This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/7908607.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Council house blues | Council house blues |
(about 9 hours later) | |
By Richard Reeves Presenter, Analysis, BBC Radio 4 | By Richard Reeves Presenter, Analysis, BBC Radio 4 |
The government says councils should be building more social housing - but can they avoid repeating past mistakes? | The government says councils should be building more social housing - but can they avoid repeating past mistakes? |
One of the five evils William Beveridge hoped to eradicate in his plans for the post-war welfare state was "squalor". | One of the five evils William Beveridge hoped to eradicate in his plans for the post-war welfare state was "squalor". |
After the sacrifices of the Second World War, families should no longer have to endure cramped, damp homes provided by unscrupulous owners. The state would become landlord instead. | After the sacrifices of the Second World War, families should no longer have to endure cramped, damp homes provided by unscrupulous owners. The state would become landlord instead. |
After falling out of favour during the Thatcher and Blair administrations, council housing is back on the political agenda. | After falling out of favour during the Thatcher and Blair administrations, council housing is back on the political agenda. |
The government is encouraging councils to start building again. Kate Barker, who has reviewed the housing market for Gordon Brown, is urging the Treasury to find £6bn to build a new generation of council housing. | The government is encouraging councils to start building again. Kate Barker, who has reviewed the housing market for Gordon Brown, is urging the Treasury to find £6bn to build a new generation of council housing. |
Lifeline | Lifeline |
As a small, heavily-populated island with strict planning laws, Britain is unable to supply decent, affordable housing to people on low incomes. | As a small, heavily-populated island with strict planning laws, Britain is unable to supply decent, affordable housing to people on low incomes. |
FIND OUT MORE class="" href="/1/hi/uk/7911803.stm">Audio slideshow: On the estate Social housing will remain a vital arm of the welfare state for the foreseeable future. | |
It has been a lifeline for people like Emran Shaheen. He has just moved into a housing association flat in south London. | It has been a lifeline for people like Emran Shaheen. He has just moved into a housing association flat in south London. |
Until recently, both his and his brother's family had been sharing a two-bedroom flat. | Until recently, both his and his brother's family had been sharing a two-bedroom flat. |
"I got married, had my wife there, when [my brother] got married, he had his wife there so we ended up being 10 people in one property in the end," he told me. | "I got married, had my wife there, when [my brother] got married, he had his wife there so we ended up being 10 people in one property in the end," he told me. |
But before investing more in state housing, it is important to learn the lessons of the past. | But before investing more in state housing, it is important to learn the lessons of the past. |
The original mission of social housing was not simply to put a roof over people's heads, but to ensure that poor people were able to remain in the mainstream of society, rather than being distanced by their poverty; and to provide a secure base upon which people could seek work. | The original mission of social housing was not simply to put a roof over people's heads, but to ensure that poor people were able to remain in the mainstream of society, rather than being distanced by their poverty; and to provide a secure base upon which people could seek work. |
On both these counts, the evidence suggests social housing has been failing in recent decades. | On both these counts, the evidence suggests social housing has been failing in recent decades. |
'Living tapestry' | 'Living tapestry' |
Post-war Labour housing minister Nye Bevan argued for a social mix on council estates. | Post-war Labour housing minister Nye Bevan argued for a social mix on council estates. |
He aimed to replicate "the lovely feature of the English and Welsh village, where the doctor, the grocer, the butcher and farm labourer all lived on the same street - the living tapestry of a mixed community." | He aimed to replicate "the lovely feature of the English and Welsh village, where the doctor, the grocer, the butcher and farm labourer all lived on the same street - the living tapestry of a mixed community." |
LISTEN TO THE PROGRAMME Analysis: Anti-social housing will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4Thursday 26 February at 2030 GMTOr subscribe to the programme's podcast. Until the 1980s, council housing was in fact embraced by a fairly broad swathe of the population. | LISTEN TO THE PROGRAMME Analysis: Anti-social housing will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4Thursday 26 February at 2030 GMTOr subscribe to the programme's podcast. Until the 1980s, council housing was in fact embraced by a fairly broad swathe of the population. |
Since then, council estates have seen increased concentration of social problems, in part because of a shift towards providing homes on the basis of social need. | Since then, council estates have seen increased concentration of social problems, in part because of a shift towards providing homes on the basis of social need. |
Professor John Hills from the London School of Economics is Britain's leading analyst of social housing. | Professor John Hills from the London School of Economics is Britain's leading analyst of social housing. |
He is worried about the consequences of this policy. | He is worried about the consequences of this policy. |
"If you had started saying what we want is housing provided for people in greatest need, I don't think anybody in their right mind would have thought let's build it all in big estates and put all those people together in the same place." | "If you had started saying what we want is housing provided for people in greatest need, I don't think anybody in their right mind would have thought let's build it all in big estates and put all those people together in the same place." |
Most working-age adults in social housing are out of paid work. Seven out of 10 tenant families are in the bottom two-fifths of the population in terms of income. | Most working-age adults in social housing are out of paid work. Seven out of 10 tenant families are in the bottom two-fifths of the population in terms of income. |
