This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk/6226217.stm

The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
Migrants 'benefit economy little' Migrants 'benefit economy little'
(about 4 hours later)
The contribution of immigrants to the UK economy is "very slight indeed" and the main benefits are to the migrants themselves, a pressure group has said.The contribution of immigrants to the UK economy is "very slight indeed" and the main benefits are to the migrants themselves, a pressure group has said.
Migrationwatch UK says the economic benefit is equal to 4p a week for each person in Britain.Migrationwatch UK says the economic benefit is equal to 4p a week for each person in Britain.
Its chairman Sir Andrew Green accused Whitehall of trying to divert attention from the problems caused by migration.Its chairman Sir Andrew Green accused Whitehall of trying to divert attention from the problems caused by migration.
A Home Office spokesman said there was "a clear consensus" that migrants had helped the economy to grow.A Home Office spokesman said there was "a clear consensus" that migrants had helped the economy to grow.
The government says that migration has increased output by £4bn and accounts for 10 to 15% of economic growth.The government says that migration has increased output by £4bn and accounts for 10 to 15% of economic growth.
But Migrationwatch UK says figures show immigration's benefits to the UK are far lower than claimed.But Migrationwatch UK says figures show immigration's benefits to the UK are far lower than claimed.
The main beneficiaries are the immigrants themselves who are able to send home about £10m a day, not the host nation Sir Andrew Green, Migrationwatch UK They certainly do add to production, but they also add in virtually the same proportion to population Migrationwatch UK chairman Sir Andrew Green
The group also analysed a series of reports on the economic impact of immigration and concluded: "The much vaunted contribution of immigrants to the economy is very slight indeed."The group also analysed a series of reports on the economic impact of immigration and concluded: "The much vaunted contribution of immigrants to the economy is very slight indeed."
Sir Andrew said: "Of course many immigrants make a useful contribution to the economy but taken in total the economic benefit is at best marginal. "What we have done is to look at the economic contribution of migrants, taken as a whole, taking the economy as a whole," Sir Andrew told BBC News.
"The main beneficiaries are the immigrants themselves who are able to send home about £10m a day, not the host nation." "We find they certainly do add to production, but they also add in virtually the same proportion to population."
He added: "The government seek to present the record immigration levels as being nothing but good news for the host community as a means of deflecting attention from some of the many problems it is causing, and to neutralise the deep public disquiet they know is out there." The benefit of mass migration to each individual member of society was "trivial", Sir Andrew added.
'Cheap points' He said the main beneficiaries were the immigrants themselves, who were able to send home about £10m each day.
Migrants to the UK bring valuable skills and ideas with them Susan AndersonCBI
But Susan Anderson of the Confederation of British Industry said: "Migrationwatch is seeking to score a few cheap political points with these figures.But Susan Anderson of the Confederation of British Industry said: "Migrationwatch is seeking to score a few cheap political points with these figures.
"Migrants to the UK bring valuable skills and ideas with them and help to fill job vacancies where Britons are unable or unwilling to do so."Migrants to the UK bring valuable skills and ideas with them and help to fill job vacancies where Britons are unable or unwilling to do so.
"Their taxes help pay for our public services and our pensions, long after many migrants have returned home."Their taxes help pay for our public services and our pensions, long after many migrants have returned home.
"Their presence also helps keep inflation low at a time when there are many forces pushing the other way.""Their presence also helps keep inflation low at a time when there are many forces pushing the other way."
Last December, the Ernst and Young Item Club, an influential economic forecasting body that uses Treasury models, estimated that immigration had brought in an extra £12bn to £18bn in tax since 1998. Eastern European workers were reducing the UK's trade deficit by an extra £1bn every year, it stressed. Independent research has found migrants make a net contribution to the Exchequer Home Office spokesman
Last December, the Ernst and Young Item Club, an influential economic forecasting body that uses Treasury models, estimated that immigration had brought in an extra £12bn to £18bn in tax since 1998.
Eastern European workers were reducing the UK's trade deficit by an extra £1bn every year, it stressed.
In the same month a fresh Bank of England analysis suggested the effect of new migrants was complex.In the same month a fresh Bank of England analysis suggested the effect of new migrants was complex.
While they were highly educated, they were also working in more low skilled jobs, it said. Some of these migrants may also be replacing low-skilled UK workers in certain jobs, although more data was needed.While they were highly educated, they were also working in more low skilled jobs, it said. Some of these migrants may also be replacing low-skilled UK workers in certain jobs, although more data was needed.
Consensus Immigration can be a real benefit to the country but only if it is properly controlled David DavisShadow home secretary
A spokesman for the Home Office said there was clear evidence of migration's benefits.A spokesman for the Home Office said there was clear evidence of migration's benefits.
"Independent research has found migrants make a net contribution to the Exchequer," said a spokesman ""We have seen a large movement of people from the EU coming here to work. "Independent research has found migrants make a net contribution to the Exchequer," said a spokesman.
"We have seen a large movement of people from the EU coming here to work.
"There is a clear consensus from commentators, business and our own research that this has helped the economy to grow. There is no evidence that it has increased unemployment.""There is a clear consensus from commentators, business and our own research that this has helped the economy to grow. There is no evidence that it has increased unemployment."
David Davis, the shadow home secretary, said the Migrationwatch figures sharply contrasted to those of the government.David Davis, the shadow home secretary, said the Migrationwatch figures sharply contrasted to those of the government.
"Immigration can be a real benefit to the country but only if it is properly controlled," he said."Immigration can be a real benefit to the country but only if it is properly controlled," he said.
"You need to have accurate information about its level and effects. The government patently has neither.""You need to have accurate information about its level and effects. The government patently has neither."