This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . The next check for changes will be
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ckgn5xkp3rko
The article has changed 20 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 16 | Version 17 |
|---|---|
| Bowen: West left powerless as Israel claims its biggest victory yet against Hezbollah | Bowen: West left powerless as Israel claims its biggest victory yet against Hezbollah |
| (about 3 hours later) | |
| Published27 September 2024 | Published27 September 2024 |
| It is time to stop talking about the Middle East being on the brink of a much more serious war. After the devastating Israeli attack on Lebanon – which killed Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah – it feels as if they’re tumbling over it. | It is time to stop talking about the Middle East being on the brink of a much more serious war. After the devastating Israeli attack on Lebanon – which killed Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah – it feels as if they’re tumbling over it. |
| It was a huge series of blasts, according to people who were in Beirut. A friend of mine in the city said it was the most powerful she had heard in any of Lebanon’s wars. | It was a huge series of blasts, according to people who were in Beirut. A friend of mine in the city said it was the most powerful she had heard in any of Lebanon’s wars. |
| As rescue workers searched among the rubble, Hezbollah remained silent on the fate of their leader - before confirming his death on Saturday afternoon. | As rescue workers searched among the rubble, Hezbollah remained silent on the fate of their leader - before confirming his death on Saturday afternoon. |
| FOLLOW LIVE: Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah killed | FOLLOW LIVE: Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah killed |
| FOLLOW LIVE: Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah killed | FOLLOW LIVE: Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah killed |
| It will reinforce Israel's belief that this is their greatest triumph yet against their great enemy. | It will reinforce Israel's belief that this is their greatest triumph yet against their great enemy. |
| They have mobilised more soldiers, and seem to want to pick up the pace. They may even be thinking about a ground incursion into Lebanon. | They have mobilised more soldiers, and seem to want to pick up the pace. They may even be thinking about a ground incursion into Lebanon. |
| It is a massively escalatory action. Over the last eleven months there has been an ongoing tit-for-tat between both sides, though with more pressure from the Israelis. | It is a massively escalatory action. Over the last eleven months there has been an ongoing tit-for-tat between both sides, though with more pressure from the Israelis. |
| But now they have decided they are going to push. | But now they have decided they are going to push. |
| They will be delighted with what they have done because – unlike the war against Hamas, which they did not expect – they have been planning this war since 2006. They are now putting those plans into effect. | They will be delighted with what they have done because – unlike the war against Hamas, which they did not expect – they have been planning this war since 2006. They are now putting those plans into effect. |
| There are now huge challenges for Hezbollah. | There are now huge challenges for Hezbollah. |
| Their rockets landed again in Israeli territory on Saturday morning, targeting areas further south, so they are pushing back, but this is an uncertain period. | Their rockets landed again in Israeli territory on Saturday morning, targeting areas further south, so they are pushing back, but this is an uncertain period. |
| That uncertainty is part of the danger. The predictability of the war of attrition that went on for months and months meant people knew where they were - they absolutely do not now. | That uncertainty is part of the danger. The predictability of the war of attrition that went on for months and months meant people knew where they were - they absolutely do not now. |
| Watch: BBC correspondent records moment air strike hits Beirut | Watch: BBC correspondent records moment air strike hits Beirut |
| Watch: BBC correspondent records moment air strike hits Beirut | Watch: BBC correspondent records moment air strike hits Beirut |
| Earlier on Friday there had been hopes, admittedly faint ones, that Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was at least prepared to discuss a proposal for a 21-day ceasefire. It came from the US and France and was backed by Israel’s most significant Western allies. | Earlier on Friday there had been hopes, admittedly faint ones, that Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was at least prepared to discuss a proposal for a 21-day ceasefire. It came from the US and France and was backed by Israel’s most significant Western allies. |
