This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/8031375.stm
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 6 | Version 7 |
|---|---|
| Brown best man for PM - Johnson | Brown best man for PM - Johnson |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| Health Secretary Alan Johnson has defended Gordon Brown's leadership, saying he is "better than me or anyone else" as prime minister. | Health Secretary Alan Johnson has defended Gordon Brown's leadership, saying he is "better than me or anyone else" as prime minister. |
| He called Mr Brown a "man for these times", despite several leading Labour figures criticising his performance. | He called Mr Brown a "man for these times", despite several leading Labour figures criticising his performance. |
| Communities Secretary Hazel Blears earlier wrote that ministers had been "lamentable" at communicating. | Communities Secretary Hazel Blears earlier wrote that ministers had been "lamentable" at communicating. |
| Ex-London Mayor Ken Livingstone said Mr Johnson could "probably do better" at the next election than Mr Brown. | Ex-London Mayor Ken Livingstone said Mr Johnson could "probably do better" at the next election than Mr Brown. |
| Several newspapers have questioned Mr Brown's future. The Mail on Sunday reported that some Labour plotters were pushing for Mr Johnson to replace the prime minister, and the Observer said the "first cracks" in his cabinet were beginning to appear. | Several newspapers have questioned Mr Brown's future. The Mail on Sunday reported that some Labour plotters were pushing for Mr Johnson to replace the prime minister, and the Observer said the "first cracks" in his cabinet were beginning to appear. |
| 'Not meltdown' | 'Not meltdown' |
| This follows a week in which Mr Brown suffered his first serious House of Commons setback since 2007, losing a vote on the rights of Gurkhas to settle in the UK. | This follows a week in which Mr Brown suffered his first serious House of Commons setback since 2007, losing a vote on the rights of Gurkhas to settle in the UK. |
| It also comes amid criticism of his handling of the reform of MPs' expenses - announced on Downing Street's YouTube site - and opinion polls showing Labour trailing the Conservatives. | It also comes amid criticism of his handling of the reform of MPs' expenses - announced on Downing Street's YouTube site - and opinion polls showing Labour trailing the Conservatives. |
| If you want to make comments, think about your position first. You should resign if you want to start doing articles Lindsay Hoyle, Labour MP What is Hazel Blears up to? | If you want to make comments, think about your position first. You should resign if you want to start doing articles Lindsay Hoyle, Labour MP What is Hazel Blears up to? |
| On BBC One's Andrew Marr Show, Mr Johnson said he was not sure whether presentation was Mr Brown's "strength" but added that the focus at the next election would be on "issues", such as the economy. | On BBC One's Andrew Marr Show, Mr Johnson said he was not sure whether presentation was Mr Brown's "strength" but added that the focus at the next election would be on "issues", such as the economy. |
| Asked government's position, he added: "It doesn't feel like meltdown to me." | Asked government's position, he added: "It doesn't feel like meltdown to me." |
| On the decision to push for replacing MPs' second homes allowances with flat-rate daily expenses for attendance - which was later dropped because of intense opposition - Mr Johnson said: "We knew that was a risk. | On the decision to push for replacing MPs' second homes allowances with flat-rate daily expenses for attendance - which was later dropped because of intense opposition - Mr Johnson said: "We knew that was a risk. |
| "The cabinet talked about this... I believe the cabinet is responsible for it. It can't just be Gordon Brown." | "The cabinet talked about this... I believe the cabinet is responsible for it. It can't just be Gordon Brown." |
| 'Second-order issues' | 'Second-order issues' |
| Discussing whether he would launch a bid for the leadership, Mr Johnson said: "I am not saying there's no circumstances." | Discussing whether he would launch a bid for the leadership, Mr Johnson said: "I am not saying there's no circumstances." |
| But he added: "I have no aspiration for the leader. My aspiration was for the deputy leadership and I couldn't even get that. | But he added: "I have no aspiration for the leader. My aspiration was for the deputy leadership and I couldn't even get that. |
| "I am not driven by this ambition. I want to be part of a good government and I want it to be led by Gordon Brown. | "I am not driven by this ambition. I want to be part of a good government and I want it to be led by Gordon Brown. |
| "I actually admire Gordon Brown tremendously. I think he is a man for these times." | "I actually admire Gordon Brown tremendously. I think he is a man for these times." |
| He said photo opportunities and "looking good on YouTube" were "second-order issues", adding: "He can do it [the job of prime minister] and he can do it a lot better than me or anyone else." | He said photo opportunities and "looking good on YouTube" were "second-order issues", adding: "He can do it [the job of prime minister] and he can do it a lot better than me or anyone else." |
| 'Speaks their language' | 'Speaks their language' |
