome based on ethnicity".
"The judge will be better equipped to do that if they have as much information as possible about the offender."The judge will be better equipped to do that if they have as much information as possible about the offender.
"The cohort of ethnic, cultural and faith minority groups may be a cohort about which judges and magistrates are less well informed.""The cohort of ethnic, cultural and faith minority groups may be a cohort about which judges and magistrates are less well informed."