This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/wear/7964916.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 2 | Version 3 |
---|---|
Artist in sculpture tragedy fined | Artist in sculpture tragedy fined |
(about 21 hours later) | |
The creator of an inflatable artwork which blew away in a County Durham park killing two women has been fined £10,000 for health and safety breaches. | The creator of an inflatable artwork which blew away in a County Durham park killing two women has been fined £10,000 for health and safety breaches. |
Maurice Agis, 77, from London, was convicted at Newcastle Crown Court of breaches relating to the 1974 Act. | Maurice Agis, 77, from London, was convicted at Newcastle Crown Court of breaches relating to the 1974 Act. |
Two women, Elizabeth Collings and Claire Furmedge, fell from his Dreamspace sculpture in July 2006. | Two women, Elizabeth Collings and Claire Furmedge, fell from his Dreamspace sculpture in July 2006. |
After the hearing, relatives of the two dead women said they were shocked at the level of neglect by all concerned. | After the hearing, relatives of the two dead women said they were shocked at the level of neglect by all concerned. |
Agis had been charged with manslaughter, but the jury was discharged after failing to reach a verdict. | Agis had been charged with manslaughter, but the jury was discharged after failing to reach a verdict. |
Maurice Agis denied all charges relating to the incident in July 2006 | Maurice Agis denied all charges relating to the incident in July 2006 |
Brouhaha International, which organised the tour of Dreamspace, was fined £4,000 and Chester-Le-Street District council, which helped organise the event, was fined £20,000. | Brouhaha International, which organised the tour of Dreamspace, was fined £4,000 and Chester-Le-Street District council, which helped organise the event, was fined £20,000. |
Agis was ordered to pay off the fine at £80 a month or face six months in prison. | Agis was ordered to pay off the fine at £80 a month or face six months in prison. |
Ms Furmedge, 38, from Chester-le-Street, and Ms Collings, 68, from Seaham, died and 13 others were injured when the artwork broke free from its moorings at Riverside Park in Chester-le-Street. | Ms Furmedge, 38, from Chester-le-Street, and Ms Collings, 68, from Seaham, died and 13 others were injured when the artwork broke free from its moorings at Riverside Park in Chester-le-Street. |
It then flipped over before crashing into a CCTV pole where it deflated. | It then flipped over before crashing into a CCTV pole where it deflated. |
The life of one victim, three-year-old Rosie Wright, was saved by passing anaesthetist Peter Evans. | The life of one victim, three-year-old Rosie Wright, was saved by passing anaesthetist Peter Evans. |
Passing sentence, Mrs Justice Cox said that no fine she imposed could compensate the families and those injured for their loss or distress. | Passing sentence, Mrs Justice Cox said that no fine she imposed could compensate the families and those injured for their loss or distress. |
But she added she had to take into account Agis's income - just his £125-a-week state pension - when imposing the fine. | But she added she had to take into account Agis's income - just his £125-a-week state pension - when imposing the fine. |
The judge told Agis, who kept his head bowed throughout the sentencing hearing, that he had failed to properly design an anchorage system that would have prevented the tragedy happening. | The judge told Agis, who kept his head bowed throughout the sentencing hearing, that he had failed to properly design an anchorage system that would have prevented the tragedy happening. |
The families say they they have been cheated of justice. | The families say they they have been cheated of justice. |
She told him: "In my view you were more concerned with the visual impact and the public's interaction than the practicalities of holding it down." | She told him: "In my view you were more concerned with the visual impact and the public's interaction than the practicalities of holding it down." |
Sally Moore, of Leigh Day & Co, read a statement from the relatives of the dead women, which said: "Anne and Claire were killed in the most appalling circumstances. | Sally Moore, of Leigh Day & Co, read a statement from the relatives of the dead women, which said: "Anne and Claire were killed in the most appalling circumstances. |
"Their deaths were caused by a catalogue of failure, complacency and incompetence on the part of Maurice Agis, Chester le Street District Council and Brouhaha International. | "Their deaths were caused by a catalogue of failure, complacency and incompetence on the part of Maurice Agis, Chester le Street District Council and Brouhaha International. |
"The two families are relieved that this process is over, but extremely disappointed and angry that the artist was not convicted of gross negligence manslaughter charges. | "The two families are relieved that this process is over, but extremely disappointed and angry that the artist was not convicted of gross negligence manslaughter charges. |
"They feel that the decision by the Crown Prosecution Service not retry the case means that the criminal justice system has let them down." | "They feel that the decision by the Crown Prosecution Service not retry the case means that the criminal justice system has let them down." |
'Truly sorry' | 'Truly sorry' |
In a statement released after the hearing, Agis of Kirton Gardens, Bethnal Green, said: "The memories of that day fill me with a profound sadness. | In a statement released after the hearing, Agis of Kirton Gardens, Bethnal Green, said: "The memories of that day fill me with a profound sadness. |
"I continue to be consumed by the tragedy of those events, the suffering of those affected and the grief and pain that they must continue to feel. | "I continue to be consumed by the tragedy of those events, the suffering of those affected and the grief and pain that they must continue to feel. |
"Never, for one moment, have I ever thought that Dreamspace posed a risk to life. | "Never, for one moment, have I ever thought that Dreamspace posed a risk to life. |
"I am truly sorry that my Dreamspace Artwork, designed to bring joy, pleasure and happiness into people's lives, could also be the source of such pain." | "I am truly sorry that my Dreamspace Artwork, designed to bring joy, pleasure and happiness into people's lives, could also be the source of such pain." |
He also pledged that the artwork would never be displayed again. | He also pledged that the artwork would never be displayed again. |
Chester-le-Street Council, which admitted health and safety breaches, said it accepted the court's decision and offered its condolences to the families of those who had died. |