This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/northern_ireland/8095431.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Real IRA are 'republican Taliban' | Real IRA are 'republican Taliban' |
(about 14 hours later) | |
A Northern Ireland journalist has told a court she will face "grave danger" if she has to give the police her notes linked to stories about the Real IRA. | A Northern Ireland journalist has told a court she will face "grave danger" if she has to give the police her notes linked to stories about the Real IRA. |
Suzanne Breen, the northern editor of the Sunday Tribune, appeared at the High Court in Belfast. | Suzanne Breen, the northern editor of the Sunday Tribune, appeared at the High Court in Belfast. |
The BBC's John Ware, giving evidence on her behalf, said there was a difference between the Provos and the Real IRA. | The BBC's John Ware, giving evidence on her behalf, said there was a difference between the Provos and the Real IRA. |
"These guys are the Taliban of the republican movement, and we need to be clear about that," he claimed. | "These guys are the Taliban of the republican movement, and we need to be clear about that," he claimed. |
Ms Breen received the Real IRA's claim of responsibility for the murder of two soldiers in March and interviewed a representative of the group. | Ms Breen received the Real IRA's claim of responsibility for the murder of two soldiers in March and interviewed a representative of the group. |
The police say they need the notes as part of the murder inquiry. | The police say they need the notes as part of the murder inquiry. |
In May, a judge said he was "minded" to grant the police application to force the journalist to hand over the material. | In May, a judge said he was "minded" to grant the police application to force the journalist to hand over the material. |
However, he said his view could change once he heard arguments from her legal team. | However, he said his view could change once he heard arguments from her legal team. |
Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, from Birmingham, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, from London, were shot dead as they collected pizzas outside their barracks in Antrim on 7 March. | Sappers Mark Quinsey, 23, from Birmingham, and Patrick Azimkar, 21, from London, were shot dead as they collected pizzas outside their barracks in Antrim on 7 March. |
Among those who went into the witness box to back Ms Breen's stance was her editor, Noreen Hegarty, Alex Thomson of Channel 4 News, Liam Clake from the Sunday Times, and media commentator Roy Greenslade, a Professor of Journalism at London City University. | Among those who went into the witness box to back Ms Breen's stance was her editor, Noreen Hegarty, Alex Thomson of Channel 4 News, Liam Clake from the Sunday Times, and media commentator Roy Greenslade, a Professor of Journalism at London City University. |
All of them were united in stressing how a journalist must honour any guarantee of confidentiality given to those who provide information. | All of them were united in stressing how a journalist must honour any guarantee of confidentiality given to those who provide information. |
A journalist making a witness statement to police and handing over their mobile phone records would be an even graver act, in republican eyes, and I would make myself an immediate target for assassination Suzanne Breen | A journalist making a witness statement to police and handing over their mobile phone records would be an even graver act, in republican eyes, and I would make myself an immediate target for assassination Suzanne Breen |
Ms Breen told the court how the National Union of Journalists code of conduct made it clear that confidentiality for sources must always be protected. | Ms Breen told the court how the National Union of Journalists code of conduct made it clear that confidentiality for sources must always be protected. |
"Our job is to gather information and put it in the public domain," she said. | "Our job is to gather information and put it in the public domain," she said. |
"It's not to act as agents of the state. We chose to become journalists, not to become detectives." | "It's not to act as agents of the state. We chose to become journalists, not to become detectives." |
Ms Breen used the example of the fast food delivery men wounded in the gun attack on the soldiers to back her argument. | Ms Breen used the example of the fast food delivery men wounded in the gun attack on the soldiers to back her argument. |
She said: "They deliberately shot the pizza men because in some ways simply to serve food to British soldiers... is regarded as an act of collaboration. | She said: "They deliberately shot the pizza men because in some ways simply to serve food to British soldiers... is regarded as an act of collaboration. |
"A journalist making a witness statement to police and handing over their mobile phone records would be an even graver act, in republican eyes, and I would make myself an immediate target for assassination." | "A journalist making a witness statement to police and handing over their mobile phone records would be an even graver act, in republican eyes, and I would make myself an immediate target for assassination." |
Counsel for the police argued that while the material may cause her professional concern it would be of "evidential value" to the police investigation. | Counsel for the police argued that while the material may cause her professional concern it would be of "evidential value" to the police investigation. |
He argued that the NUJ code carried no legal force, and claimed there was no current and immediate threat to life. | He argued that the NUJ code carried no legal force, and claimed there was no current and immediate threat to life. |
Any future and verified risk would place an obligation on the chief constable and other state agencies to provide protection, he accepted. | Any future and verified risk would place an obligation on the chief constable and other state agencies to provide protection, he accepted. |
Judge Tom Burgess, the Recorder for Belfast, reserved judgment in the police application and indicated he will give his ruling early next week. | Judge Tom Burgess, the Recorder for Belfast, reserved judgment in the police application and indicated he will give his ruling early next week. |