This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/nov/22/nancy-mace-sarah-mcbride-transphobia
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| I’d much rather share a ladies’ room with Sarah McBride than with Nancy Mace | I’d much rather share a ladies’ room with Sarah McBride than with Nancy Mace |
| (31 minutes later) | |
| Mace’s campaign to humiliate Congress’s first openly transgender member is mean-spirited and desperate | Mace’s campaign to humiliate Congress’s first openly transgender member is mean-spirited and desperate |
| Since the conversation, if you can call it that, about trans people always seems to come down to bathrooms, I am sure of one thing. | Since the conversation, if you can call it that, about trans people always seems to come down to bathrooms, I am sure of one thing. |
| I would much rather share a ladies’ room or a locker room with Sarah McBride than with Nancy Mace. | I would much rather share a ladies’ room or a locker room with Sarah McBride than with Nancy Mace. |
| McBride, of course, was just elected to Congress and, in January, will be the highest-ranking elected official in America who is openly transgender. The 34-year-old comes to the US House of Representatives after serving in the Delaware legislature; before that, she was the national press secretary of the Human Rights Campaign. | McBride, of course, was just elected to Congress and, in January, will be the highest-ranking elected official in America who is openly transgender. The 34-year-old comes to the US House of Representatives after serving in the Delaware legislature; before that, she was the national press secretary of the Human Rights Campaign. |
| Mace, a member of Congress from South Carolina since 2021, has been on an ugly campaign in recent weeks clearly intended to belittle and marginalize McBride – and to get on TV as much as possible doing so. She has filed a resolution, and the House speaker, Mike Johnson, has given it his nod of approval, that would somehow force trans people to keep out of the congressional bathrooms that reflect their gender identity. | Mace, a member of Congress from South Carolina since 2021, has been on an ugly campaign in recent weeks clearly intended to belittle and marginalize McBride – and to get on TV as much as possible doing so. She has filed a resolution, and the House speaker, Mike Johnson, has given it his nod of approval, that would somehow force trans people to keep out of the congressional bathrooms that reflect their gender identity. |
| “If you think this bill is about protecting women and not simply a ploy to get on Fox News, you’ve been fooled,” wrote Natalie Johnson, Mace’s former communications director. She added, pointedly, that a real effort to protect women would involve “a bill to bar Matt Gaetz, a sexual predator with an affinity for underage girls, from ever walking those halls again”. (Trump, as you know, tapped the far-right former Florida representative as his attorney general as part of this month’s parade of appalling cabinet choices. Gaetz later withdrew from consideration.) | “If you think this bill is about protecting women and not simply a ploy to get on Fox News, you’ve been fooled,” wrote Natalie Johnson, Mace’s former communications director. She added, pointedly, that a real effort to protect women would involve “a bill to bar Matt Gaetz, a sexual predator with an affinity for underage girls, from ever walking those halls again”. (Trump, as you know, tapped the far-right former Florida representative as his attorney general as part of this month’s parade of appalling cabinet choices. Gaetz later withdrew from consideration.) |
| On Wednesday, McBride reacted with dignity to all the performative insults and abuse. She simply responded that she would follow the rules and that she’s in Congress to represent her Delaware district; I’m sure she’ll eventually find ways to continue her admirable advocacy. | On Wednesday, McBride reacted with dignity to all the performative insults and abuse. She simply responded that she would follow the rules and that she’s in Congress to represent her Delaware district; I’m sure she’ll eventually find ways to continue her admirable advocacy. |
| Mace, on the other hand, can’t be described as dignified. She’s running around pasting the word “biological” on restroom doors for photo ops, and snidely tweeting in McBride’s direction about International Men’s Day. | Mace, on the other hand, can’t be described as dignified. She’s running around pasting the word “biological” on restroom doors for photo ops, and snidely tweeting in McBride’s direction about International Men’s Day. |
| And she’s getting plenty of the media attention she craves. | And she’s getting plenty of the media attention she craves. |
| On one level, this is all part of the unending circus of the Trump era. | On one level, this is all part of the unending circus of the Trump era. |
| On a human level, it’s scary, wrong and damaging. | On a human level, it’s scary, wrong and damaging. |
