This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/south_asia/7884222.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Pashtun influx fuels Karachi tensions | |
(about 2 hours later) | |
By Syed Shoaib Hasan BBC News, Karachi Karachi has been plagued by violence for much of the last 20 years | By Syed Shoaib Hasan BBC News, Karachi Karachi has been plagued by violence for much of the last 20 years |
"We are doing our best to prevent them from taking over," says Mohammad Rafiq earnestly as he sits in the crowded room in Karachi. | "We are doing our best to prevent them from taking over," says Mohammad Rafiq earnestly as he sits in the crowded room in Karachi. |
He is referring to Taleban militants who have come to the city from Pakistan's tribal areas such as North and South Waziristan who "want to take over Karachi". | He is referring to Taleban militants who have come to the city from Pakistan's tribal areas such as North and South Waziristan who "want to take over Karachi". |
Rafiq, a primary school teacher, is a resident of Baldia town, a suburb of Karachi. | Rafiq, a primary school teacher, is a resident of Baldia town, a suburb of Karachi. |
He is also a member of a neighbourhood, or sector, office of the MQM (United National Movement) political party for his area. | He is also a member of a neighbourhood, or sector, office of the MQM (United National Movement) political party for his area. |
'Bully and kill' | 'Bully and kill' |
Karachi, on the coast of Pakistan's southern Sindh province, is the country's largest city. | Karachi, on the coast of Pakistan's southern Sindh province, is the country's largest city. |
It is also the South Asian nation's financial capital and main port. | It is also the South Asian nation's financial capital and main port. |
The MQM, which is allied to Pakistan's ruling Pakistan People's Party (PPP), is politically in control of Karachi. | The MQM, which is allied to Pakistan's ruling Pakistan People's Party (PPP), is politically in control of Karachi. |
Four armed men came to the back of the market on two bikes... they only targeted Pashtun businesses Azmatullah Khan class="" href="/1/hi/world/south_asia/7886460.stm">Karachi's Taleban threat | |
The party draws its strength from a mainly middle class electorate, made up of Urdu-speaking people, descendants of migrants from India after partition in 1947. | The party draws its strength from a mainly middle class electorate, made up of Urdu-speaking people, descendants of migrants from India after partition in 1947. |
Its detractors have often complained that it has used its political strength to bully and even kill opponents. | Its detractors have often complained that it has used its political strength to bully and even kill opponents. |
The MQM, however, strongly denies this allegations. | The MQM, however, strongly denies this allegations. |
"Our job is to find solutions for neighbourhood problems at the local level," says Farooq Sattar, a central government minister and senior MQM leader. | "Our job is to find solutions for neighbourhood problems at the local level," says Farooq Sattar, a central government minister and senior MQM leader. |
"We also inform the top leadership if there are matters here that are beyond our control." | "We also inform the top leadership if there are matters here that are beyond our control." |
Of late these have been primarily to do with what the MQM has called the "Talebanisation" of Karachi. | Of late these have been primarily to do with what the MQM has called the "Talebanisation" of Karachi. |
It says that more and more people are migrating to Karachi from different parts of Pakistan, especially from the tribal areas. | It says that more and more people are migrating to Karachi from different parts of Pakistan, especially from the tribal areas. |
"The Taleban don't want to be concentrated in the northern areas and are looking for other options," says Dr Sattar. | "The Taleban don't want to be concentrated in the northern areas and are looking for other options," says Dr Sattar. |
De facto rulers | De facto rulers |
Urban experts agree, pointing out that there has also been a substantial rise in migrants into Karachi from the North West Frontier Province's Pashtun community. | Urban experts agree, pointing out that there has also been a substantial rise in migrants into Karachi from the North West Frontier Province's Pashtun community. |
Tension is rising in Karachi | Tension is rising in Karachi |
It is perhaps this fact which is most galling for the MQM, which stormed into control of Karachi following ethnic riots which began in the mid-1980s. | It is perhaps this fact which is most galling for the MQM, which stormed into control of Karachi following ethnic riots which began in the mid-1980s. |
At that time, disagreements over the identity question led to clashes between the Urdu-speaking and Pashtun-speaking communities. | At that time, disagreements over the identity question led to clashes between the Urdu-speaking and Pashtun-speaking communities. |
The MQM rose to power on the back of these riots which left hundreds of people dead and established the party's position in Karachi. | The MQM rose to power on the back of these riots which left hundreds of people dead and established the party's position in Karachi. |
But critics have accused the party of using the "ethnic card" to keep control over Karachi. | But critics have accused the party of using the "ethnic card" to keep control over Karachi. |
Ethnicity remains a touchy topic in the metropolis and since 2007 there have been rumblings of a return to the problems of before. | Ethnicity remains a touchy topic in the metropolis and since 2007 there have been rumblings of a return to the problems of before. |
In November, more than 40 people were killed in two days of ethnic-related killings. | In November, more than 40 people were killed in two days of ethnic-related killings. |
