This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6340101.stm
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Goldsmith in legal advice pledge | Goldsmith in legal advice pledge |
| (about 19 hours later) | |
| The Attorney General has said he will publish all his legal advice about the cash-for-honours inquiry, but only if there are no prosecutions. | The Attorney General has said he will publish all his legal advice about the cash-for-honours inquiry, but only if there are no prosecutions. |
| "That will mean the public will know openly, it will be transparent what the reasons are and why," Lord Goldsmith said of the independent advice. | "That will mean the public will know openly, it will be transparent what the reasons are and why," Lord Goldsmith said of the independent advice. |
| He has already said he would give an explanation of the legal advice. | He has already said he would give an explanation of the legal advice. |
| Police are investigating allegations that donations were given to political parties in exchange for peerages. | Police are investigating allegations that donations were given to political parties in exchange for peerages. |
| Four people have been arrested during the inquiry, but the first person to be detained, head teacher Des Smith, will not face charges after the Crown Prosecution Service said there was insufficient evidence for a prosecution. | Four people have been arrested during the inquiry, but the first person to be detained, head teacher Des Smith, will not face charges after the Crown Prosecution Service said there was insufficient evidence for a prosecution. |
| All those arrested deny any wrongdoing. | All those arrested deny any wrongdoing. |
| Ministerial criticisms | Ministerial criticisms |
| Lord Goldsmith, appearing before the constitutional affairs committee, said: "If a question is referred to me ... then I will - my office will - appoint independent legal counsel to advise. | Lord Goldsmith, appearing before the constitutional affairs committee, said: "If a question is referred to me ... then I will - my office will - appoint independent legal counsel to advise. |
| "And ... in the event that there isn't a prosecution, I will make public that advice." | "And ... in the event that there isn't a prosecution, I will make public that advice." |
| During his session in front of the committee, he also hit back at criticisms by ministerial colleagues about his role. | During his session in front of the committee, he also hit back at criticisms by ministerial colleagues about his role. |
| He told MPs he "did not agree" with Constitutional Affairs Minister Harriet Harman's call for his legal advice to be routinely published. | He told MPs he "did not agree" with Constitutional Affairs Minister Harriet Harman's call for his legal advice to be routinely published. |
| My duty is to the law, not to party politics or party loyalties Lord Goldsmith | My duty is to the law, not to party politics or party loyalties Lord Goldsmith |
| He said the decision should be "up to the prime minister of the day". | He said the decision should be "up to the prime minister of the day". |
| He also rejected a suggestion that the attorney general should no longer have a Cabinet role, saying it was vital for "accountability". | |
| Lord Goldsmith has come under pressure to publish his advice on the legality of the Iraq war and the decision to drop a fraud inquiry into a BAE arms deal with Saudi Arabia. | Lord Goldsmith has come under pressure to publish his advice on the legality of the Iraq war and the decision to drop a fraud inquiry into a BAE arms deal with Saudi Arabia. |
| He insisted there was no contradiction between his role as a member of the Labour government and an impartial law officer. | He insisted there was no contradiction between his role as a member of the Labour government and an impartial law officer. |
| 'Accountable' politician | 'Accountable' politician |
| He said there were occasions when he had to make decisions which were not covered by "collective Cabinet responsibility". | He said there were occasions when he had to make decisions which were not covered by "collective Cabinet responsibility". |
| He said he had taken decisions which colleagues had not agreed with and added: "My duty is to the law, not to party politics or party loyalties". | He said he had taken decisions which colleagues had not agreed with and added: "My duty is to the law, not to party politics or party loyalties". |
| But it was important that the attorney general remained a politician and not "some civil servant" so that he or she would be "accountable" to Parliament and be able to be cross-examined by MPs, he added. | |
| He also hit back at claims public confidence in his role had been damaged by criticism over legal advice in the run up to the Iraq war, the cash-for-honours inquiry and the BAE systems row. | He also hit back at claims public confidence in his role had been damaged by criticism over legal advice in the run up to the Iraq war, the cash-for-honours inquiry and the BAE systems row. |
| National test | National test |
| On BAE Systems, he insisted the decision to drop the inquiry had been taken by the director of the Serious Fraud Office, who had been told the investigation would harm national security. | On BAE Systems, he insisted the decision to drop the inquiry had been taken by the director of the Serious Fraud Office, who had been told the investigation would harm national security. |
| Lord Goldsmith said he had reached the same conclusion after carrying out a national interest test. | Lord Goldsmith said he had reached the same conclusion after carrying out a national interest test. |
| But he also revealed a national interest test carried out a year earlier had focused on whether BAE would lose contracts if the investigation continued. | But he also revealed a national interest test carried out a year earlier had focused on whether BAE would lose contracts if the investigation continued. |
| It had ruled the investigation could not be dropped on those grounds without breaking the terms of an anti-corruption treaty Britain had signed up to. | It had ruled the investigation could not be dropped on those grounds without breaking the terms of an anti-corruption treaty Britain had signed up to. |
| Lord Goldsmith confirmed International Development Secretary Hilary Benn had not been among the ministers consulted on the decision to drop the inquiry. | Lord Goldsmith confirmed International Development Secretary Hilary Benn had not been among the ministers consulted on the decision to drop the inquiry. |
| Harman's criticism | Harman's criticism |
| "He could have told us that we have a commitment to fight corruption, but I know that and I know there was public interest in it," Lord Goldsmith said. | "He could have told us that we have a commitment to fight corruption, but I know that and I know there was public interest in it," Lord Goldsmith said. |
| Harriet Harman, who is also campaigning to become Labour's deputy leader, called last week in a speech for "greater transparency'' from Lord Goldsmith and future holders of the office. | |
| "It is not enough for government ministers to say: 'We are advised that it is lawful,''' she said. | "It is not enough for government ministers to say: 'We are advised that it is lawful,''' she said. |
| "Backbenchers, let alone the wider public, want to see for themselves what the arguments are.'' | "Backbenchers, let alone the wider public, want to see for themselves what the arguments are.'' |