This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/scotland/highlands_and_islands/8112639.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Death crash sentence 'disgusting' | |
(about 4 hours later) | |
The family of a tyre fitter has described as "disgusting" the two-and-a-half year prison sentence handed down to the driver who caused his death. | |
Andrew Ramsay, 50, of Bellshill, Lanarkshire, collided with Gavin Sutherland's stationary van and the lorry he was working on. | |
Another man, Bryan Duff, was injured in the incident on the A9 at Daviot, near Inverness, in October 2007. | |
Mr Sutherland's twin brother Gordon said he had expected a longer sentence. | |
There is no suggestion that your bad driving was deliberate - it was however, again on the evidence, prolonged Lord BrailsfordJudge | |
Outside the High Court in Glasgow, he said: "It's disgusting. | |
"I would like to have seen five years anyway." | |
Mr Sutherland said his brother was an "absolutely brilliant guy", adding: "Not a day goes by that we don't think about him. | |
"He did not deserve this, no way did he deserve this. I felt today there was no justice done for Gavin." | |
Ramsay was also disqualified from driving for four years. | Ramsay was also disqualified from driving for four years. |
Gavin Sutherland had been working on a puncture | |
The judge Lord Brailsford said the offence fell into the "intermediate culpability" category. | The judge Lord Brailsford said the offence fell into the "intermediate culpability" category. |
In May, the judge apologised to the victim's family for a delay in the sentencing because background reports were not ready. | In May, the judge apologised to the victim's family for a delay in the sentencing because background reports were not ready. |
Mr Sutherland's family had travelled from Invergordon in the Highlands to Edinburgh to hear the sentence. | Mr Sutherland's family had travelled from Invergordon in the Highlands to Edinburgh to hear the sentence. |
Earlier, Ramsay was found guilty of causing 41-year-old Mr Sutherland's death and injuring Mr Duff by dangerous driving. | |
Ramsay denied the charge of death by dangerous driving. | Ramsay denied the charge of death by dangerous driving. |
Wind rush | |
He had offered to plead guilty to the lesser charge of careless driving, but this was not accepted by the Crown. | He had offered to plead guilty to the lesser charge of careless driving, but this was not accepted by the Crown. |
Ramsay was found guilty at the High Court in Dunfermline by the majority verdict of the jury. | Ramsay was found guilty at the High Court in Dunfermline by the majority verdict of the jury. |
The court heard how Mr Sutherland, from Invergordon, had been replacing a punctured tyre on a lorry driven by Mr Duff, 33, of Portmahomack in Easter Ross. | The court heard how Mr Sutherland, from Invergordon, had been replacing a punctured tyre on a lorry driven by Mr Duff, 33, of Portmahomack in Easter Ross. |
Mr Duff was swept off his feet by the wind rush from the crash and landed in the road, breaking a bone in his foot and injuring his shoulder. Since the smash he has had flashbacks and nightmares. | Mr Duff was swept off his feet by the wind rush from the crash and landed in the road, breaking a bone in his foot and injuring his shoulder. Since the smash he has had flashbacks and nightmares. |
A young vet stopped at the scene and tried to give Mr Sutherland first aid, but her efforts were in vain. | A young vet stopped at the scene and tried to give Mr Sutherland first aid, but her efforts were in vain. |
Lord Brailsford told the court that a recent English Court of Appeal case had set out "aggravating factors" which should be looked for in similar cases. | |
Andrew Ramsay was also disqualified from driving for four years | |
He told Ramsay "only one" was present in his case - a "prolonged persistent and deliberate course of very bad driving". | |
The judge said: "I should make it clear that even that factor is not wholly satisfied because, on the evidence, there is no suggestion that your bad driving was deliberate - it was however, again on the evidence, prolonged. | |
"The lights of the recovery vehicle were visible to an oncoming vehicle such as yours for something in the order of half-a-mile to a mile." | |
Defence advocate Ian Duguid told the court that Ramsay had split with his partner in the aftermath of the crash and has been taking medication to deal with depression. | |
He added: "It is hard to measure a loss of life and the grief of relatives against a custodial sentence. | |
"But Mr Ramsay apologises and regrets his actions." |