This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/essex/7907779.stm
The article has changed 13 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 9 | Version 10 |
|---|---|
| Barrymore police missed evidence | Barrymore police missed evidence |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| Blood and items left near the body of a man found dead by Michael Barrymore's swimming pool were not properly investigated, a report has found. | Blood and items left near the body of a man found dead by Michael Barrymore's swimming pool were not properly investigated, a report has found. |
| Stuart Lubbock, 31, died at the entertainer's home in 2001. | Stuart Lubbock, 31, died at the entertainer's home in 2001. |
| The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) inquiry noted two pieces of evidence - a pool thermometer and a door handle - were not seized. | The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) inquiry noted two pieces of evidence - a pool thermometer and a door handle - were not seized. |
| Police also failed to "promptly investigate" blood left on the victim's boxer shorts, towels and a robe. | Police also failed to "promptly investigate" blood left on the victim's boxer shorts, towels and a robe. |
| The IPCC upheld six of 36 complaints and allegations made by Stuart's father, Terry Lubbock. | The IPCC upheld six of 36 complaints and allegations made by Stuart's father, Terry Lubbock. |
| No one has ever been charged in connection with the death of Mr Lubbock and Mr Barrymore has always denied involvement. | No one has ever been charged in connection with the death of Mr Lubbock and Mr Barrymore has always denied involvement. |
| These shortcomings must be frustrating and distressing for Mr Lubbock, who has worked tirelessly to find out what happened to his son IPCC Commissioner David Petch | These shortcomings must be frustrating and distressing for Mr Lubbock, who has worked tirelessly to find out what happened to his son IPCC Commissioner David Petch |
| Post-mortem tests showed Mr Lubbock suffered internal injuries which suggested sexual assault. | Post-mortem tests showed Mr Lubbock suffered internal injuries which suggested sexual assault. |
| He had also taken ecstasy, cocaine and alcohol before he died. | He had also taken ecstasy, cocaine and alcohol before he died. |
| A coroner recorded an open verdict into Mr Lubbock's death following an inquest in September 2002. | A coroner recorded an open verdict into Mr Lubbock's death following an inquest in September 2002. |
| The IPCC report revealed that the two pieces of evidence which were not seized by police and subsequently went missing could have been crucial to the case. | The IPCC report revealed that the two pieces of evidence which were not seized by police and subsequently went missing could have been crucial to the case. |
| The swimming pool thermometer appears in photographs of the scene but, along with the detached door handle, was never forensically tested. | The swimming pool thermometer appears in photographs of the scene but, along with the detached door handle, was never forensically tested. |
| It has not been possible for the police to establish whether or not the implements were used to cause Mr Lubbock's injuries, the IPCC said. | |
| 'Lingering fears' | 'Lingering fears' |
| The complaints which were upheld include: the scene not being effectively preserved; unauthorised people allowed to stay at the scene; a member of the public being allowed to take the temperature of the swimming pool, and the investigation being suspended prematurely. | The complaints which were upheld include: the scene not being effectively preserved; unauthorised people allowed to stay at the scene; a member of the public being allowed to take the temperature of the swimming pool, and the investigation being suspended prematurely. |
| IPCC Commissioner David Petch said: "There are absolutely no grounds to support allegations that officers acted corruptly. | IPCC Commissioner David Petch said: "There are absolutely no grounds to support allegations that officers acted corruptly. |
| "The view that the entire investigation was incompetent is not borne out by the bulk of the evidence. | "The view that the entire investigation was incompetent is not borne out by the bulk of the evidence. |
| Terry Lubbock welcomes IPCC report | Terry Lubbock welcomes IPCC report |
| "But undoubtedly there were failings in some aspects of the investigation. | "But undoubtedly there were failings in some aspects of the investigation. |
| "As a consequence there are lingering fears that, because the integrity of the scene was not properly preserved, important evidence may have been lost." | "As a consequence there are lingering fears that, because the integrity of the scene was not properly preserved, important evidence may have been lost." |
| He added: "In our view the decision in December 2001 to suspend the investigation was premature - at that time some key forensic work had not been completed and some inquiries were still outstanding. | He added: "In our view the decision in December 2001 to suspend the investigation was premature - at that time some key forensic work had not been completed and some inquiries were still outstanding. |
| "We will probably never know whether the missing thermometer and door handle were evidentially important, but not securing these items was a failure and leaves questions unanswered. | "We will probably never know whether the missing thermometer and door handle were evidentially important, but not securing these items was a failure and leaves questions unanswered. |
| "All of these shortcomings must be frustrating and distressing for Mr Lubbock, who has worked tirelessly to find out what happened to his son." | "All of these shortcomings must be frustrating and distressing for Mr Lubbock, who has worked tirelessly to find out what happened to his son." |
| Mr Barrymore has always denied involvement in Mr Lubbock's death | Mr Barrymore has always denied involvement in Mr Lubbock's death |
| Terry Lubbock said the IPCC report revealed "significant" police errors. | Terry Lubbock said the IPCC report revealed "significant" police errors. |
| He said: "If they had done the job properly in the first place we would have had people in court charged. I am sure of that. | He said: "If they had done the job properly in the first place we would have had people in court charged. I am sure of that. |
| "And that is what I am still pursuing. I want justice to be done and I will not rest until it is." | "And that is what I am still pursuing. I want justice to be done and I will not rest until it is." |
| The IPCC began its inquiry in March 2007 after receiving complaints from Mr Lubbock. | The IPCC began its inquiry in March 2007 after receiving complaints from Mr Lubbock. |
| Deputy Chief Constable of Essex Police Andy Bliss said he had visited Mr Lubbock to deliver a personal apology on behalf of the force. | Deputy Chief Constable of Essex Police Andy Bliss said he had visited Mr Lubbock to deliver a personal apology on behalf of the force. |
| "Over the last eight years, Essex Police has taken a number of steps to improve investigations into suspicious deaths. | "Over the last eight years, Essex Police has taken a number of steps to improve investigations into suspicious deaths. |
| "Since this investigation, Essex Police has introduced specific training for dealing with suspicious deaths and we continually seek to improve this. | "Since this investigation, Essex Police has introduced specific training for dealing with suspicious deaths and we continually seek to improve this. |
| "We remain determined to find out what happened to Stuart back in March 2001. A new investigation began in 2006 and this remains ongoing." | "We remain determined to find out what happened to Stuart back in March 2001. A new investigation began in 2006 and this remains ongoing." |