'What Russia Got Wrong' diff viewer (0/1)

This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on December 18, 2022 13:30 (UTC). It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/18/briefing/russia-putin-ukraine-war.html

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Previous version 1 Next version

Previous version 1 Next version

Version 0	Version 1
What Russia Got Wrong	What Russia Got Wrong
2022-12-20 00:58:50 UTC	2022-12-21 21:00:28 UTC (2 days later)
Nearly 10 months into its invasion of Ukraine, Russia has suffered great losses. Its military has faltered against a foe that, before the war, appeared much weaker. A team of Times journalists published an account this weekend of how Russia so badly mismanaged its invasion, based on interviews, intercepted phone calls, documents and secret battle plans. At the center of it is Vladimir Putin, Russia’s president, who has been in power for more than two decades.	Nearly 10 months into its invasion of Ukraine, Russia has suffered great losses. Its military has faltered against a foe that, before the war, appeared much weaker. A team of Times journalists published an account this weekend of how Russia so badly mismanaged its invasion, based on interviews, intercepted phone calls, documents and secret battle plans. At the center of it is Vladimir Putin, Russia’s president, who has been in power for more than two decades.
I spoke to Anton Troianovski, the Moscow bureau chief and one of the lead reporters on the story, about how Putin came to decide to go to war.	I spoke to Anton Troianovski, the Moscow bureau chief and one of the lead reporters on the story, about how Putin came to decide to go to war.
Claire: When Russia invaded Ukraine in February, experts believed that Russia would quickly conquer Ukraine. That didn’t happen. What is the main reason that the war went so badly for Russia?	Claire: When Russia invaded Ukraine in February, experts believed that Russia would quickly conquer Ukraine. That didn’t happen. What is the main reason that the war went so badly for Russia?
Anton: It was a cascade of failures, and at the top is Putin’s own misguidedness, his own isolation and his own conviction that he knew what was best. The Russian military was unprepared all the way down to a tactical level, like using Soviet-era maps. Like using their cellphones to call home, which gave away their positions and allowed them to be ambushed or attacked. There wasn’t enough food to feed the soldiers.	Anton: It was a cascade of failures, and at the top is Putin’s own misguidedness, his own isolation and his own conviction that he knew what was best. The Russian military was unprepared all the way down to a tactical level, like using Soviet-era maps. Like using their cellphones to call home, which gave away their positions and allowed them to be ambushed or attacked. There wasn’t enough food to feed the soldiers.
We got hold of actual copies of some of the invasion plans that some of the Russian military units had, which showed them expecting to race toward Kyiv within hours of invading. Russian military leaders didn’t think they’d need any reinforcements.	We got hold of actual copies of some of the invasion plans that some of the Russian military units had, which showed them expecting to race toward Kyiv within hours of invading. Russian military leaders didn’t think they’d need any reinforcements.
I talked to many people who knew Putin personally, and they told me that the decision to go to war was based on his gut feeling. Putin didn’t seem to think he needed advice on the wisdom of this invasion. Putin was convinced that he knew best, that he understood Ukraine and its place in history as well as his own.	I talked to many people who knew Putin personally, and they told me that the decision to go to war was based on his gut feeling. Putin didn’t seem to think he needed advice on the wisdom of this invasion. Putin was convinced that he knew best, that he understood Ukraine and its place in history as well as his own.
You report in the story that, partly because of the pandemic, Putin didn’t meet face to face with a Western leader for more than a year. How did that affect his decision to go to war?	You report in the story that, partly because of the pandemic, Putin didn’t meet face to face with a Western leader for more than a year. How did that affect his decision to go to war?
We don’t have perfect insight into what’s going on inside Putin’s inner circle; it’s still one of the world’s most secretive ruling establishments. But everyone I talked to said they didn’t believe that Putin had a single meeting before the invasion where people talked openly about the wisdom of going to war. Putin doesn’t like group discussions, he likes one-on-one discussions.	We don’t have perfect insight into what’s going on inside Putin’s inner circle; it’s still one of the world’s most secretive ruling establishments. But everyone I talked to said they didn’t believe that Putin had a single meeting before the invasion where people talked openly about the wisdom of going to war. Putin doesn’t like group discussions, he likes one-on-one discussions.