| But in a typically defiant and at times aggressive speech to the UN General Assembly in New York, Netanyahu did not talk about diplomacy. | But in a typically defiant and at times aggressive speech to the UN General Assembly in New York, Netanyahu did not talk about diplomacy. |
| Israel, he said, had no choice but to fight savage enemies who sought its annihilation. Hezbollah would be defeated – and there would be total victory over Hamas in Gaza, which would ensure the return of Israeli hostages. | Israel, he said, had no choice but to fight savage enemies who sought its annihilation. Hezbollah would be defeated – and there would be total victory over Hamas in Gaza, which would ensure the return of Israeli hostages. |
| Far from being lambs led to the slaughter – a phrase sometimes used in Israel to refer to the Nazi Holocaust – Israel, he said, was winning. | Far from being lambs led to the slaughter – a phrase sometimes used in Israel to refer to the Nazi Holocaust – Israel, he said, was winning. |
| Explained: What is Hezbollah and why is Israel attacking Lebanon? | Explained: What is Hezbollah and why is Israel attacking Lebanon? |
| Explained: What is Hezbollah and why is Israel attacking Lebanon? | Explained: What is Hezbollah and why is Israel attacking Lebanon? |
| Watch: Hezbollah rockets hit residential areas in Israel | Watch: Hezbollah rockets hit residential areas in Israel |
| Watch: Hezbollah rockets hit residential areas in Israel | Watch: Hezbollah rockets hit residential areas in Israel |
| Analysis: Israel is gambling Hezbollah will crumple but it faces a well-armed, angry enemy | Analysis: Israel is gambling Hezbollah will crumple but it faces a well-armed, angry enemy |
| Analysis: Israel is gambling Hezbollah will crumple but it faces a well-armed, angry enemy | Analysis: Israel is gambling Hezbollah will crumple but it faces a well-armed, angry enemy |
| The huge attack in Beirut that occurred as he finished his speech was an even more emphatic sign that a truce in Lebanon was not on Israel’s agenda. | The huge attack in Beirut that occurred as he finished his speech was an even more emphatic sign that a truce in Lebanon was not on Israel’s agenda. |
| It seemed more than feasible that the attack was timed to follow up Mr Netanyahu’s threats that Israel could, and would, hit its enemies, wherever they were. | It seemed more than feasible that the attack was timed to follow up Mr Netanyahu’s threats that Israel could, and would, hit its enemies, wherever they were. |
| The Pentagon, the US defence department, said it had no advance warning from Israel about the raid. | The Pentagon, the US defence department, said it had no advance warning from Israel about the raid. |
| A photo released by the prime minister’s office in Jerusalem showed him at a bank of communications equipment in what looked like his hotel in New York City. The image’s caption said it showed the moment that he authorised the raid. | A photo released by the prime minister’s office in Jerusalem showed him at a bank of communications equipment in what looked like his hotel in New York City. The image’s caption said it showed the moment that he authorised the raid. |
| Netanyahu reportedly authorised the airstrike from his hotel room in New York | Netanyahu reportedly authorised the airstrike from his hotel room in New York |
| Netanyahu reportedly authorised the airstrike from his hotel room in New York | Netanyahu reportedly authorised the airstrike from his hotel room in New York |
| US Secretary of State Antony Blinken defended the policy he has worked on for months. He said there was still room for negotiation. That assertion is looking hollow. | US Secretary of State Antony Blinken defended the policy he has worked on for months. He said there was still room for negotiation. That assertion is looking hollow. |
| The Americans have very few levers to use against any side. They cannot, by law, talk to Hezbollah and Hamas as they are classified as foreign terrorist organisations. With the US elections only weeks away, they are even less likely to put pressure on Israel than they have been in the last year. | The Americans have very few levers to use against any side. They cannot, by law, talk to Hezbollah and Hamas as they are classified as foreign terrorist organisations. With the US elections only weeks away, they are even less likely to put pressure on Israel than they have been in the last year. |