| However, on the same programme, Labour's Mr Livingstone said: "I think Alan Johnson will probably do better at the next election than Gordon Brown... particularly in terms of recapturing our working-class support." | However, on the same programme, Labour's Mr Livingstone said: "I think Alan Johnson will probably do better at the next election than Gordon Brown... particularly in terms of recapturing our working-class support." |
| He added: "Alan speaks their language. If you want to undermine the BNP, Johnson could do that." | He added: "Alan speaks their language. If you want to undermine the BNP, Johnson could do that." |
| In her article for The Observer, Ms Blears said the public did not believe many government policy announcements. | In her article for The Observer, Ms Blears said the public did not believe many government policy announcements. |
| Hazel Blears said it was wrong to say she was criticising Mr Brown | |
| She wrote: "Promote your message via YouTube if you want to. But it is no substitute for knocking on doors or setting up a stall in the town centre." | She wrote: "Promote your message via YouTube if you want to. But it is no substitute for knocking on doors or setting up a stall in the town centre." |
| Ms Blears said Mr Brown would lead the party into the next election, but that the government must appear more "human" to defeat the Tories. | Ms Blears said Mr Brown would lead the party into the next election, but that the government must appear more "human" to defeat the Tories. |
| "Labour ministers have a collective responsibility for the government's lamentable failure to get our message across," she said. | "Labour ministers have a collective responsibility for the government's lamentable failure to get our message across," she said. |
| In a statement later, she said: "Any suggestion that I intended what I wrote as criticism of him [Mr Brown] or his leadership is completely wrong. I fully support the collective decisions we take." | In a statement later, she said: "Any suggestion that I intended what I wrote as criticism of him [Mr Brown] or his leadership is completely wrong. I fully support the collective decisions we take." |
| 'Sniping and griping' | 'Sniping and griping' |
| Asked about media reaction to Ms Blears' comments, Mr Johnson said: "Hazel would be absolutely distraught to see that her article is being used in this way." | Asked about media reaction to Ms Blears' comments, Mr Johnson said: "Hazel would be absolutely distraught to see that her article is being used in this way." |
| But Lindsay Hoyle, Labour MP for Chorley, said there should be less "sniping and griping" from cabinet ministers. | But Lindsay Hoyle, Labour MP for Chorley, said there should be less "sniping and griping" from cabinet ministers. |
| He added: "In fact, if you're in cabinet you have a collective responsibility and that collective responsibility is: 'Keep out of the argument, keep out of the media, let's have less comment'. | He added: "In fact, if you're in cabinet you have a collective responsibility and that collective responsibility is: 'Keep out of the argument, keep out of the media, let's have less comment'. |
| "And if you want to make comments, think about your position first. You should resign if you want to start doing articles." | "And if you want to make comments, think about your position first. You should resign if you want to start doing articles." |
| Geraldine Smith, Labour MP for Morecambe and Lunesdale , agreed, saying: "What Hazel has done is inappropriate. In attacking the government she is attacking herself - what happened to collective responsibility? | Geraldine Smith, Labour MP for Morecambe and Lunesdale , agreed, saying: "What Hazel has done is inappropriate. In attacking the government she is attacking herself - what happened to collective responsibility? |
| "The place to raise these matters is in cabinet. If she wants to speak out and criticise, she should be on the back benches." | "The place to raise these matters is in cabinet. If she wants to speak out and criticise, she should be on the back benches." |
| Housing Minister Margaret Beckett told BBC One's Politics Show Ms Blears was "certainly right that the [Labour] campaign is not as effective as it should be". | Housing Minister Margaret Beckett told BBC One's Politics Show Ms Blears was "certainly right that the [Labour] campaign is not as effective as it should be". |
| She said: "It's all of us that have to be responsible for communicating where we are." | She said: "It's all of us that have to be responsible for communicating where we are." |
| Former deputy prime minister John Prescott earlier urged Labour politicians who had criticised the prime minister - including former Home Secretary Charles Clarke who said recent events made him "ashamed" to be a Labour MP - to stop complaining and get behind the party. | Former deputy prime minister John Prescott earlier urged Labour politicians who had criticised the prime minister - including former Home Secretary Charles Clarke who said recent events made him "ashamed" to be a Labour MP - to stop complaining and get behind the party. |
| Mrs Beckett agreed, saying she had been "horrified by what Charles said" and adding: "I'm very proud to be a Labour MP." | Mrs Beckett agreed, saying she had been "horrified by what Charles said" and adding: "I'm very proud to be a Labour MP." |