This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/africa/8037430.stm
The article has changed 12 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 5 | Version 6 |
---|---|
Aristocrat guilty of manslaughter | Aristocrat guilty of manslaughter |
(10 minutes later) | |
A white Kenyan aristocrat has been cleared of murder but found guilty of the manslaughter of a black poacher on his estate in 2006. | A white Kenyan aristocrat has been cleared of murder but found guilty of the manslaughter of a black poacher on his estate in 2006. |
A judge ruled Thomas Cholmondeley did not show "malice aforethought" in the shooting of Robert Njoya in May 2006. | A judge ruled Thomas Cholmondeley did not show "malice aforethought" in the shooting of Robert Njoya in May 2006. |
The case, involving the descendant of one of Kenya's first British settlers, has attracted huge media attention. | |
There was national outrage after a murder charge against Cholmondeley in 2005 was dropped for lack of evidence. | |
'No malice' | 'No malice' |
The courtroom in the Kenyan capital Nairobi was packed with lawyers, reporters, cameramen, and family and friends of Thomas Cholmondeley, the BBC's Adam Mynott in court said. | The courtroom in the Kenyan capital Nairobi was packed with lawyers, reporters, cameramen, and family and friends of Thomas Cholmondeley, the BBC's Adam Mynott in court said. |
There were gasps of surprise as High Court Justice Muga Apondi gave his ruling after reading out a 320-page verdict on the case, although the defendant himself remained impassive. | There were gasps of surprise as High Court Justice Muga Apondi gave his ruling after reading out a 320-page verdict on the case, although the defendant himself remained impassive. |
"I find as a fact that it was the accused who had shot the deceased resulting in his death," he said. | "I find as a fact that it was the accused who had shot the deceased resulting in his death," he said. |
"In view of the above analysis I hereby find which I do, that the accused did not have any malice aforethought to kill the deceased." | "In view of the above analysis I hereby find which I do, that the accused did not have any malice aforethought to kill the deceased." |
He said he had therefore decided Mr Cholmondeley should be acquitted of the murder charge, but found guilty of manslaughter. | He said he had therefore decided Mr Cholmondeley should be acquitted of the murder charge, but found guilty of manslaughter. |
The Eton-educated 40-year-old, who has spent the last three years in jail, will be sentenced next week. | The Eton-educated 40-year-old, who has spent the last three years in jail, will be sentenced next week. |
Surprise outcome | Surprise outcome |
The incident took place in a remote corner of his family's massive 100,000-acre farm in the Rift Valley region, acquired by his great-grandfather the third Baron Delamere. | The incident took place in a remote corner of his family's massive 100,000-acre farm in the Rift Valley region, acquired by his great-grandfather the third Baron Delamere. |
Mr Cholmondeley told police at the time Mr Njoya was with three companions and a pack of dogs and he suspected them of poaching a gazelle. | Mr Cholmondeley told police at the time Mr Njoya was with three companions and a pack of dogs and he suspected them of poaching a gazelle. |
He said he had shot at the dogs, killing two of them. Mr Njoya was hit by a bullet, later dying on the way to hospital. | He said he had shot at the dogs, killing two of them. Mr Njoya was hit by a bullet, later dying on the way to hospital. |
Mr Cholmondeley's defence had argued that he could not have fired the deadly shot. | Mr Cholmondeley's defence had argued that he could not have fired the deadly shot. |
The judge's verdict is contrary to the non-binding not guilty verdict found by a panel of lay assessors - who do a similar job to juries in Kenya - in March. | The judge's verdict is contrary to the non-binding not guilty verdict found by a panel of lay assessors - who do a similar job to juries in Kenya - in March. |
The outcome will surprise some who followed the case closely, our correspondent says. | The outcome will surprise some who followed the case closely, our correspondent says. |
But it will please those Kenyans who believe Thomas Cholmondeley should have been prosecuted over the shooting of Maasai ranger Samson Ole Sisina on his estate in 2005. | |
Mr Cholmondeley, a divorced father of two, had admitted the shooting, but said he acted in self-defence mistaking the warden for an armed robber. | Mr Cholmondeley, a divorced father of two, had admitted the shooting, but said he acted in self-defence mistaking the warden for an armed robber. |
Much of Kenya's most fertile land was given to white settlers during the colonial era and this remains the case 46 years after independence - a fact resented by many Kenyans. | Much of Kenya's most fertile land was given to white settlers during the colonial era and this remains the case 46 years after independence - a fact resented by many Kenyans. |