| Powerful voices in the Israeli government and military wanted to attack Hezbollah in the days after the Hamas attacks last October. They argued that they could deal their enemies in Lebanon a decisive blow. The Americans persuaded them not to do it, arguing that the trouble it might set off across the region offset any potential security benefit for Israel. | Powerful voices in the Israeli government and military wanted to attack Hezbollah in the days after the Hamas attacks last October. They argued that they could deal their enemies in Lebanon a decisive blow. The Americans persuaded them not to do it, arguing that the trouble it might set off across the region offset any potential security benefit for Israel. |
| But in the course of the last year Netanyahu has made a habit of defying President Joe Biden’s wishes about the way Israel is fighting. Despite providing Israel with the aircraft and bombs used in the raid on Beirut, President Biden and team were spectators. | But in the course of the last year Netanyahu has made a habit of defying President Joe Biden’s wishes about the way Israel is fighting. Despite providing Israel with the aircraft and bombs used in the raid on Beirut, President Biden and team were spectators. |
| Workers dig through the debris for survivors following strikes on Friday | Workers dig through the debris for survivors following strikes on Friday |
| Workers dig through the debris for survivors following strikes on Friday | Workers dig through the debris for survivors following strikes on Friday |
| His policy for the last year, as a lifelong supporter of Israel, was to try to influence Netanyahu by showing solidarity and support, delivering weapons and diplomatic protection. | His policy for the last year, as a lifelong supporter of Israel, was to try to influence Netanyahu by showing solidarity and support, delivering weapons and diplomatic protection. |
| Biden believed that he could persuade Netanyahu not just to change the way Israel fights – the president has said repeatedly that it is imposing too much suffering and killing too many Palestinian civilians – but to accept an American plan for the day after that rested on creating an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel. | Biden believed that he could persuade Netanyahu not just to change the way Israel fights – the president has said repeatedly that it is imposing too much suffering and killing too many Palestinian civilians – but to accept an American plan for the day after that rested on creating an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel. |
| Netanyahu rejected the idea out of hand and has ignored Joe Biden’s advice. | Netanyahu rejected the idea out of hand and has ignored Joe Biden’s advice. |
| After the attack on Beirut, Blinken repeated his view that a combination of deterrence and diplomacy had staved off a wider war in the Middle East. But as events spiral out of US control, he is not sounding convincing. | After the attack on Beirut, Blinken repeated his view that a combination of deterrence and diplomacy had staved off a wider war in the Middle East. But as events spiral out of US control, he is not sounding convincing. |
| Big decisions lie ahead. | Big decisions lie ahead. |
| First of all, Hezbollah is going to have to decide how to use its remaining arsenal. Do they try to mount a much heavier attack on Israel? If they don’t use their remaining rockets and missiles in storage, they might decide Israel will get around to destroying even more of them. | First of all, Hezbollah is going to have to decide how to use its remaining arsenal. Do they try to mount a much heavier attack on Israel? If they don’t use their remaining rockets and missiles in storage, they might decide Israel will get around to destroying even more of them. |
| The Israelis also face highly consequential decisions. They have already talked about a ground operation against Lebanon, and while they haven’t yet mobilised all the reserves they might need, their military said on Saturday that they were “ready for a wider escalation”. | The Israelis also face highly consequential decisions. They have already talked about a ground operation against Lebanon, and while they haven’t yet mobilised all the reserves they might need, their military said on Saturday that they were “ready for a wider escalation”. |
| Some in Lebanon believe that in a ground war Hezbollah could negate some of Israel’s military strengths. | Some in Lebanon believe that in a ground war Hezbollah could negate some of Israel’s military strengths. |
| Western diplomats, among them Israel’s staunchest allies, were hoping to calm matters, urging Israel to accept a diplomatic solution. They will now be looking at events with dismay and also a sense of powerlessness. | Western diplomats, among them Israel’s staunchest allies, were hoping to calm matters, urging Israel to accept a diplomatic solution. They will now be looking at events with dismay and also a sense of powerlessness. |
| Get in touch | |
| Are you trying to leave Lebanon? If it is safe to do so, get in touch. | |
| Related topics | Related topics |
| Israel-Gaza war | Israel-Gaza war |
| Hezbollah | Hezbollah |
| Lebanon | Lebanon |