One person I spoke to compared it to a social media algorithm. Putin’s aides and friends would see what got a rise out of him emotionally, and they’d bring him information that further intensified his views.	One person I spoke to compared it to a social media algorithm. Putin’s aides and friends would see what got a rise out of him emotionally, and they’d bring him information that further intensified his views.
Why were the predictions about the war so wrong?	Why were the predictions about the war so wrong?
It’s because this war was something that nobody could really imagine. It wasn’t just Putin who miscalculated. The Russian elite largely thought there’d be no way that Putin would actually go to war. Many Ukrainians also didn’t think Putin was actually going to invade, nor did the Europeans. The U.S. did expect Russia to invade, but thought it could win in days. The war was so different from anything that has happened in recent decades that it was impossible to make informed predictions.	It’s because this war was something that nobody could really imagine. It wasn’t just Putin who miscalculated. The Russian elite largely thought there’d be no way that Putin would actually go to war. Many Ukrainians also didn’t think Putin was actually going to invade, nor did the Europeans. The U.S. did expect Russia to invade, but thought it could win in days. The war was so different from anything that has happened in recent decades that it was impossible to make informed predictions.
There was a ton of miscalculation from all sides. Putin also didn’t expect the West to unite behind Ukraine the way it did, nor does he appear to have expected Europe to reorient away from Russian fossil fuels so quickly.	There was a ton of miscalculation from all sides. Putin also didn’t expect the West to unite behind Ukraine the way it did, nor does he appear to have expected Europe to reorient away from Russian fossil fuels so quickly.
We’ve talked a lot about what went wrong for Russia, and of course the war isn’t over. Is there anything that is going well?	We’ve talked a lot about what went wrong for Russia, and of course the war isn’t over. Is there anything that is going well?
Putin recognizes that things haven’t gone to plan, but that doesn’t mean he’s going to fold. He is willing to accept a lot of casualties — up to 300,000, according to what one NATO member is now telling allies. The way Putin looks at it is that the Soviet Union lost 27 million people in World War II, and he’s convinced that the Russian people are prepared to suffer — more than people in the West.	Putin recognizes that things haven’t gone to plan, but that doesn’t mean he’s going to fold. He is willing to accept a lot of casualties — up to 300,000, according to what one NATO member is now telling allies. The way Putin looks at it is that the Soviet Union lost 27 million people in World War II, and he’s convinced that the Russian people are prepared to suffer — more than people in the West.
Something else that has gone well from the Kremlin’s point of view is the country’s propaganda machine. It helped convince many Russians that the war was not going disastrously wrong, and that it was the West that was forcing Russia to fight. In addition, sanctions haven’t derailed the Russian economy the way the West had hoped, and much of the world hasn’t turned its back on Russia ~~they~~ way some expected.	Something else that has gone well from the Kremlin’s point of view is the country’s propaganda machine. It helped convince many Russians that the war was not going disastrously wrong, and that it was the West that was forcing Russia to fight. In addition, sanctions haven’t derailed the Russian economy the way the West had hoped, and much of the world hasn’t turned its back on Russia the way some expected.
Telling the inside history of an ongoing war is an ambitious goal. How did you all pursue this story?	Telling the inside history of an ongoing war is an ambitious goal. How did you all pursue this story?
It was a very intense reporting effort. I was trying to get beyond what we already know about Putin and get to some of the nuances surrounding him and his decision to go to war. It is really hard, because it’s something that so few people know for sure. It took a long time and a lot of conversations.	It was a very intense reporting effort. I was trying to get beyond what we already know about Putin and get to some of the nuances surrounding him and his decision to go to war. It is really hard, because it’s something that so few people know for sure. It took a long time and a lot of conversations.
I spoke on the record to two rich Russians, one who turned against Putin and another who didn’t. It was fascinating to see how people made their decisions. There were a good amount of people who were willing to speak publicly. Often these people were prepared to talk because they want their side of the story out there.	I spoke on the record to two rich Russians, one who turned against Putin and another who didn’t. It was fascinating to see how people made their decisions. There were a good amount of people who were willing to speak publicly. Often these people were prepared to talk because they want their side of the story out there.
