This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/nov/21/what-is-methanol-how-does-it-get-into-alcoholic-drinks-and-why-is-it-so-dangerous
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| What is methanol, how does it get into alcoholic drinks and why is it so dangerous? | What is methanol, how does it get into alcoholic drinks and why is it so dangerous? |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| Poisoning can overload the body with acid, causing vomiting, abdominal pain, unconsciousness and vision loss | Poisoning can overload the body with acid, causing vomiting, abdominal pain, unconsciousness and vision loss |
| Two Australian teenagers have died in hospitals in Thailand after experiencing suspected methanol poisoning while travelling in Laos. | |
| The pair are among several foreign nationals to become ill after unknowingly consuming alcoholic drinks containing methanol in the south-east Asian country. Three deaths have reportedly been linked to the mass poisoning. | The pair are among several foreign nationals to become ill after unknowingly consuming alcoholic drinks containing methanol in the south-east Asian country. Three deaths have reportedly been linked to the mass poisoning. |
| So what is methanol, and how does it make people sick? | So what is methanol, and how does it make people sick? |
| Methanol v ethanol | Methanol v ethanol |
| Methanol is an alcohol, like the familiar ethanol we consume in alcoholic beverages. | Methanol is an alcohol, like the familiar ethanol we consume in alcoholic beverages. |
| Like ethanol, methanol is a colourless, flammable liquid. It has a smell similar to ethanol as well. | Like ethanol, methanol is a colourless, flammable liquid. It has a smell similar to ethanol as well. |
| But the two have different chemical structures. Methanol is composed of only one carbon atom, while ethanol has two. | But the two have different chemical structures. Methanol is composed of only one carbon atom, while ethanol has two. |
| That one carbon atom makes all the difference. It means methanol is processed differently in our bodies and is much more toxic than ethanol. | That one carbon atom makes all the difference. It means methanol is processed differently in our bodies and is much more toxic than ethanol. |
| Methanol is used in a variety of industrial and household products, such as windshield cleaning fluids, antifreeze and fuel. It’s not safe for human consumption. | Methanol is used in a variety of industrial and household products, such as windshield cleaning fluids, antifreeze and fuel. It’s not safe for human consumption. |
| What makes methanol toxic? | What makes methanol toxic? |
| The difference is in how methanol is metabolised, or broken down in our bodies. | The difference is in how methanol is metabolised, or broken down in our bodies. |
| Ethanol is metabolised into a chemical compound called acetaldehyde. Acetaldehyde is toxic but is rapidly converted to acetate (also known as acetic acid, found in vinegar). Generating an acid may sound bad but acetate actually produces energy and makes important molecules in the body. | Ethanol is metabolised into a chemical compound called acetaldehyde. Acetaldehyde is toxic but is rapidly converted to acetate (also known as acetic acid, found in vinegar). Generating an acid may sound bad but acetate actually produces energy and makes important molecules in the body. |
| By contrast, methanol is metabolised into formaldehyde (a chemical used in industrial glues and for embalming corpses) and then to formic acid (the chemical in some ant bites that makes them hurt so much). | By contrast, methanol is metabolised into formaldehyde (a chemical used in industrial glues and for embalming corpses) and then to formic acid (the chemical in some ant bites that makes them hurt so much). |
| Unlike acetate, which the body uses, formic acid poisons the mitochondria, the powerhouses of the cells. | Unlike acetate, which the body uses, formic acid poisons the mitochondria, the powerhouses of the cells. |
| As a result, a person exposed to methanol can go into severe metabolic acidosis, which is when too much acid builds up in the body. | As a result, a person exposed to methanol can go into severe metabolic acidosis, which is when too much acid builds up in the body. |
| Methanol poisoning can cause nausea, vomiting and abdominal pain. The acidosis then causes depression of the central nervous system which can cause people with methanol poisoning to fall unconscious and go into a coma, as well as retinal damage leading to vision loss. This is because the retinas are full of active mitochondria and sensitive to them being damaged. | Methanol poisoning can cause nausea, vomiting and abdominal pain. The acidosis then causes depression of the central nervous system which can cause people with methanol poisoning to fall unconscious and go into a coma, as well as retinal damage leading to vision loss. This is because the retinas are full of active mitochondria and sensitive to them being damaged. |
