This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/04/us/coronavirus-california-air-pollution.html

The article has changed 34 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 27 Version 28
Will Smoke From Controlled Burns Hurt Covid-19 Patients? Will Smoke From Controlled Burns Hurt Covid-19 Patients?
(about 20 hours later)
By Will McCarthyBy Will McCarthy
Good morning.Good morning.
(Here’s the sign-up, if you don’t already get California Today delivered to your inbox.)(Here’s the sign-up, if you don’t already get California Today delivered to your inbox.)
Today, we have another dispatch from the University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism, written by Will McCarthy:Today, we have another dispatch from the University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism, written by Will McCarthy:
In the mountains of California, snow is melting, the days are ticking closer to fire season and officials responsible for fighting wildfires face an agonizing choice: Exacerbate the current crisis, or pile risk on to the next one.In the mountains of California, snow is melting, the days are ticking closer to fire season and officials responsible for fighting wildfires face an agonizing choice: Exacerbate the current crisis, or pile risk on to the next one.
This is the season when California’s forests are thinned out with controlled burns to reduce the devastation that has become all too common during the fall wildfire season. But the smoke generated by setting fire to thousands of acres this spring could be lethal for Covid-19 victims fighting for every breath.This is the season when California’s forests are thinned out with controlled burns to reduce the devastation that has become all too common during the fall wildfire season. But the smoke generated by setting fire to thousands of acres this spring could be lethal for Covid-19 victims fighting for every breath.
While thousands have recovered, hospitals are caring for nearly 4,000 Covid-19 patients, with at least 1,100 in intensive care. Untold numbers more are suffering at home. Worse still, the effects of heavy smoke — pneumonia, asthma, bronchitis — are felt most acutely by older people with underlying health problems, the population most at risk from Covid-19.While thousands have recovered, hospitals are caring for nearly 4,000 Covid-19 patients, with at least 1,100 in intensive care. Untold numbers more are suffering at home. Worse still, the effects of heavy smoke — pneumonia, asthma, bronchitis — are felt most acutely by older people with underlying health problems, the population most at risk from Covid-19.
[Track every coronavirus case in California by county.][Track every coronavirus case in California by county.]
“It’s a hard call,” said Dr. Mary Prunicki, who researches air pollution at Stanford University. “It does put smoke into the air. But the downside is, ‘Are we going to have bigger wildfires in the fall?’”“It’s a hard call,” said Dr. Mary Prunicki, who researches air pollution at Stanford University. “It does put smoke into the air. But the downside is, ‘Are we going to have bigger wildfires in the fall?’”
Forestry officials have taken divergent approaches to this dilemma.Forestry officials have taken divergent approaches to this dilemma.
The U.S. Forest Service, which oversees about 57 percent of the forest lands in California, halted its prescribed burns throughout the state for six weeks. When the decision was announced in March, a spokesman said that postponing burns “will prevent any effects from smoke that might further worsen conditions for those who are at risk in our communities.”The U.S. Forest Service, which oversees about 57 percent of the forest lands in California, halted its prescribed burns throughout the state for six weeks. When the decision was announced in March, a spokesman said that postponing burns “will prevent any effects from smoke that might further worsen conditions for those who are at risk in our communities.”
Yet a different branch of the federal government, the Bureau of Land Management, which manages more than a million acres in California, did not halt its controlled burns, nor did Cal Fire, the state agency charged with combating wildfires on land not under federal control.Yet a different branch of the federal government, the Bureau of Land Management, which manages more than a million acres in California, did not halt its controlled burns, nor did Cal Fire, the state agency charged with combating wildfires on land not under federal control.
“What is Covid-19? A respiratory issue,” Scott McLean, a spokesman for Cal Fire, said. “We’re not naïve to that, but we have to provide for the well-being of the public.”“What is Covid-19? A respiratory issue,” Scott McLean, a spokesman for Cal Fire, said. “We’re not naïve to that, but we have to provide for the well-being of the public.”
The contradictory policies reflect an absence of coordination between the agencies most directly responsible for fighting wildfires in California. According to Mr. McLean, the Forest Service did not consult with Cal Fire on its decision to suspend controlled burns. “We found out when the news release came out,” he said.The contradictory policies reflect an absence of coordination between the agencies most directly responsible for fighting wildfires in California. According to Mr. McLean, the Forest Service did not consult with Cal Fire on its decision to suspend controlled burns. “We found out when the news release came out,” he said.