Social housing tenants are twice as likely to be unemployed and twice as likely to be lone parents as those living in private rented accommodation or their own homes. | Social housing tenants are twice as likely to be unemployed and twice as likely to be lone parents as those living in private rented accommodation or their own homes. |
"You are then creating a situation where one group of people, who end up with difficulties in the labour market to start with, are away from contact with the run-of-the-mill services, jobs, knowledge about jobs that one would expect in the rest of society," says Hills. | "You are then creating a situation where one group of people, who end up with difficulties in the labour market to start with, are away from contact with the run-of-the-mill services, jobs, knowledge about jobs that one would expect in the rest of society," says Hills. |
"From the point of view of society as a whole, the idea of walling away one group of people from the rest of the society, so that people become invisible to the mainstream, is not a healthy part of the political process." | "From the point of view of society as a whole, the idea of walling away one group of people from the rest of the society, so that people become invisible to the mainstream, is not a healthy part of the political process." |
Security | Security |
If social housing is - for good reason - going to be focused on the most needy, the only way to avoid vast monoculture estates is to build "mixed tenure" developments. | If social housing is - for good reason - going to be focused on the most needy, the only way to avoid vast monoculture estates is to build "mixed tenure" developments. |
What people want is a home, not just somewhere to lay down their head for a few nights Alan Walter, Defend Council Housing Housing Associations - private but not-for-profit providers - were leading this charge until they were hit hard by the downturn in the owner-occupied sector, which helped fund these developments. | What people want is a home, not just somewhere to lay down their head for a few nights Alan Walter, Defend Council Housing Housing Associations - private but not-for-profit providers - were leading this charge until they were hit hard by the downturn in the owner-occupied sector, which helped fund these developments. |
But there is no reason why local authorities should not show more imagination in the way they construct estates, and go for a better social mix. | But there is no reason why local authorities should not show more imagination in the way they construct estates, and go for a better social mix. |
One of the most controversial and sensitive areas in social housing policy is security of tenure. | One of the most controversial and sensitive areas in social housing policy is security of tenure. |
This means that once you have got a council tenancy you can keep it, regardless of any later changes in family size or income. In theory, you can go from an impoverished single parent of five to a millionaire lottery winner and keep your council flat. | This means that once you have got a council tenancy you can keep it, regardless of any later changes in family size or income. In theory, you can go from an impoverished single parent of five to a millionaire lottery winner and keep your council flat. |
One of the main arguments for this policy is to ensure that social housing tenants are not put off going into a job. | One of the main arguments for this policy is to ensure that social housing tenants are not put off going into a job. |
The fear of many policymakers is that if people fear losing their home if they succeed in getting paid work they will be less likely to look for a job. | The fear of many policymakers is that if people fear losing their home if they succeed in getting paid work they will be less likely to look for a job. |
Alan Walter, of Defend Council Housing, wants to ensure social housing tenants do not face any more insecurity. | Alan Walter, of Defend Council Housing, wants to ensure social housing tenants do not face any more insecurity. |
"What people want is a home, not just somewhere to lay down their head for a few nights," he says. | "What people want is a home, not just somewhere to lay down their head for a few nights," he says. |
"There is something that I find really offensive when you have politicians talking about council housing as if it is just a short-term fallback for those in desperate need." | "There is something that I find really offensive when you have politicians talking about council housing as if it is just a short-term fallback for those in desperate need." |
On the other hand, security of tenure does not appear to having the positive effects on levels of employment that the economic textbooks suggest it should. | On the other hand, security of tenure does not appear to having the positive effects on levels of employment that the economic textbooks suggest it should. |
Social housing tenants are significantly less likely to move into paid work than private renters. | Social housing tenants are significantly less likely to move into paid work than private renters. |
The goals of social housing remain salient: to provide decent, affordable homes for those unable to secure them, to allow children of low-income families to grow up in the mainstream of society, and to provide adults with a platform upon which to build independent lives and careers. | The goals of social housing remain salient: to provide decent, affordable homes for those unable to secure them, to allow children of low-income families to grow up in the mainstream of society, and to provide adults with a platform upon which to build independent lives and careers. |
The trouble is, social housing is not delivering on its promise. On current trends, it risks becoming anti-social housing. | The trouble is, social housing is not delivering on its promise. On current trends, it risks becoming anti-social housing. |
Richard Reeves is director of the independent think tank Demos. He presents Analysis: Anti-social Housing on BBC Radio 4 on Thursday 26 February at 2030 GMT. Or subscribe to the programme's podcast. | Richard Reeves is director of the independent think tank Demos. He presents Analysis: Anti-social Housing on BBC Radio 4 on Thursday 26 February at 2030 GMT. Or subscribe to the programme's podcast. |
Previous version
1
Next version