| Death is not inevitable if only a small amount of methanol has been consumed and rapid treatment will greatly reduce damage. | Death is not inevitable if only a small amount of methanol has been consumed and rapid treatment will greatly reduce damage. |
| But permanent vision damage can occur even at non-lethal doses if treatment is not administered quickly. | But permanent vision damage can occur even at non-lethal doses if treatment is not administered quickly. |
| Sign up to Breaking News Australia | Sign up to Breaking News Australia |
| Get the most important news as it breaks | Get the most important news as it breaks |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| What does treatment involve? | What does treatment involve? |
| Treatment is mainly supportive care, such as intubation and mechanical ventilation to help the patient to breathe. | Treatment is mainly supportive care, such as intubation and mechanical ventilation to help the patient to breathe. |
| But it can also involve drugs including fomepizole (which inhibits the generation of toxic formic acid) and dialysis to remove methanol and its metabolites from the body. | But it can also involve drugs including fomepizole (which inhibits the generation of toxic formic acid) and dialysis to remove methanol and its metabolites from the body. |
| How does methanol get into alcoholic drinks? | How does methanol get into alcoholic drinks? |
| Methanol can turn up in any alcoholic beverage but it’s most likely found in drinks with higher alcohol content, such as spirits, and traditionally brewed drinks, such as fruit wines. | Methanol can turn up in any alcoholic beverage but it’s most likely found in drinks with higher alcohol content, such as spirits, and traditionally brewed drinks, such as fruit wines. |
| Methanol can get into alcoholic beverages in a number of ways. Sometimes it’s added deliberately and illegally during or after manufacturing as a cheaper way to increase the alcohol content in a drink. | Methanol can get into alcoholic beverages in a number of ways. Sometimes it’s added deliberately and illegally during or after manufacturing as a cheaper way to increase the alcohol content in a drink. |
| Traditional brewing methods can also inadvertently generate methanol as well as ethanol, and produce toxic levels of methanol depending on the microbes and the types of plant materials used in the fermentation process. | Traditional brewing methods can also inadvertently generate methanol as well as ethanol, and produce toxic levels of methanol depending on the microbes and the types of plant materials used in the fermentation process. |
| We don’t yet know how the Australian teenagers came to be poisoned in this tragedy. But it is a good idea when travelling (particularly in areas with traditionally fermented drinks, such as south-east Asia, the Indian subcontinent and parts of Africa) to always be careful. | We don’t yet know how the Australian teenagers came to be poisoned in this tragedy. But it is a good idea when travelling (particularly in areas with traditionally fermented drinks, such as south-east Asia, the Indian subcontinent and parts of Africa) to always be careful. |
| The Australian government’s Smartraveller website advises that to avoid methanol poisoning you should be careful drinking cocktails and drinks made with spirits, drink only at reputable licensed premises and avoid home-made alcoholic drinks. | The Australian government’s Smartraveller website advises that to avoid methanol poisoning you should be careful drinking cocktails and drinks made with spirits, drink only at reputable licensed premises and avoid home-made alcoholic drinks. |
| Drinking only mass-produced commercial brews can be safer, though understandably people often want to try locally made drinks as part of their adventure. | Drinking only mass-produced commercial brews can be safer, though understandably people often want to try locally made drinks as part of their adventure. |
| This article was originally published by the Conversation. Ian Musgrave is a senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of Adelaide | This article was originally published by the Conversation. Ian Musgrave is a senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of Adelaide |
| This article was originally published by the Conversation. Ian Musgrave is a senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of Adelaide | This article was originally published by the Conversation. Ian Musgrave is a senior lecturer in pharmacology at the University of Adelaide |