This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-63206302
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Indyref2 arguments to be heard at Supreme Court | Indyref2 arguments to be heard at Supreme Court |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Inside the indyref2 Supreme Court case | Inside the indyref2 Supreme Court case |
| Inside the indyref2 Supreme Court case | Inside the indyref2 Supreme Court case |
| The UK's highest court is to hear arguments on whether Holyrood can set up a Scottish independence referendum without the agreement of Westminster. | The UK's highest court is to hear arguments on whether Holyrood can set up a Scottish independence referendum without the agreement of Westminster. |
| First Minister Nicola Sturgeon wants to hold such a vote on 19 October 2023, but the UK government opposes this. | First Minister Nicola Sturgeon wants to hold such a vote on 19 October 2023, but the UK government opposes this. |
| Two days have been set aside for the hearing, with the outcome being issued within weeks or months. | Two days have been set aside for the hearing, with the outcome being issued within weeks or months. |
| The Scottish and UK governments will make their cases before a panel of five judges at the Supreme Court in London. | The Scottish and UK governments will make their cases before a panel of five judges at the Supreme Court in London. |
| UK law officers argue the constitution is reserved to Westminster and it is therefore a matter beyond the powers of the Scottish Parliament. | UK law officers argue the constitution is reserved to Westminster and it is therefore a matter beyond the powers of the Scottish Parliament. |
| The Scottish government case argues the referendum is "advisory" and would have no legal effect on the Union. | The Scottish government case argues the referendum is "advisory" and would have no legal effect on the Union. |
| The indyref2 questions facing the Supreme Court | The indyref2 questions facing the Supreme Court |
| How will indyref2 compare with 2014? | How will indyref2 compare with 2014? |
| Sturgeon proposes 19 October 2023 for referendum | Sturgeon proposes 19 October 2023 for referendum |
| A written submission from the SNP will also be considered. This document stresses the right to self determination, stating that it must inform the interpretation of the Scotland Act 1998. | A written submission from the SNP will also be considered. This document stresses the right to self determination, stating that it must inform the interpretation of the Scotland Act 1998. |
| Ms Sturgeon used her speech at the SNP party conference on Monday to reiterate her commitment to making Scotland an independent country, saying it was "essential to escape Westminster control and mismanagement" and return to the EU. | Ms Sturgeon used her speech at the SNP party conference on Monday to reiterate her commitment to making Scotland an independent country, saying it was "essential to escape Westminster control and mismanagement" and return to the EU. |
| She has repeatedly said her preference would be to proceed with the agreement of the UK government, as happened ahead of the referendum in 2014 when a "section 30 order" was granted giving Holyrood the power to hold such a vote. | She has repeatedly said her preference would be to proceed with the agreement of the UK government, as happened ahead of the referendum in 2014 when a "section 30 order" was granted giving Holyrood the power to hold such a vote. |
| Prime Minister Liz Truss and her recent Conservative predecessors, however, have refused to grant such permission, arguing that now is not time for another independence vote. | |
| In an attempt to break this deadlock, Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain - the Scottish government's top law officer - has asked the Supreme Court to rule on whether MSPs could set up a referendum themselves. | In an attempt to break this deadlock, Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain - the Scottish government's top law officer - has asked the Supreme Court to rule on whether MSPs could set up a referendum themselves. |
| Ms Sturgeon has said she would respect the judgement of the court but if the ruling goes against the Scottish government, she would then fight the next general election solely on the issue, making it a de facto independence vote. | Ms Sturgeon has said she would respect the judgement of the court but if the ruling goes against the Scottish government, she would then fight the next general election solely on the issue, making it a de facto independence vote. |
| Legislative competence | Legislative competence |
| The UK government will be represented by the Advocate General for Scotland, Lord Keith Stewart KC, who will argue that an independence referendum plainly relates to reserved matters. | The UK government will be represented by the Advocate General for Scotland, Lord Keith Stewart KC, who will argue that an independence referendum plainly relates to reserved matters. |
| In August, he asked the Supreme Court to "decline to determine the reference", saying it was beyond the court's jurisdiction. | |
| However, he also argued that even if the court did decide it had jurisdiction over the matter, Holyrood would be unable to hold a lawful referendum. | However, he also argued that even if the court did decide it had jurisdiction over the matter, Holyrood would be unable to hold a lawful referendum. |
| The Scotland Act states that "the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England" is a reserved matter. | The Scotland Act states that "the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England" is a reserved matter. |
| A UK government spokesperson said: "People across Scotland want both their governments to be working together, focusing on the issues that matter to them, not talking about another independence referendum. | A UK government spokesperson said: "People across Scotland want both their governments to be working together, focusing on the issues that matter to them, not talking about another independence referendum. |
| "On the question of legislative competence, the UK government's clear view remains that a bill legislating for a referendum on independence would be outside the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament." | "On the question of legislative competence, the UK government's clear view remains that a bill legislating for a referendum on independence would be outside the legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament." |
| The five judges listed are Lord Reed, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Sales, Lord Stephens and Lady Rose. | The five judges listed are Lord Reed, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Sales, Lord Stephens and Lady Rose. |