This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/scotland/south_of_scotland/8000580.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Scots nuclear stance criticised | Scots nuclear stance criticised |
(1 day later) | |
Two south of Scotland MPs have hit out at the Scottish Government's refusal to approve new nuclear plants being built. | Two south of Scotland MPs have hit out at the Scottish Government's refusal to approve new nuclear plants being built. |
Labour's Russell Brown and Tory David Mundell said it could cost jobs in Dumfries and Galloway where a station was being decommissioned. | Labour's Russell Brown and Tory David Mundell said it could cost jobs in Dumfries and Galloway where a station was being decommissioned. |
The UK Government has released a list of 11 sites in England and Wales where new plants could be built. | The UK Government has released a list of 11 sites in England and Wales where new plants could be built. |
But the SNP said Scotland was right to reject "dangerous, unnecessary and costly" power stations. | But the SNP said Scotland was right to reject "dangerous, unnecessary and costly" power stations. |
The UK Government's list of potential sites included three in Cumbria, just south of the border between Scotland and England. | The UK Government's list of potential sites included three in Cumbria, just south of the border between Scotland and England. |
The risks and uncertainties of nuclear power, in terms of waste disposal, decommissioning, security and health concerns, or cost, are far too great Mike Weir MPSNP energy spokesman | The risks and uncertainties of nuclear power, in terms of waste disposal, decommissioning, security and health concerns, or cost, are far too great Mike Weir MPSNP energy spokesman |
Mr Brown said the Scottish Government's stance would mean no replacement could be built for the Chapelcross plant in Annan, which is being decommissioned. | Mr Brown said the Scottish Government's stance would mean no replacement could be built for the Chapelcross plant in Annan, which is being decommissioned. |
He said: "The SNP's anti-nuclear dogma runs the risk of costing jobs in our region. | He said: "The SNP's anti-nuclear dogma runs the risk of costing jobs in our region. |
"Over the last 50 years Dumfriesshire has benefited massively from the highly-skilled local jobs at Chapelcross. | "Over the last 50 years Dumfriesshire has benefited massively from the highly-skilled local jobs at Chapelcross. |
"This list of sites for potential new nuclear power plants underlines that other communities in England and Wales who have benefited equally from the nuclear industry could be boosted by a new generation of skilled jobs." | "This list of sites for potential new nuclear power plants underlines that other communities in England and Wales who have benefited equally from the nuclear industry could be boosted by a new generation of skilled jobs." |
Mr Mundell said he was also disappointed not to see Chapelcross on the list of potential sites. | Mr Mundell said he was also disappointed not to see Chapelcross on the list of potential sites. |
"We must ensure security of supply and a balanced energy mix for the future," he said. | "We must ensure security of supply and a balanced energy mix for the future," he said. |
"That is why today's announcement is so disappointing and worrying for Scotland." | "That is why today's announcement is so disappointing and worrying for Scotland." |
UK Energy Secretary Ed Miliband also said he hoped the Scottish Government might review its position. | UK Energy Secretary Ed Miliband also said he hoped the Scottish Government might review its position. |
Future demand | Future demand |
He said two new nuclear stations alongside existing ones at Hunterston and Torness could mean up to £5.6bn investment and nearly 9,000 jobs created in building them. | He said two new nuclear stations alongside existing ones at Hunterston and Torness could mean up to £5.6bn investment and nearly 9,000 jobs created in building them. |
However, the SNP's Westminster energy spokesman, Mike Weir, said Mr Miliband was "wasting his breath". | However, the SNP's Westminster energy spokesman, Mike Weir, said Mr Miliband was "wasting his breath". |
He said Scotland was "right to reject the development of dangerous, unnecessary and costly new nuclear power stations". | He said Scotland was "right to reject the development of dangerous, unnecessary and costly new nuclear power stations". |
He added: "The risks and uncertainties of nuclear power, in terms of waste disposal, decommissioning, security and health concerns, or cost, are far too great. | He added: "The risks and uncertainties of nuclear power, in terms of waste disposal, decommissioning, security and health concerns, or cost, are far too great. |
"Without nuclear power Scotland has the natural resources to generate clean, green power. | "Without nuclear power Scotland has the natural resources to generate clean, green power. |
"Harnessing that potential can meet our future energy demands several times over, while tackling climate change." | "Harnessing that potential can meet our future energy demands several times over, while tackling climate change." |
Previous version
1
Next version