This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/education/8055474.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Student complaints rise sharply | Student complaints rise sharply |
(about 8 hours later) | |
The university adjudicator for England and Wales received 900 complaints from students in 2008 - a rise of 23% on 2007 - but just 7% were upheld. | The university adjudicator for England and Wales received 900 complaints from students in 2008 - a rise of 23% on 2007 - but just 7% were upheld. |
Disputes over postgraduate courses and allegations of plagiarism pushed up the total, the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education said. | Disputes over postgraduate courses and allegations of plagiarism pushed up the total, the Office of the Independent Adjudicator for Higher Education said. |
The adjudicator said the rise reflected a "cultural change" with fee-paying students wanting more value for money. | The adjudicator said the rise reflected a "cultural change" with fee-paying students wanting more value for money. |
Universities said the figure should be seen in the context of 1.9m students. | Universities said the figure should be seen in the context of 1.9m students. |
Consumer awareness | Consumer awareness |
There have been claims that students paying tuition fees were becoming more consumerist in their attitudes, with higher expectations of getting value for money from their courses. | There have been claims that students paying tuition fees were becoming more consumerist in their attitudes, with higher expectations of getting value for money from their courses. |
Adjudicator Rob Behrens says that such a consumer awareness among students is "not necessarily a bad thing". | Adjudicator Rob Behrens says that such a consumer awareness among students is "not necessarily a bad thing". |
The 23% rise in complaints in 2008 follows a 25% increase in 2007 compared with 2006. | The 23% rise in complaints in 2008 follows a 25% increase in 2007 compared with 2006. |
But only 7% of the complaints were upheld - with many falling outside the adjudicator's remit. | But only 7% of the complaints were upheld - with many falling outside the adjudicator's remit. |
The office cannot address some of the most contentious areas of higher education - such as admissions and academic judgments such as the awarding of degree grades. | The office cannot address some of the most contentious areas of higher education - such as admissions and academic judgments such as the awarding of degree grades. |
Greater assertiveness | Greater assertiveness |
It considers only complaints which have failed to be resolved by the disputes procedures within universities. | It considers only complaints which have failed to be resolved by the disputes procedures within universities. |
There was a disproportionately high number of international students among complainants - and Mr Behrens says this reflects a greater assertiveness among those paying higher fees. | There was a disproportionately high number of international students among complainants - and Mr Behrens says this reflects a greater assertiveness among those paying higher fees. |
But it also overlaps with the increase in disputes over plagiarism - and he says there were questions about different cultural attitudes towards what constitutes plagiarism. | But it also overlaps with the increase in disputes over plagiarism - and he says there were questions about different cultural attitudes towards what constitutes plagiarism. |
Mr Behrens says this emphasises that universities should make clear how plagiarism will be interpreted, before any ambiguities can arise. | Mr Behrens says this emphasises that universities should make clear how plagiarism will be interpreted, before any ambiguities can arise. |
When there are disputes over universities' handling of plagiarism accusations the report says that "practice is variable". | When there are disputes over universities' handling of plagiarism accusations the report says that "practice is variable". |
It says in a small number of these cases, there were "conflicts of interest" in the handling of complaints. | It says in a small number of these cases, there were "conflicts of interest" in the handling of complaints. |
Postgraduate courses also "feature prominently in our case files", says the report. | Postgraduate courses also "feature prominently in our case files", says the report. |
The report found cases where there had been "a clear reluctance to give timely feedback to underperforming postgraduate students". | The report found cases where there had been "a clear reluctance to give timely feedback to underperforming postgraduate students". |
"This creates false expectations of successful outcomes from thesis submission and is something that could be avoided." | "This creates false expectations of successful outcomes from thesis submission and is something that could be avoided." |
Business students were the most likely to have pursued a complaint. | Business students were the most likely to have pursued a complaint. |
Consumer students | Consumer students |
The rise in complaints is against a background in which students are seen to have much greater expectations of receiving value for their tuition fees. | The rise in complaints is against a background in which students are seen to have much greater expectations of receiving value for their tuition fees. |
Earlier this year, students at Manchester Metropolitan University set up a text service for disgruntled students who were kept waiting for their lectures. | Earlier this year, students at Manchester Metropolitan University set up a text service for disgruntled students who were kept waiting for their lectures. |
Diana Warwick, head of the university vice-chancellors' representative body, Universities UK, said the rise in complaints reflected "the increased awareness of this complaints procedure". | Diana Warwick, head of the university vice-chancellors' representative body, Universities UK, said the rise in complaints reflected "the increased awareness of this complaints procedure". |
But she said that the 900 complaints handled by the adjudicator should be seen in the context of 1.9 million students. | But she said that the 900 complaints handled by the adjudicator should be seen in the context of 1.9 million students. |
And a spokeswoman for England's Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills said: "According to the latest student survey, 80% of students are satisfied overall with the quality of their university experience. | |
"The OIA provides an important service for the small percentage of students that have outstanding issues." | |
But the National Union of Students said that there were still too many delays within universities in addressing complaints. | |
"Many universities need to work much harder to make their complaints procedures more efficient and transparent." | "Many universities need to work much harder to make their complaints procedures more efficient and transparent." |
Previous version
1
Next version