This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2022/nov/04/william-tyrrells-foster-mother-acquitted-of-lying-to-the-nsw-commission
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| William Tyrrell’s foster mother acquitted of lying to the NSW Crime Commission | William Tyrrell’s foster mother acquitted of lying to the NSW Crime Commission |
| (7 months later) | |
| Woman had been accused of lying about whether she had ever struck a different child in her care with a wooden spoon | Woman had been accused of lying about whether she had ever struck a different child in her care with a wooden spoon |
| The foster mother of missing boy William Tyrrell did not lie to the New South Wales Crime Commission about hitting a different foster child with a wooden spoon, a magistrate has found. | The foster mother of missing boy William Tyrrell did not lie to the New South Wales Crime Commission about hitting a different foster child with a wooden spoon, a magistrate has found. |
| The woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, appeared in Sydney’s Downing Centre local court on Friday charged with knowingly giving false or misleading evidence to the commission. | The woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, appeared in Sydney’s Downing Centre local court on Friday charged with knowingly giving false or misleading evidence to the commission. |
| The charge was unrelated to William, who was aged three when he went missing from a home at Kendall on the NSW mid-north coast in 2014. | The charge was unrelated to William, who was aged three when he went missing from a home at Kendall on the NSW mid-north coast in 2014. |
| The woman was accused of lying to the commission about whether she had ever struck another child in her care with a wooden spoon. | The woman was accused of lying to the commission about whether she had ever struck another child in her care with a wooden spoon. |
| Magistrate Miranda Moody said she could not “discount the possibility she was mistaken and did not deliberately lie” to the commission, because she made such prompt admissions of hitting and kicking the child in other instances during the hearing. | Magistrate Miranda Moody said she could not “discount the possibility she was mistaken and did not deliberately lie” to the commission, because she made such prompt admissions of hitting and kicking the child in other instances during the hearing. |
| The woman responded “yes” to questions put to her during the hearing including “did you ever hit [the child]?” and “did you ever kick [the child]?”. | The woman responded “yes” to questions put to her during the hearing including “did you ever hit [the child]?” and “did you ever kick [the child]?”. |
| “Have you ever hit her with a wooden spoon?” Det Sgt Andrew Lonergan asked her. | “Have you ever hit her with a wooden spoon?” Det Sgt Andrew Lonergan asked her. |
| “Never,” she responded. | “Never,” she responded. |
| Sign up for our free morning and afternoon email newsletters from Guardian Australia for your daily news roundup | Sign up for our free morning and afternoon email newsletters from Guardian Australia for your daily news roundup |
| Sign up for our free morning and afternoon email newsletters from Guardian Australia for your daily news roundup | Sign up for our free morning and afternoon email newsletters from Guardian Australia for your daily news roundup |
| The magistrate said she “might have taken a different view had she denied ever hitting or kicking [the child]”. | The magistrate said she “might have taken a different view had she denied ever hitting or kicking [the child]”. |
| Audio recording from listening devices placed in the home recorded what police allege is the woman hitting a child with a wooden spoon. | Audio recording from listening devices placed in the home recorded what police allege is the woman hitting a child with a wooden spoon. |
| The child can be heard threatening to call the police beforehand. | The child can be heard threatening to call the police beforehand. |
| A woman is then heard telling the child to “stand up” three times. | A woman is then heard telling the child to “stand up” three times. |
| “Where’d you put the wooden spoon?” the court heard a woman on the recording say. | “Where’d you put the wooden spoon?” the court heard a woman on the recording say. |
| The child then pleads, screams and cries, and is told to turn around and move her hands before smacking sounds are heard. | The child then pleads, screams and cries, and is told to turn around and move her hands before smacking sounds are heard. |
| Sign up to Morning Mail | |
| Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it matters | |
| after newsletter promotion | after newsletter promotion |
| “She’s still going on about it,” the woman is heard telling her husband in a later phone call intercepted by police. | “She’s still going on about it,” the woman is heard telling her husband in a later phone call intercepted by police. |
| Earlier in the court hearing, Lonergan said he believed the foster mother knew where William Tyrrell is. | Earlier in the court hearing, Lonergan said he believed the foster mother knew where William Tyrrell is. |
| Her barrister, John Stratton, said that was a false belief. | Her barrister, John Stratton, said that was a false belief. |
| Police charged her for allegedly lying, in an attempt to pressure her, he said. | Police charged her for allegedly lying, in an attempt to pressure her, he said. |
| “You are hoping to break her spirit,” Stratton suggested. | “You are hoping to break her spirit,” Stratton suggested. |
| “Our main objective is to find out where William Tyrrell is,” Lonergan said. | “Our main objective is to find out where William Tyrrell is,” Lonergan said. |
| The woman was emotional and teary when the magistrate delivered her decision. | The woman was emotional and teary when the magistrate delivered her decision. |
| “With this behind me I hope the police focus on finding William and what happened to him,” she told reporters outside court. | “With this behind me I hope the police focus on finding William and what happened to him,” she told reporters outside court. |