This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-63573387
The article has changed 10 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| Kherson: Russia to withdraw troops from key Ukrainian city | Kherson: Russia to withdraw troops from key Ukrainian city |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Gen Surovikin (L) said the withdrawal, ordered by the defence minister (R) was a difficult decision | Gen Surovikin (L) said the withdrawal, ordered by the defence minister (R) was a difficult decision |
| Russia's military has been ordered to pull out of the Ukrainian city of Kherson, the only regional capital it captured after invading in February. | Russia's military has been ordered to pull out of the Ukrainian city of Kherson, the only regional capital it captured after invading in February. |
| Russia's commander in Ukraine, Gen Sergei Surovikin, said it was no longer possible to keep supplying the city. | Russia's commander in Ukraine, Gen Sergei Surovikin, said it was no longer possible to keep supplying the city. |
| The withdrawal means Russian forces will pull out entirely from the western bank of the River Dnipro. | The withdrawal means Russian forces will pull out entirely from the western bank of the River Dnipro. |
| It is a significant blow as Russia faces a Ukrainian counter-offensive. | It is a significant blow as Russia faces a Ukrainian counter-offensive. |
| The military's top brass were seen making the decision on Russian state TV, with Gen Surovikin reporting on the situation on the ground in Kherson. | The military's top brass were seen making the decision on Russian state TV, with Gen Surovikin reporting on the situation on the ground in Kherson. |
| President Vladimir Putin did not take part in the staged event. The architect of Russia's failing war in Ukraine appeared to have left the announcement to his generals. | President Vladimir Putin did not take part in the staged event. The architect of Russia's failing war in Ukraine appeared to have left the announcement to his generals. |
| It was Mr Putin who announced Russia's annexation of Kherson, and three other occupied regions, at the end of September. | It was Mr Putin who announced Russia's annexation of Kherson, and three other occupied regions, at the end of September. |
| "In these circumstances, the most sensible option is to organise the defence along a barrier line along the river Dnipro," Gen Surovikin told the meeting. | "In these circumstances, the most sensible option is to organise the defence along a barrier line along the river Dnipro," Gen Surovikin told the meeting. |
| Nato secretary general Jens Stoltenberg said it was "encouraging" to see Ukraine making advances. | |
| "The gains the Ukrainian armed forces are making belong to the brave, courageous Ukrainian soldiers, but of course the support they receive from the United Kingdom, from Nato allies and partners is also essential," he said. | |
| Vladimir Putin celebrated his annexation of occupied regions but his forces were already on the back foot in Kherson | Vladimir Putin celebrated his annexation of occupied regions but his forces were already on the back foot in Kherson |
| Russian troops swept across southern Ukraine from annexed Crimea at the start of the war, seizing Kherson city in early March. | |
| They also launched attacks in the south, east and north of the country, including surrounding the capital, Kyiv. In recent months, however, Ukraine's forces have made significant advances, particularly in the east. | |
| This counter-offensive escalated in September, when Ukraine drove back Russian forces, retaking the cities of Izyum and Kupiansk, both key supply hubs for Moscow's forces. Since then, Russia has mainly focused its military operations in smaller pockets of Ukraine's south, east and north-east. | |
| But its decision to pull back across the Dnipro river was treated with caution by Ukrainian officials. | |
| "Actions speak louder than words," said presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak. | "Actions speak louder than words," said presidential adviser Mykhailo Podolyak. |
| "We see no signs that Russia is leaving Kherson without a fight... [Ukraine] is liberating territories based on intelligence data, not staged TV statements." | "We see no signs that Russia is leaving Kherson without a fight... [Ukraine] is liberating territories based on intelligence data, not staged TV statements." |
| Pro-Kremlin war bloggers were less cautious, with one known as War Gonzo condemning the retreat as a "black page in the history of the Russian army". | Pro-Kremlin war bloggers were less cautious, with one known as War Gonzo condemning the retreat as a "black page in the history of the Russian army". |
| There is no way for Moscow to depict this withdrawal as anything other than a humiliating setback - its biggest loss since Ukraine recaptured large areas around the city of Kharkiv in the early autumn. | There is no way for Moscow to depict this withdrawal as anything other than a humiliating setback - its biggest loss since Ukraine recaptured large areas around the city of Kharkiv in the early autumn. |
| And it further undermines Russia's announcement that it was illegally annexing Ukrainian provinces, including Kherson, which it said would remain Russian territory "forever". | And it further undermines Russia's announcement that it was illegally annexing Ukrainian provinces, including Kherson, which it said would remain Russian territory "forever". |
| But, as Mr Podolyak warned, there are several reasons for Ukraine to be cautious. | But, as Mr Podolyak warned, there are several reasons for Ukraine to be cautious. |
| The first is that retreating Russian forces will most likely have left behind mines and booby traps for the advancing Ukrainians. | The first is that retreating Russian forces will most likely have left behind mines and booby traps for the advancing Ukrainians. |
| The second is that Russia, having withdrawn its troops to the east bank - and having "evacuated", sometimes by force, large numbers of civilians - will now be tempted to bombard Kherson at will. | The second is that Russia, having withdrawn its troops to the east bank - and having "evacuated", sometimes by force, large numbers of civilians - will now be tempted to bombard Kherson at will. |
| Finally, the pattern emerging in this war is that every time Russia suffers a major military setback it responds by further punishing the civilian population. | Finally, the pattern emerging in this war is that every time Russia suffers a major military setback it responds by further punishing the civilian population. |
| Expect more missile and drone strikes to make winter for Ukrainians as miserable as possible. | Expect more missile and drone strikes to make winter for Ukrainians as miserable as possible. |
| Watch: Ros Atkins asks Jeremy Bowen about reporting from Ukraine's frontline | Watch: Ros Atkins asks Jeremy Bowen about reporting from Ukraine's frontline |
| Watch: Ros Atkins asks Jeremy Bowen about reporting from Ukraine's frontline | Watch: Ros Atkins asks Jeremy Bowen about reporting from Ukraine's frontline |
| The withdrawal was announced shortly after Russian media said the deputy leader of Kherson, Kirill Stremousov, had been killed in a car crash. | The withdrawal was announced shortly after Russian media said the deputy leader of Kherson, Kirill Stremousov, had been killed in a car crash. |
| Seen as one of the main cheerleaders of the occupation of Kherson, he had warned only six days ago that it was "most likely" that Russian forces would have to cross to the eastern bank. | Seen as one of the main cheerleaders of the occupation of Kherson, he had warned only six days ago that it was "most likely" that Russian forces would have to cross to the eastern bank. |
| Although the Ukrainian advance had slowed in recent weeks, Russia's supply lines across the Dnipro had become increasingly difficult after the few bridges across were destroyed by Ukrainian missiles. | Although the Ukrainian advance had slowed in recent weeks, Russia's supply lines across the Dnipro had become increasingly difficult after the few bridges across were destroyed by Ukrainian missiles. |
| Before the withdrawal, Russia moved thousands of civilians out of the city by boat, in what Ukraine condemned as a forced deportation. | Before the withdrawal, Russia moved thousands of civilians out of the city by boat, in what Ukraine condemned as a forced deportation. |
| Gen Surovikin - previously a notorious commander of Russia's recent operations in Syria - was appointed to take over the running of Russia's invasion a month ago. | Gen Surovikin - previously a notorious commander of Russia's recent operations in Syria - was appointed to take over the running of Russia's invasion a month ago. |