But the dueling approaches also reflected starkly different calculations of risk.But the dueling approaches also reflected starkly different calculations of risk.
Forest Service officials said they were concerned that assembling a work force to conduct the burns would expose traveling employees to the virus and potentially contribute to its spread. They also raised doubts about how their fire crews could tend to burns while also abiding by social distancing directives.Forest Service officials said they were concerned that assembling a work force to conduct the burns would expose traveling employees to the virus and potentially contribute to its spread. They also raised doubts about how their fire crews could tend to burns while also abiding by social distancing directives.
They said they would continue to use other methods — such as removing brush by hand and with heavy machinery — that reduce combustible forest fuel without generating smoke.They said they would continue to use other methods — such as removing brush by hand and with heavy machinery — that reduce combustible forest fuel without generating smoke.
On Friday, however, the Forest Service changed course and announced it would resume controlled burns in California “as conditions and resources permit.”On Friday, however, the Forest Service changed course and announced it would resume controlled burns in California “as conditions and resources permit.”
“We will continue to prioritize the health and safety of communities and firefighters during this global and national emergency, and will also conduct prescribed fire where feasible as an important tool to protect communities,” Randy Moore, a Forest Service official, said in a statement.“We will continue to prioritize the health and safety of communities and firefighters during this global and national emergency, and will also conduct prescribed fire where feasible as an important tool to protect communities,” Randy Moore, a Forest Service official, said in a statement.
Cal Fire plans to burn roughly 3,200 acres over the next two months. Its risk calculations have been influenced by recent catastrophes such as the 2018 Camp Fire, which killed 86 people in Paradise and surrounding towns, and last fall’s wildfires, which left huge portions of the state without power for days at a time.Cal Fire plans to burn roughly 3,200 acres over the next two months. Its risk calculations have been influenced by recent catastrophes such as the 2018 Camp Fire, which killed 86 people in Paradise and surrounding towns, and last fall’s wildfires, which left huge portions of the state without power for days at a time.
At the same time, officials at Cal Fire said they were taking steps to limit the health effects from their controlled burns, such as analyzing wind conditions to make sure smoke will not blow toward hospitals. Each burn, which can range in size from a few acres to several hundred, also requires advance approval from local air quality management boards, which in turn typically consult with local public health agencies.At the same time, officials at Cal Fire said they were taking steps to limit the health effects from their controlled burns, such as analyzing wind conditions to make sure smoke will not blow toward hospitals. Each burn, which can range in size from a few acres to several hundred, also requires advance approval from local air quality management boards, which in turn typically consult with local public health agencies.
Officials from several air quality boards and public health agencies downplayed the harm that controlled burns could inflict on those infected with Covid-19. “If they’re fighting for every breath, they’re in the hospital and not exposed to the smoky air,” said Lisa Almaguer, a spokeswoman for the Butte County public health department. “If they have moderate to severe symptoms then they’re home and in bed.”Officials from several air quality boards and public health agencies downplayed the harm that controlled burns could inflict on those infected with Covid-19. “If they’re fighting for every breath, they’re in the hospital and not exposed to the smoky air,” said Lisa Almaguer, a spokeswoman for the Butte County public health department. “If they have moderate to severe symptoms then they’re home and in bed.”
State and local officials repeatedly argued that whatever the risks of controlled burns, failing to thin forests today could create conditions for a far greater calamity come fall. Dave Winnacker, chief of the Moraga-Orinda fire district east of Berkeley, worries what would happen if a failure to do adequate controlled burns means more intense wildfires in a few months. If Covid-19 is still a menace, what will that mean for the thousands of firefighters assembled to battle those wildfires, often in close quarters, often to the point of exhaustion? How will those firefighters evacuate thousands of residents while adhering to social distancing?State and local officials repeatedly argued that whatever the risks of controlled burns, failing to thin forests today could create conditions for a far greater calamity come fall. Dave Winnacker, chief of the Moraga-Orinda fire district east of Berkeley, worries what would happen if a failure to do adequate controlled burns means more intense wildfires in a few months. If Covid-19 is still a menace, what will that mean for the thousands of firefighters assembled to battle those wildfires, often in close quarters, often to the point of exhaustion? How will those firefighters evacuate thousands of residents while adhering to social distancing?
