This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/6359559.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Morgan climate remarks criticised | Morgan climate remarks criticised |
(10 minutes later) | |
There has been more criticism of Wales' First Minister Rhodri Morgan's claim climate change would not be "entirely unhelpful" if it meant warmer weather. | |
Mr Morgan's remarks in the Welsh assembly were condemned by opposition politicians as "utterly irresponsible". | Mr Morgan's remarks in the Welsh assembly were condemned by opposition politicians as "utterly irresponsible". |
Environmental group Friends of the Earth Cymru later said the comments were "dangerously complacent". | Environmental group Friends of the Earth Cymru later said the comments were "dangerously complacent". |
Reacting to the criticism, Mr Morgan's spokesperson said his remarks needed to be taken in context. | Reacting to the criticism, Mr Morgan's spokesperson said his remarks needed to be taken in context. |
Mr Morgan said in a speech on Monday night: "If our climate in Wales is going to be more like Spain's or southern California's in the summer, then Spain will be more like the Sahara. | Mr Morgan said in a speech on Monday night: "If our climate in Wales is going to be more like Spain's or southern California's in the summer, then Spain will be more like the Sahara. |
The point he was making is that Wales must act globally and not put self-interest first Rhodri Morgan's spokesperson | The point he was making is that Wales must act globally and not put self-interest first Rhodri Morgan's spokesperson |
"If that is the kind of climate shift we cannot avoid having by 2050, it will hardly be unhelpful to Wales." | "If that is the kind of climate shift we cannot avoid having by 2050, it will hardly be unhelpful to Wales." |
During weekly questions in the Senedd the following day, Mr Morgan said he was happy to repeat his comments. | During weekly questions in the Senedd the following day, Mr Morgan said he was happy to repeat his comments. |
"There is some climate change you can't stop, it's already built into the system and as well as curbing it we need to adapt to it," he said. | "There is some climate change you can't stop, it's already built into the system and as well as curbing it we need to adapt to it," he said. |
"If the north becomes hotter, it will not be entirely unhelpful." | "If the north becomes hotter, it will not be entirely unhelpful." |
His views were immediately condemned by Liberal Democrat Mike German, Plaid Cymru leader Ieuan Wyn Jones and Welsh Conservative leader Nick Bourne. | His views were immediately condemned by Liberal Democrat Mike German, Plaid Cymru leader Ieuan Wyn Jones and Welsh Conservative leader Nick Bourne. |
The criticisms were supported by Friends of the Earth's assembly campaigner, Gordon James, who said: "This is a dangerously complacent and irresponsible statement. | The criticisms were supported by Friends of the Earth's assembly campaigner, Gordon James, who said: "This is a dangerously complacent and irresponsible statement. |
"Although opportunities exist in areas such as clean energy developments, the environmental and economic threats posed by climate change significantly outweigh any benefits. | "Although opportunities exist in areas such as clean energy developments, the environmental and economic threats posed by climate change significantly outweigh any benefits. |
"The climate will become more unstable producing extremes of weather, such as flooding, droughts and storms, which will cause significant economic, social and environmental problems." | "The climate will become more unstable producing extremes of weather, such as flooding, droughts and storms, which will cause significant economic, social and environmental problems." |
Mr Morgan said Wales' climate could become like California's | Mr Morgan said Wales' climate could become like California's |
He added: "Our response to the severe threat posed by climate change is already far too little too late. | He added: "Our response to the severe threat posed by climate change is already far too little too late. |
"What we need now is strong political action - this sort of muddled thinking from the first minister shows a serious lack of leadership on the most important issue of the day." | "What we need now is strong political action - this sort of muddled thinking from the first minister shows a serious lack of leadership on the most important issue of the day." |
John Bunker, head of south Wales seaside resort Porthcawl's tourist association, said any benefits from warmer temperatures would be followed by potential drawbacks associated with global warming. | John Bunker, head of south Wales seaside resort Porthcawl's tourist association, said any benefits from warmer temperatures would be followed by potential drawbacks associated with global warming. |
He said: "As far as we are concerned, warmer temperatures wouldn't be a bad thing, but what would that do to the rest of the planet? | He said: "As far as we are concerned, warmer temperatures wouldn't be a bad thing, but what would that do to the rest of the planet? |
"We don't want the problems that come with global warming like storms and flooding." | "We don't want the problems that come with global warming like storms and flooding." |
He added: "Tourists come to Wales and the UK for the history, the scenery and culture rather than the weather and that will continue." | He added: "Tourists come to Wales and the UK for the history, the scenery and culture rather than the weather and that will continue." |
Reacting to the criticism of Mr Morgan's speech, the first minister's spokesperson said the comments "need to be read in the context of a speech on Wales's economic future". | Reacting to the criticism of Mr Morgan's speech, the first minister's spokesperson said the comments "need to be read in the context of a speech on Wales's economic future". |
The spokesperson added: "He did say that our climate would become similar to that of Spain or Southern California and that this would hardly be unhelpful to Wales in many ways. | The spokesperson added: "He did say that our climate would become similar to that of Spain or Southern California and that this would hardly be unhelpful to Wales in many ways. |
"But the point he was making is that Wales must act globally and not put self-interest first. | "But the point he was making is that Wales must act globally and not put self-interest first. |
"He was stressing that even if climate change has advantages for Wales it will be catastrophic for other parts of the world." | "He was stressing that even if climate change has advantages for Wales it will be catastrophic for other parts of the world." |
Previous version
1
Next version