This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/8124696.stm
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 3 | Version 4 |
---|---|
MPs' code of conduct plan dropped | MPs' code of conduct plan dropped |
(about 2 hours later) | |
The government has dropped plans for a legally-binding code of conduct for MPs after fears it would prompt a flood of legal challenges. | The government has dropped plans for a legally-binding code of conduct for MPs after fears it would prompt a flood of legal challenges. |
The idea had been a key part of the government's plans to "clean-up" politics after the expenses scandal. | The idea had been a key part of the government's plans to "clean-up" politics after the expenses scandal. |
But former standards watchdog Sir Philip Mawer warned it was a recipe for "delay, cost and confusion". | But former standards watchdog Sir Philip Mawer warned it was a recipe for "delay, cost and confusion". |
Ministers are to press ahead with plans to set up an external body to run the MPs' expenses system. | Ministers are to press ahead with plans to set up an external body to run the MPs' expenses system. |
Only three days of debate have been scheduled for the Parliamentary Standards Bill as the government wants it passed before MPs leave for the summer recess on 21 July. | Only three days of debate have been scheduled for the Parliamentary Standards Bill as the government wants it passed before MPs leave for the summer recess on 21 July. |
Lawyers' 'field day' | Lawyers' 'field day' |
The bill would hand the day-to-day administration and oversight of MPs' expenses to an external body. | The bill would hand the day-to-day administration and oversight of MPs' expenses to an external body. |
Earlier Sir Philip, the former Parliamentary Standards Commissioner, told a separate inquiry into MPs' expenses the legislation was "confused" and warned that a legally binding code of conduct could create a "rules-based system which lawyers will have a field day with and which may well cost the public more". | Earlier Sir Philip, the former Parliamentary Standards Commissioner, told a separate inquiry into MPs' expenses the legislation was "confused" and warned that a legally binding code of conduct could create a "rules-based system which lawyers will have a field day with and which may well cost the public more". |
The Clerk of the House - the Commons' top official Malcolm Jack - has also warned of legal challenges to any code drawn up by MPs which "in the present climate" might mean "no shortage of potential litigants trying to make a point". | |
There are some really serious issues about the role of Parliament in this bill and I am very worried that we are rushing it through Sir George Young MP | There are some really serious issues about the role of Parliament in this bill and I am very worried that we are rushing it through Sir George Young MP |
MPs debating the bill on Monday raised concerns that lack of sufficient scrutiny will lead to long-term damage to how the institution functions. | MPs debating the bill on Monday raised concerns that lack of sufficient scrutiny will lead to long-term damage to how the institution functions. |
"There are some really serious issues about the role of Parliament in this bill and I am very worried that we are rushing it through," Sir George Young, chairman of the committee on standards and privileges, said. | "There are some really serious issues about the role of Parliament in this bill and I am very worried that we are rushing it through," Sir George Young, chairman of the committee on standards and privileges, said. |
Earlier he said he wanted to be "held accountable to the ballot box, not to the courts, for what I do as an MP". | Earlier he said he wanted to be "held accountable to the ballot box, not to the courts, for what I do as an MP". |
Justice Secretary Jack Straw said the measures had to be agreed quickly because of Parliament's "collective" failure over expenses. | Justice Secretary Jack Straw said the measures had to be agreed quickly because of Parliament's "collective" failure over expenses. |
'Consensus' decision | 'Consensus' decision |
"The expenses scandal was not just a matter of a couple of headlines," he said. | "The expenses scandal was not just a matter of a couple of headlines," he said. |
"It has engulfed this House and its reputation. We face a really serious problem in terms of rebuilding public confidence." | "It has engulfed this House and its reputation. We face a really serious problem in terms of rebuilding public confidence." |
But he agreed to drop a clause introducing a legally binding code of conduct on non-financial aspects of MPs' behaviour which could have stipulated, for instance, how many surgery hours they offer. | But he agreed to drop a clause introducing a legally binding code of conduct on non-financial aspects of MPs' behaviour which could have stipulated, for instance, how many surgery hours they offer. |
Having offences in this Bill are fundamental to its proper operation Jack Straw | Having offences in this Bill are fundamental to its proper operation Jack Straw |
Instead the code will be incorporated into the clause of the bill dealing solely with MPs' financial interests. | Instead the code will be incorporated into the clause of the bill dealing solely with MPs' financial interests. |
Mr Straw said he was acting in the "interest of consensus" after several MPs and Parliamentary officials had expressed concerns about the measure's likely consequences. | Mr Straw said he was acting in the "interest of consensus" after several MPs and Parliamentary officials had expressed concerns about the measure's likely consequences. |
The bill passed its second reading with a majority of 290. | The bill passed its second reading with a majority of 290. |
For the Conservatives, Shadow Commons Leader Alan Duncan welcomed the climb-down, saying "we can't end the culture of blank cheques to MPs, only to open up a culture of blank cheques for lawyers". | For the Conservatives, Shadow Commons Leader Alan Duncan welcomed the climb-down, saying "we can't end the culture of blank cheques to MPs, only to open up a culture of blank cheques for lawyers". |
However, Mr Straw refused to give ground over the inclusion of three new criminal offences in the bill governing MPs' financial dealings. | However, Mr Straw refused to give ground over the inclusion of three new criminal offences in the bill governing MPs' financial dealings. |
These would see fines and a potential 12-month jail sentence for MPs who area found to have knowingly made false claims, failed to fully declare outside financial interests or breached the rules on paid advocacy. | These would see fines and a potential 12-month jail sentence for MPs who area found to have knowingly made false claims, failed to fully declare outside financial interests or breached the rules on paid advocacy. |
Several Tory MPs said the offences were unnecessary and redundant as the offences were already covered by existing laws on fraud and theft applicable to MPs. | Several Tory MPs said the offences were unnecessary and redundant as the offences were already covered by existing laws on fraud and theft applicable to MPs. |
"Having offences in this Bill are fundamental to its proper operation and, above all, fundamental to ensuring public confidence in this scheme," Mr Straw said. | "Having offences in this Bill are fundamental to its proper operation and, above all, fundamental to ensuring public confidence in this scheme," Mr Straw said. |
Meanwhile, during a separate independent inquiry into MPs expenses, another former parliamentary standards commissioner, Elizabeth Filkin, said the crisis was avoidable. | Meanwhile, during a separate independent inquiry into MPs expenses, another former parliamentary standards commissioner, Elizabeth Filkin, said the crisis was avoidable. |
She was removed as commissioner in 2001 after angering many MPs through criticism of their conduct. | She was removed as commissioner in 2001 after angering many MPs through criticism of their conduct. |
She told the Committee on Standards in Public Life, which is looking into MPs' pay and expenses, that Parliament was a "very insular place and people feel entitled to all sorts of privileges of one kind or another because of their position". | She told the Committee on Standards in Public Life, which is looking into MPs' pay and expenses, that Parliament was a "very insular place and people feel entitled to all sorts of privileges of one kind or another because of their position". |
She said it was "very sad" that "people at the top" did not do enough to ensure "the right sort of standards". | She said it was "very sad" that "people at the top" did not do enough to ensure "the right sort of standards". |