This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/northern_ireland/foyle_and_west/8166098.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Tasered man posed no threat: SF | |
(about 4 hours later) | |
A Policing Board member has criticised the finding of the Police Ombudsman that the use of a Taser stun gun was "justified and proportionate". | |
Sinn Fein MLA Martina Anderson said police should never have used one on Declan Smith, 38, of Elaghmore Park, Londonderry last August. | |
Police surrounded his home after they received a report he was threatening to kill himself and his children. | |
Charges were dropped after the alleged injured party withdrew her complaint. | |
Following his own investigation of the police operation, Al Hutchinson said it had been "effective and successful". | Following his own investigation of the police operation, Al Hutchinson said it had been "effective and successful". |
"The use of a Taser represented a less lethal option compared to the potential use of live fire or impact (baton) rounds at close range," he said. | "The use of a Taser represented a less lethal option compared to the potential use of live fire or impact (baton) rounds at close range," he said. |
"Unlike handheld batons, it allowed officers to maintain a safe distance from a suspect they believed was armed with a knife." | "Unlike handheld batons, it allowed officers to maintain a safe distance from a suspect they believed was armed with a knife." |
Taser guns fire two wires which attach to the body and carry an electric shock. | Taser guns fire two wires which attach to the body and carry an electric shock. |
'Unjust' | |
Mr Smith said the Ombudsman's report has made him feel like a "criminal". | |
"The report finds the police to be right in every way," he said. | |
"I find them not to be. I feel my civil rights were taken away and I was unjustly tasered. The shock of this is greater than the shock of the Taser. | |
"When I awoke that morning it was six-thirty and I went down to get a glass of water. I didn't even realise that the house was surrounded by police. | |
"As soon as I did I went to the door and opened it, I was asked to step outside which I did, I was in my pyjamas and I was shot. I had no comprehension of what was going on around me." | |
Ms Anderson questioned why Mr Smith was tasered "when he posed no threat". | |
"In the report they state categorically that when Declan came out they could not see a weapon," she said. | |
"Had a negotiator been at the scene earlier, which one should have been, I firmly believe Declan would not have been Tasered." | |
'Vindication' | |
The police were given permission to buy 12 Taser guns in 2008, despite opposition from human rights groups and some members of the Policing Board. | The police were given permission to buy 12 Taser guns in 2008, despite opposition from human rights groups and some members of the Policing Board. |
Ulster Unionist Policing Board member Basil McCrea said Mr Hutchinson's report provided a "clear vindication" of Taser usage, while fellow Board member Peter Weir of the DUP said it was "a welcome step for practical and common-sense policing". | Ulster Unionist Policing Board member Basil McCrea said Mr Hutchinson's report provided a "clear vindication" of Taser usage, while fellow Board member Peter Weir of the DUP said it was "a welcome step for practical and common-sense policing". |
Mr Hutchinson said police were first called to the incident at about 0300 BST by a woman who said her drunk partner, who was armed with a knife, had locked himself in their home and was threatening to kill himself and their two children, aged four and five. | Mr Hutchinson said police were first called to the incident at about 0300 BST by a woman who said her drunk partner, who was armed with a knife, had locked himself in their home and was threatening to kill himself and their two children, aged four and five. |
After repeated attempts by police to contact Mr Smith by mobile phone were unsuccessful, he eventually went to the back door of the house shortly after 0630 BST. | After repeated attempts by police to contact Mr Smith by mobile phone were unsuccessful, he eventually went to the back door of the house shortly after 0630 BST. |
Officers told him to move away from the house into the back yard, and he took a single step forward but did not move further. | Officers told him to move away from the house into the back yard, and he took a single step forward but did not move further. |
Mr Smith was then struck by the Taser discharge and fell to the ground, suffering injuries to his head and elbow, before officers moved in to restrain him, according to the report. | Mr Smith was then struck by the Taser discharge and fell to the ground, suffering injuries to his head and elbow, before officers moved in to restrain him, according to the report. |
The officer who discharged the Taser told Police Ombudsman investigators that he believed the children would have been at risk if the man had re-entered the house. | The officer who discharged the Taser told Police Ombudsman investigators that he believed the children would have been at risk if the man had re-entered the house. |
The report recommended that regional teams of negotiators should be established across Northern Ireland to allow for a quicker response to such incidents. | |
In this case, negotiators took several hours to arrive at the scene. | In this case, negotiators took several hours to arrive at the scene. |
He also said that advice to medical professionals on the removal of the small barbs discharged by Tasers should be re-circulated. | He also said that advice to medical professionals on the removal of the small barbs discharged by Tasers should be re-circulated. |