Anton Troianovski is The Times’s Moscow bureau chief. His first journalism job was as a photographer with local papers in the St. Louis area, where he grew up, and he first reported in Russia as an intern for The Associated Press in 2006.	Anton Troianovski is The Times’s Moscow bureau chief. His first journalism job was as a photographer with local papers in the St. Louis area, where he grew up, and he first reported in Russia as an intern for The Associated Press in 2006.
Russian soldiers entered battle relying on Wikipedia instructions for their weapons. Read the inside story of Russia’s historic military failures.	Russian soldiers entered battle relying on Wikipedia instructions for their weapons. Read the inside story of Russia’s historic military failures.
Putin made a rare visit to his war headquarters and signaled a shift to more active involvement.	Putin made a rare visit to his war headquarters and signaled a shift to more active involvement.
Congress is on track to expand the U.S. military budget in response to the war and other threats, setting up a boom for weapons makers.	Congress is on track to expand the U.S. military budget in response to the war and other threats, setting up a boom for weapons makers.
Federal prosecutors are seeking information about political donations made by Sam Bankman-Fried and other FTX executives.	Federal prosecutors are seeking information about political donations made by Sam Bankman-Fried and other FTX executives.
Bankman-Fried, in jail in the Bahamas, is expected to agree to extradition to the U.S.	Bankman-Fried, in jail in the Bahamas, is expected to agree to extradition to the U.S.
A social media dispute escalated into a shootout in Atlanta, killing two teenagers and wounding three other young people.	A social media dispute escalated into a shootout in Atlanta, killing two teenagers and wounding three other young people.
The T.S.A. intercepted a record number of guns at airport security checkpoints this year.	The T.S.A. intercepted a record number of guns at airport security checkpoints this year.
A snowstorm knocked out power for more than 140,000 customers in New England and upstate New York.	A snowstorm knocked out power for more than 140,000 customers in New England and upstate New York.
The Vatican removed an anti-abortion leader from the priesthood.	The Vatican removed an anti-abortion leader from the priesthood.
Some child care chains are charging over $40,000 a year and profiting during a shortage.	Some child care chains are charging over $40,000 a year and profiting during a shortage.
P-22, the celebrity mountain lion in Los Angeles, was euthanized.	P-22, the celebrity mountain lion in Los Angeles, was euthanized.
The Minnesota Vikings beat the Indianapolis Colts, 39-36, in the biggest comeback in N.F.L. history.	The Minnesota Vikings beat the Indianapolis Colts, 39-36, in the biggest comeback in N.F.L. history.
Cecily Strong made her last appearance on “Saturday Night Live.”	Cecily Strong made her last appearance on “Saturday Night Live.”
The championship match: Argentina faces France at 10 a.m. Eastern. Each country is trying to win its third World Cup.	The championship match: Argentina faces France at 10 a.m. Eastern. Each country is trying to win its third World Cup.
Lionel Messi: A win for Argentina could help smooth a complicated relationship between the star and his homeland.	Lionel Messi: A win for Argentina could help smooth a complicated relationship between the star and his homeland.
Competing stars: France’s Kylian Mbappé is ready to make Messi’s moment his own.	Competing stars: France’s Kylian Mbappé is ready to make Messi’s moment his own.
A magic game: Hundreds of witches are casting spells for an Argentine victory.	A magic game: Hundreds of witches are casting spells for an Argentine victory.
“It physically hurts to talk about it”: Caroline Edwards, a Capitol Police officer, explains why there’s nothing final about Congress’s final report on the Jan. 6 attacks.	“It physically hurts to talk about it”: Caroline Edwards, a Capitol Police officer, explains why there’s nothing final about Congress’s final report on the Jan. 6 attacks.
Regulators shouldn’t let celebrities like Matt Damon and Steph Curry off the hook for hawking bad cryptocurrency businesses, says John Reed Stark.	Regulators shouldn’t let celebrities like Matt Damon and Steph Curry off the hook for hawking bad cryptocurrency businesses, says John Reed Stark.