| “As a trans person myself, I’m really worried about where this is headed,” wrote Parker Molloy, who writes incisively about politics and media in her newsletter the Present Age. “I spend each day worrying about whether or not the healthcare that keeps me alive will remain legal, whether I’m going to face new restrictions on where I’m allowed to exist in public, what would happen to me if (god forbid) I wound up in prison for some reason, and whether or not my identity documents like my passport will be retroactively made invalid.” | “As a trans person myself, I’m really worried about where this is headed,” wrote Parker Molloy, who writes incisively about politics and media in her newsletter the Present Age. “I spend each day worrying about whether or not the healthcare that keeps me alive will remain legal, whether I’m going to face new restrictions on where I’m allowed to exist in public, what would happen to me if (god forbid) I wound up in prison for some reason, and whether or not my identity documents like my passport will be retroactively made invalid.” |
| She added poignantly: “Now, more than ever, I feel alone.” | She added poignantly: “Now, more than ever, I feel alone.” |
| Trans students may have it even worse. Again, it often comes down to bathrooms. | Trans students may have it even worse. Again, it often comes down to bathrooms. |
| A lot of children, especially transgender and gender-nonconforming children, avoid bathrooms all day, since that’s where the bullying can be most intense. Thus, advocates say, trans kids often are prone to urinary tract infections or eating disorders because they’ve avoided eating and drinking. | A lot of children, especially transgender and gender-nonconforming children, avoid bathrooms all day, since that’s where the bullying can be most intense. Thus, advocates say, trans kids often are prone to urinary tract infections or eating disorders because they’ve avoided eating and drinking. |
| Sign up to Follow Margaret Sullivan | |
| Sign up to get email alerts every time Margaret Sullivan publishes a new column. | |
| after newsletter promotion | |
| As for the right’s obsession with trans students on sports team, the vast majority have no unfair advantage on the playing fields (or courts, or pools). They are just trying to reap the same benefits of sports as do other kids – leadership, teamwork and friendship. | As for the right’s obsession with trans students on sports team, the vast majority have no unfair advantage on the playing fields (or courts, or pools). They are just trying to reap the same benefits of sports as do other kids – leadership, teamwork and friendship. |
| The meanspirited and misinformed narrative about transgender people makes it difficult for them to feel cared about and to live full lives. | The meanspirited and misinformed narrative about transgender people makes it difficult for them to feel cared about and to live full lives. |
| But don’t try to tell that to Mace, whose preoccupation is not with kindness or decency, but with getting attention and winning the culture wars. | But don’t try to tell that to Mace, whose preoccupation is not with kindness or decency, but with getting attention and winning the culture wars. |
| As the Daily Beast reported last year, Mace’s staffers were given a handbook that outlined just how intensely this mattered to their boss; they were told to book her on TV multiple times a day, amounting to nine times a week for national outlets and six times a week for local outlets. | As the Daily Beast reported last year, Mace’s staffers were given a handbook that outlined just how intensely this mattered to their boss; they were told to book her on TV multiple times a day, amounting to nine times a week for national outlets and six times a week for local outlets. |
| In 2021, Mace depicted herself as supportive of LGBTQ+ rights. That was before the tide turned so forcefully and, as Philip Bump of the Washington Post put it, before “the Republican base had been fed a steady diet of anti-trans rhetoric, making trans issues fertile ground for anyone willing to engage in the fight”. | In 2021, Mace depicted herself as supportive of LGBTQ+ rights. That was before the tide turned so forcefully and, as Philip Bump of the Washington Post put it, before “the Republican base had been fed a steady diet of anti-trans rhetoric, making trans issues fertile ground for anyone willing to engage in the fight”. |
| Mace, clearly, is more than willing. | Mace, clearly, is more than willing. |
| If that means being cruel, then so be it. As writer Adam Serwer observed about Trumpian politics: “The cruelty is the point.” | If that means being cruel, then so be it. As writer Adam Serwer observed about Trumpian politics: “The cruelty is the point.” |
| Meanwhile, vulnerable and marginalized people are made to suffer for trying to be true to themselves. And despite the progress shown by McBride’s election, the world around this milestone seems to be getting increasingly harsh. | Meanwhile, vulnerable and marginalized people are made to suffer for trying to be true to themselves. And despite the progress shown by McBride’s election, the world around this milestone seems to be getting increasingly harsh. |
| Margaret Sullivan is a Guardian US columnist writing on media, politics and culture | Margaret Sullivan is a Guardian US columnist writing on media, politics and culture |
| Margaret Sullivan is a Guardian US columnist writing on media, politics and culture | Margaret Sullivan is a Guardian US columnist writing on media, politics and culture |