This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/63477452
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Paul Pelosi: Who is spreading false claims about attack on Nancy Pelosi's husband? | Paul Pelosi: Who is spreading false claims about attack on Nancy Pelosi's husband? |
(about 7 hours later) | |
Paul Pelosi, the husband of US House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi, was attacked by a hammer-wielding intruder at the couple's San Francisco home in the early hours of Friday. | Paul Pelosi, the husband of US House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi, was attacked by a hammer-wielding intruder at the couple's San Francisco home in the early hours of Friday. |
Within hours of the attack, a series of unsubstantiated claims began circulating in fringe far-right circles that contradicted the official police account of how the attack unfolded. | Within hours of the attack, a series of unsubstantiated claims began circulating in fringe far-right circles that contradicted the official police account of how the attack unfolded. |
Those misleading claims have since gone viral after being amplified by new Twitter chief Elon Musk and a number of conservative influencers. | Those misleading claims have since gone viral after being amplified by new Twitter chief Elon Musk and a number of conservative influencers. |
BBC News examines some of the claims about the attack. | BBC News examines some of the claims about the attack. |
False same-sex affair claims | False same-sex affair claims |
One of the most viral false claims about the attack suggests that Mr Pelosi, 82, and his attacker David DePape, 42, were in a same-sex relationship and had a drunken quarrel. | One of the most viral false claims about the attack suggests that Mr Pelosi, 82, and his attacker David DePape, 42, were in a same-sex relationship and had a drunken quarrel. |
A series of baseless assumptions that do not match official accounts of the incident have been used to support the narrative. | A series of baseless assumptions that do not match official accounts of the incident have been used to support the narrative. |
These claims started to trend in the US after Elon Musk tweeted an article from a website featuring similar claims to his 112 million followers on Sunday, before deleting his tweet without any explanation hours later. | These claims started to trend in the US after Elon Musk tweeted an article from a website featuring similar claims to his 112 million followers on Sunday, before deleting his tweet without any explanation hours later. |
"There is a tiny possibility there might be more to this story than meets the eye," Mr Musk had said in response to a tweet by former Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton. | "There is a tiny possibility there might be more to this story than meets the eye," Mr Musk had said in response to a tweet by former Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton. |
The website Mr Musk linked to has a history of publishing inaccurate stories, including an article from 2016 that claimed Hillary Clinton was dead. | The website Mr Musk linked to has a history of publishing inaccurate stories, including an article from 2016 that claimed Hillary Clinton was dead. |
One of the claims made online is that both Mr DePape and Mr Pelosi were in just their underwear as police arrived at the scene. | One of the claims made online is that both Mr DePape and Mr Pelosi were in just their underwear as police arrived at the scene. |
But the FBI complaint against Mr DePape quotes a witness as saying he was dressed "in all black" carrying a large black bag on his back. | But the FBI complaint against Mr DePape quotes a witness as saying he was dressed "in all black" carrying a large black bag on his back. |
Another claim seized on to support this narrative is that the two men knew each other before the attack and were friends. | Another claim seized on to support this narrative is that the two men knew each other before the attack and were friends. |
Republican Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene repeated the claim in a tweet yesterday. | Republican Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene repeated the claim in a tweet yesterday. |
According to the FBI complaint, Paul Pelosi did not know Mr DePape. Mr Pelosi used coded language as he made a 911 call from the bathroom, and an experienced operator worked out what was happening in his house. | According to the FBI complaint, Paul Pelosi did not know Mr DePape. Mr Pelosi used coded language as he made a 911 call from the bathroom, and an experienced operator worked out what was happening in his house. |
Another rumour supporting the idea that the two men knew each other claimed that the shattered glass door of the house was broken from the inside, suggesting Mr Pelosi or a third person had let Mr DePape in. | Another rumour supporting the idea that the two men knew each other claimed that the shattered glass door of the house was broken from the inside, suggesting Mr Pelosi or a third person had let Mr DePape in. |