“Covid-19 has crowded out every other thing that people have the capacity to worry about,” he said. “But that doesn’t mean the fire season is going to take a year off.”“Covid-19 has crowded out every other thing that people have the capacity to worry about,” he said. “But that doesn’t mean the fire season is going to take a year off.”
Many residents of California know all too well what it is to suffer ongoing respiratory problems from fire seasons past. Laura Whitaker, a former resident of Paradise, said her lungs have never been the same since she survived the Camp Fire. “I remember feeling that my lungs were full and that I couldn’t breathe,” she said. “It felt like drowning.”Many residents of California know all too well what it is to suffer ongoing respiratory problems from fire seasons past. Laura Whitaker, a former resident of Paradise, said her lungs have never been the same since she survived the Camp Fire. “I remember feeling that my lungs were full and that I couldn’t breathe,” she said. “It felt like drowning.”
In the years since, Ms. Whitaker said she could tell from her lungs when controlled burns begin anew. “The smoke, definitely, it gets to me pretty badly,” she said. And having just gotten over a bout of pneumonia, she said she was afraid this year’s burns will make her more vulnerable to the novel coronavirus. “When I heard that it affects the lungs, it puts the fear into you,” she said.In the years since, Ms. Whitaker said she could tell from her lungs when controlled burns begin anew. “The smoke, definitely, it gets to me pretty badly,” she said. And having just gotten over a bout of pneumonia, she said she was afraid this year’s burns will make her more vulnerable to the novel coronavirus. “When I heard that it affects the lungs, it puts the fear into you,” she said.
Her fears are well grounded, experts said. “As you batter the lungs, which is what’s happening when you breathe wildfire smoke, the defense mechanisms get overwhelmed,” said Katharine Hammond, a professor of environmental health sciences at the University of California, Berkeley.Her fears are well grounded, experts said. “As you batter the lungs, which is what’s happening when you breathe wildfire smoke, the defense mechanisms get overwhelmed,” said Katharine Hammond, a professor of environmental health sciences at the University of California, Berkeley.
Updated August 4, 2020 Updated August 6, 2020
“There’s a big difference if there’s a little bit of smoke or a lot of smoke,” she added. “Those are trade-offs that need to be carefully thought through.”“There’s a big difference if there’s a little bit of smoke or a lot of smoke,” she added. “Those are trade-offs that need to be carefully thought through.”
After Gov. Gavin Newsom moved to close beaches in Orange County, The Los Angeles Times reported that protesters showed up in droves to defy the order.After Gov. Gavin Newsom moved to close beaches in Orange County, The Los Angeles Times reported that protesters showed up in droves to defy the order.
They were part of wider demonstrations against stay-at-home orders, including in Sacramento, that have been increasingly driven by antivaccination activists, The New York Times reported.They were part of wider demonstrations against stay-at-home orders, including in Sacramento, that have been increasingly driven by antivaccination activists, The New York Times reported.
On Friday, Mr. Newsom sought to reassure restless Californians, saying that statewide restrictions would be eased in coming days.On Friday, Mr. Newsom sought to reassure restless Californians, saying that statewide restrictions would be eased in coming days.
In the meantime, neighbors have come together in new ways, as The Times shows in this visual piece. In Los Angeles, for instance, once-anonymous neighbors are picking and donating citrus.In the meantime, neighbors have come together in new ways, as The Times shows in this visual piece. In Los Angeles, for instance, once-anonymous neighbors are picking and donating citrus.
California Today goes live at 6:30 a.m. Pacific time weekdays. Tell us what you want to see: CAtoday@nytimes.com. Were you forwarded this email? Sign up for California Today here and read every edition online here.California Today goes live at 6:30 a.m. Pacific time weekdays. Tell us what you want to see: CAtoday@nytimes.com. Were you forwarded this email? Sign up for California Today here and read every edition online here.
Jill Cowan grew up in Orange County, went to school at U.C. Berkeley and has reported all over the state, including the Bay Area, Bakersfield and Los Angeles — but she always wants to see more. Follow along here or on Twitter.Jill Cowan grew up in Orange County, went to school at U.C. Berkeley and has reported all over the state, including the Bay Area, Bakersfield and Los Angeles — but she always wants to see more. Follow along here or on Twitter.
California Today is edited by Julie Bloom, who grew up in Los Angeles and graduated from U.C. Berkeley.California Today is edited by Julie Bloom, who grew up in Los Angeles and graduated from U.C. Berkeley.