This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2024/nov/20/isla-bell-death-missing-melbourne-teen-brunswick-two-men-charged-ntwnfb

The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
‘I could not protect you’: mother pays tribute to Melbourne teenager Isla Bell after man charged with murder and remains found Final hours of missing Melbourne woman Isla Bell’s life captured by CCTV, police allege
(about 20 hours later)
Bell, 19, was last seen leaving her Brunswick home in October and remains yet to be formally identified have been found in Dandenong Nineteen-year-old last seen leaving her Brunswick home in October and remains yet to be formally identified have been found in Dandenong
A man accused of murdering missing teenager Isla Bell has appeared in court after human remains were found at a Melbourne rubbish tip. The final hours of missing teen Isla Bell’s life have been captured on CCTV in the Melbourne apartment building of her alleged killer, according to court documents.
St Kilda East man Marat Ganiev, 53, appeared in the Melbourne magistrates court on Wednesday charged with murder. The documents released by the court on Wednesday afternoon detail how the 19-year-old allegedly ended up at Marat Ganiev’s St Kilda East apartment on 7 October.
Bell, 19, was last seen leaving her home in Brunswick on 4 October. Bell was seen leaving her home in Brunswick on 4 October but family members have said she was active on social media until three days later.
Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news emailSign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email
Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news emailSign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email
Human remains, which are yet to be formally identified, were found at a waste management facility in Dandenong, in Melbourne’s outer east, on Tuesday evening. Ganiev, 53, appeared in Melbourne magistrates court on Wednesday charged with Bell’s murder.
Bell’s mother, Justine Spokes, paid tribute to her “beloved daughter” on Wednesday. Eyal Yaffe, 57, from Hampton, faced a charge of assisting an offender with murder.
“Cherished forever and suffering no more,” she told the Age. “I am so sorry I could not protect you.” Neither man was required to enter a plea to the charges, and the allegations against them are unproven.
Missing persons squad detectives raided homes in Bentleigh East and Mulgrave on Tuesday and arrested three men, including Ganiev. According to court documents, police allege that Ganiev told officers that he had moved Bell’s remains but denied killing her.
Ganiev is accused of murdering Bell in St Kilda East on 7 October, about three days after she was last seen, court documents show. Ganiev’s building was surrounded by a CCTV system that covered the front door and window of the apartment, according to a Victoria police summary. Bell was seen entering the apartment for the last time on 5 October and was never seen to leave again, according to police.
The court heard Ganiev had been prescribed methadone but his lawyer said he had not received the medication for two days. Two days later, police allege in court documents: “What appears to be a fight can be seen through a gap in the front kitchen window of Ganiev’s apartment.
Magistrate Justin Foster remanded Ganiev in custody and ordered he be seen by a prison nurse. “Investigators observed what appears to be Bell’s head whipping around as if she has been struck.
He will return to court in March. “She falls to the ground and Ganiev can then be seen striking her on the ground of the kitchen.
A 57-year-old Hampton man has been charged with helping the alleged murderer and will appear in court on Wednesday afternoon, while a 63-year-old Mulgrave man has been released pending further inquiries. “What appears to be Bell’s head can be seen rising up before being pushed back down by Ganiev’s arm.”
Bell was captured on CCTV through the same window up until 2am on 7 October, the documents said. During the next few days, Ganiev is shown allegedly cleaning the apartment.
According to the documents, A fridge wrapped in clear plastic and black tape was allegedly moved from the apartment in a trailer attached to a RAV4 by the two men and taken to Caulfield South, where it stayed until 22 October.
Sign up to Breaking News AustraliaSign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaksGet the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotionafter newsletter promotion
Police allege the fridge was used to store Bell’s body.
A neighbour reported the fridge to police because it was attracting flies and had a “foul smell”, the documents said. The trailer carrying the fridge was allegedly moved to a Bentleigh East property before being shifted to Mulgrave days later in a Hino removal van.
The police summary alleges that a resident discovered Bell’s remains on 18 November after he removed the plastic wrapping, the fridge door swung open and a bag fell out. He believed the bag contained animal remains and dumped the fridge on a street corner near hard rubbish in Bentleigh.
The man then placed the bag holding Bell’s remains in a residential rubbish bin before later contacting police, the court documents said.
Human remains, which are yet to be formally identified, were found at a waste management facility in Dandenong, in Melbourne’s outer east, on Tuesday evening, police have alleged.
Detectives raided homes in Bentleigh East and Mulgrave on Tuesday.
Bell’s family have been notified of the discovery and police say they will be provided support services.Bell’s family have been notified of the discovery and police say they will be provided support services.
Her mother had previously made emotional pleas for information about her daughter’s whereabouts. Her mother, Justine Spokes, had previously made emotional pleas for information about her whereabouts including at a press conference on 22 October, the day Bell would have turned 20.
“My girl is missing and dearly missed,” Spokes wrote on Facebook on 15 October.
“She leaves an impression, she’s hard to forget. She has a fighting spirit, sometimes it’s loud and sometimes it’s soft, always enduring.
“We’re here for you bub. I love you my care bear.”
There had been no activity on Bell’s bank or social media accounts and her phone had not pinged to any telecommunication towers.