The FBI complaint quotes Mr DePape as saying that he "broke into the house through a glass door, which was a difficult task that required the use of a hammer". | The FBI complaint quotes Mr DePape as saying that he "broke into the house through a glass door, which was a difficult task that required the use of a hammer". |
False claims suggested the glass door of the house was broken from the inside | False claims suggested the glass door of the house was broken from the inside |
There is no evidence in any of the police accounts that a third person was either in the house or involved in the attack. | There is no evidence in any of the police accounts that a third person was either in the house or involved in the attack. |
Paul Pelosi attack suspect 'was on suicide mission' | |
Claims DePape's blogs were faked | Claims DePape's blogs were faked |
Two personal blogs and a Facebook account in the suspect's name were found on the internet after police revealed his name following the attack, all of which were subsequently taken down. | Two personal blogs and a Facebook account in the suspect's name were found on the internet after police revealed his name following the attack, all of which were subsequently taken down. |
His writings, viewed by the BBC, suggest he was a man radicalised by far-right conspiracy theories. | His writings, viewed by the BBC, suggest he was a man radicalised by far-right conspiracy theories. |
His posts cover a range of subjects, including unsubstantiated theories that the 2020 election was stolen, the 6 January Capitol riot, claims that Covid vaccines were harmful, support for the QAnon conspiracy theory, as well as racist and anti-Semitic posts. | His posts cover a range of subjects, including unsubstantiated theories that the 2020 election was stolen, the 6 January Capitol riot, claims that Covid vaccines were harmful, support for the QAnon conspiracy theory, as well as racist and anti-Semitic posts. |
Some online posts suggested the blogs were fake and only created on the day of the attack to support the narrative that he believed in far-right conspiracy theories. | Some online posts suggested the blogs were fake and only created on the day of the attack to support the narrative that he believed in far-right conspiracy theories. |
But the BBC has screenshots of the blogs which show he had made posts as early as August, weeks before the attack. | But the BBC has screenshots of the blogs which show he had made posts as early as August, weeks before the attack. |
Some have also claimed the attack was not motivated by politics or Mr DePape's beliefs. | Some have also claimed the attack was not motivated by politics or Mr DePape's beliefs. |
Conservative commentator Matt Walsh said it was "absurd" to portray the attacker as "a militant right winger". | Conservative commentator Matt Walsh said it was "absurd" to portray the attacker as "a militant right winger". |
Texas Senator Ted Cruz echoed Mr Walsh's words, simply tweeting "truth". | Texas Senator Ted Cruz echoed Mr Walsh's words, simply tweeting "truth". |
However, the police complaint clarifies the attack was not a random act. According to San Francisco's district attorney Brooke Jenkins, the attack was likely "politically motivated". | However, the police complaint clarifies the attack was not a random act. According to San Francisco's district attorney Brooke Jenkins, the attack was likely "politically motivated". |
In his police interview, Mr DePape described Nancy Pelosi as the "leader of the pack of lies told by the Democratic Party", adding that he wanted to "break her kneecaps". | In his police interview, Mr DePape described Nancy Pelosi as the "leader of the pack of lies told by the Democratic Party", adding that he wanted to "break her kneecaps". |
Conservative figures, including Congressman Steve Scalise and Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, have also been targets of violent attacks by political opponents in recent years. | Conservative figures, including Congressman Steve Scalise and Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, have also been targets of violent attacks by political opponents in recent years. |
Evidence-free accusations against Marjorie Taylor Greene | Evidence-free accusations against Marjorie Taylor Greene |
Baseless theories in the aftermath of the attack weren't confined to the right. | Baseless theories in the aftermath of the attack weren't confined to the right. |
Some liberal influencers seized on a tweet by Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, posted a day prior to the attack, which read: "Just wait until tomorrow." | Some liberal influencers seized on a tweet by Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, posted a day prior to the attack, which read: "Just wait until tomorrow." |
A number of accounts with large liberal followings claimed that Ms Taylor Greene's tweet could be a hint that she was in on the attack on Mr Pelosi. There is no evidence whatsoever to support this theory. | A number of accounts with large liberal followings claimed that Ms Taylor Greene's tweet could be a hint that she was in on the attack on Mr Pelosi. There is no evidence whatsoever to support this theory. |