"Riots and violence did take place between 1985 and 1988, but our leaders met and reached a conclusive peace accord," says Aminullah Khattak, secretary general of the Sindh chapter of the mostly Pashtun Awami National Party (ANP). | "Riots and violence did take place between 1985 and 1988, but our leaders met and reached a conclusive peace accord," says Aminullah Khattak, secretary general of the Sindh chapter of the mostly Pashtun Awami National Party (ANP). |
"We wanted to end it, and it did end at that time." | "We wanted to end it, and it did end at that time." |
'Menial activities' | 'Menial activities' |
But Mr Khattak now says that the issue has once again reared its head, this times he feels because of economic factors. | But Mr Khattak now says that the issue has once again reared its head, this times he feels because of economic factors. |
The MQM says that Karachi is at risk of 'Talebanisation' | The MQM says that Karachi is at risk of 'Talebanisation' |
"The thing that has started it again is that the Pashtuns living over here have progressed economically," he says. | "The thing that has started it again is that the Pashtuns living over here have progressed economically," he says. |
"Some people believe that they will remain watchmen or labourers, or remain engaged in menial economic activities all their lives. | "Some people believe that they will remain watchmen or labourers, or remain engaged in menial economic activities all their lives. |
"But they've become well educated, they've progressed economically, they want to get better jobs." | "But they've become well educated, they've progressed economically, they want to get better jobs." |
The ANP argues that "Talebanisation" is not a problem in Karachi, but just a ruse for a movement against upwardly-mobile Pashtuns. | The ANP argues that "Talebanisation" is not a problem in Karachi, but just a ruse for a movement against upwardly-mobile Pashtuns. |
Evidence of that movement is all too clear to Azmatullah Khan, a pharmacy student, as he stands on the ruins of his family business which was burnt to the ground in December. | Evidence of that movement is all too clear to Azmatullah Khan, a pharmacy student, as he stands on the ruins of his family business which was burnt to the ground in December. |
"Four armed men came to the back of the market on two bikes," he says. | "Four armed men came to the back of the market on two bikes," he says. |
"They threw some kind of chemicals... and started a fire which spread if water was thrown on it. | "They threw some kind of chemicals... and started a fire which spread if water was thrown on it. |
"You can see yourselves, they only targeted Pashtun businesses," he says while bitterly pointing to nearby timber shops which remain intact and open. | "You can see yourselves, they only targeted Pashtun businesses," he says while bitterly pointing to nearby timber shops which remain intact and open. |
"If you look at the situation in Karachi now, it is the Pashtun community which is facing the brunt of the problems," says Ismail Khan, a member of the ANP provincial executive committee. | "If you look at the situation in Karachi now, it is the Pashtun community which is facing the brunt of the problems," says Ismail Khan, a member of the ANP provincial executive committee. |
"Pashtun areas are the least developed in terms of basic amenities, as well as facilities such as hospitals and schools. | "Pashtun areas are the least developed in terms of basic amenities, as well as facilities such as hospitals and schools. |
"In addition, Pashtuns are said to be the root of all troubles." | "In addition, Pashtuns are said to be the root of all troubles." |
'Taleban ideas' | 'Taleban ideas' |
Ismail Khan believes that the MQM is behind this, and its principal motive is to get Pashtuns to give up the land they hold in Karachi. | Ismail Khan believes that the MQM is behind this, and its principal motive is to get Pashtuns to give up the land they hold in Karachi. |
There has been a substantial rise in migrant numbers | There has been a substantial rise in migrant numbers |
"We are the only threat to their power, and that is why they have used the spectre of Talebanisation." | "We are the only threat to their power, and that is why they have used the spectre of Talebanisation." |
But Mohammad Rafiq and many others believe that it is the realities on the ground which have forced the MQM to move matters. | But Mohammad Rafiq and many others believe that it is the realities on the ground which have forced the MQM to move matters. |
"We had no problems with the Pashtun community which has been settled here for a long time," he says. | "We had no problems with the Pashtun community which has been settled here for a long time," he says. |
"But we do have a problem with those who are extremists and have come here to spread Taleban ideas." | "But we do have a problem with those who are extremists and have come here to spread Taleban ideas." |
There seems little outward signs that the fundamentalist movement is taking over this most cosmopolitan of cities. | There seems little outward signs that the fundamentalist movement is taking over this most cosmopolitan of cities. |
Karachi's problems remain largely ethnic despite claims by the MQM. | Karachi's problems remain largely ethnic despite claims by the MQM. |
Pakistan's current debilitating security scenario however means that this is no less of a threat. | Pakistan's current debilitating security scenario however means that this is no less of a threat. |
"Karachi remains Pakistan's jugular vein and its microcosm," says Aminullah Khattak. | "Karachi remains Pakistan's jugular vein and its microcosm," says Aminullah Khattak. |
"Any descent into violence here could cripple the country economically, and have grave consequences for national unity." | "Any descent into violence here could cripple the country economically, and have grave consequences for national unity." |
Watch Barbara Plett's film from Karachi on Newsnight on Thursday 12 February 2009 at 2230 GMT on BBC2. | Watch Barbara Plett's film from Karachi on Newsnight on Thursday 12 February 2009 at 2230 GMT on BBC2. |
Previous version
1
Next version