This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/6333713.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Labour MPs split on Lords reform | |
(about 13 hours later) | |
Commons leader Jack Straw's Lords reform proposals have met with a mixed response from Labour MPs and peers. | |
Labour Party sources said speakers at a meeting to debate the plans had been "60/40" in favour of Mr Straw's ideas. | |
But some Labour MPs were also reported to be planning to revive a campaign for a mainly elected second chamber. | |
Mr Straw, who favours a 50/50 split between elected and appointed peers, will set out his proposals in a White Paper to be published on Wednesday. | |
It will set out seven options for reform and there will be a Commons vote on the exact proportion of peers to be elected, with the options ranging from none to all being elected. | |
Labour backbenchers and peers were reported to have expressed a "vast range of views" about the White Paper at a meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party on Monday night. | |
It is understood there was particular discussion of Mr Straw's plans to have a preliminary vote on options for the proportion of elected Lords. | It is understood there was particular discussion of Mr Straw's plans to have a preliminary vote on options for the proportion of elected Lords. |
Voting options | Voting options |
Under the current plan, MPs will vote first - in the Commons chamber - on whether they want any kind of upper house at all and then whether the current House of Lords should be reformed. | Under the current plan, MPs will vote first - in the Commons chamber - on whether they want any kind of upper house at all and then whether the current House of Lords should be reformed. |
MPs will then, in an unusual move, vote on seven options for reform: all elected; 80% elected, 20% appointed; 60% elected, 40% appointed; half and half; 40% elected, 60% appointed; 20% elected, 80% appointed; and all appointed. | MPs will then, in an unusual move, vote on seven options for reform: all elected; 80% elected, 20% appointed; 60% elected, 40% appointed; half and half; 40% elected, 60% appointed; 20% elected, 80% appointed; and all appointed. |
Instead of voting in the division lobbies, MPs will indicate their preferences in order on a ballot paper. | Instead of voting in the division lobbies, MPs will indicate their preferences in order on a ballot paper. |
Under this alternative vote system, the least popular option will be knocked out and its second preferences redistributed until one option achieves a majority. | Under this alternative vote system, the least popular option will be knocked out and its second preferences redistributed until one option achieves a majority. |
Some Labour MPs are planning to campaign for a mainly elected House of Lords, to encourage MPs to vote for any option which would mean that over 50% of the upper house would be elected. | |
At Monday's meeting, the veteran Labour backbencher Dennis Skinner also warned candidates for the Labour party deputy leadership against discussing the cash-for-honours investigation in public. | At Monday's meeting, the veteran Labour backbencher Dennis Skinner also warned candidates for the Labour party deputy leadership against discussing the cash-for-honours investigation in public. |
Mr Skinner was heard to tell the meeting that contenders should "keep your traps shut and remember Scotland and Wales", referring to May's local elections. | Mr Skinner was heard to tell the meeting that contenders should "keep your traps shut and remember Scotland and Wales", referring to May's local elections. |
There are concerns in the Labour Party that the cash-for-honours investigation could affect Labour's fortunes in the local elections. |
Previous version
1
Next version