This article is from the source 'washpo' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/act-four/the-dark-side-of-harry-and-meghans-fairy-tale-escape/2020/01/09/eb49d8ac-3321-11ea-a053-dc6d944ba776_story.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| The dark side of Harry and Meghan’s fairy-tale escape | The dark side of Harry and Meghan’s fairy-tale escape |
| (about 8 hours later) | |
| Alyssa Rosenberg writes about culture and politics for The Post’s Opinions section. | Alyssa Rosenberg writes about culture and politics for The Post’s Opinions section. |
| The initial and understandable impulse is to cheer the Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s declaration of independence from the racist British press, from the suffocating rituals of “senior royal” life, from the fickleness of English weather. But we shouldn’t fool ourselves: This latest fracture within the House of Windsor is the continuation of a very sad story of family dysfunction, made even sadder by its contrast with the ideals the royal family is meant to represent. | The initial and understandable impulse is to cheer the Duke and Duchess of Sussex’s declaration of independence from the racist British press, from the suffocating rituals of “senior royal” life, from the fickleness of English weather. But we shouldn’t fool ourselves: This latest fracture within the House of Windsor is the continuation of a very sad story of family dysfunction, made even sadder by its contrast with the ideals the royal family is meant to represent. |
| The announcement may have been a striking preemptive move, with Prince Harry reportedly defying the explicit instructions of his grandmother the queen not to announce that he and his wife, Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, would “step back” from royal life. Yet this is hardly the most dramatic rupture the family has suffered. Queen Elizabeth II is on the throne precisely because of such a rift: Her father became king after her uncle abdicated the throne to marry a divorced woman and went into exile. Three of the queen’s four children have subsequently divorced themselves, one in breathtakingly acrimonious fashion. The Sussexes’ bombshell is nothing compared with the late Princess Diana’s confessional collaborations with the journalists Andrew Morton and Martin Bashir, undertaken in an effort to get first Prince Charles and her in-laws, and then the British public, to understand her pain. | The announcement may have been a striking preemptive move, with Prince Harry reportedly defying the explicit instructions of his grandmother the queen not to announce that he and his wife, Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, would “step back” from royal life. Yet this is hardly the most dramatic rupture the family has suffered. Queen Elizabeth II is on the throne precisely because of such a rift: Her father became king after her uncle abdicated the throne to marry a divorced woman and went into exile. Three of the queen’s four children have subsequently divorced themselves, one in breathtakingly acrimonious fashion. The Sussexes’ bombshell is nothing compared with the late Princess Diana’s confessional collaborations with the journalists Andrew Morton and Martin Bashir, undertaken in an effort to get first Prince Charles and her in-laws, and then the British public, to understand her pain. |
| Maybe this constant state of royal breakdown is understandable. The House of Windsor is spectacularly privileged, but its members are also under tremendous pressure. Those of us on the outside might sigh over the decor and imagine what we might do with 20 million pounds a year (about $26 million). But I’m not sure most of us could name the actual salary we’d like to be paid for surrendering our personalities, performing an endless array of ceremonial but crushingly dull appearances, and doing it all while submitting to pantyhose (the female royals) and exhaustingly personal media criticism (both genders, but it’s worse for the women) every day. | Maybe this constant state of royal breakdown is understandable. The House of Windsor is spectacularly privileged, but its members are also under tremendous pressure. Those of us on the outside might sigh over the decor and imagine what we might do with 20 million pounds a year (about $26 million). But I’m not sure most of us could name the actual salary we’d like to be paid for surrendering our personalities, performing an endless array of ceremonial but crushingly dull appearances, and doing it all while submitting to pantyhose (the female royals) and exhaustingly personal media criticism (both genders, but it’s worse for the women) every day. |
| Can you imagine being told by your mother that no one actually cares about you as an individual, as Queen Elizabeth II does to Prince Charles in this season of Netflix’s “The Crown,” a show that may be fictionalized but is deeply rooted in fact? What would you have to be paid if you knew you were going to have to fight a years-long struggle to get your family to acknowledge your bulimia and other mental health issues, as Diana did in real life? The idea that Meghan Markle was going to transform the Windsors into a breezily diverse, egalitarian bunch by marrying into the family was always more aspirational than reasonable, a white dress and tiara acting as camouflage for the futility of it all. | Can you imagine being told by your mother that no one actually cares about you as an individual, as Queen Elizabeth II does to Prince Charles in this season of Netflix’s “The Crown,” a show that may be fictionalized but is deeply rooted in fact? What would you have to be paid if you knew you were going to have to fight a years-long struggle to get your family to acknowledge your bulimia and other mental health issues, as Diana did in real life? The idea that Meghan Markle was going to transform the Windsors into a breezily diverse, egalitarian bunch by marrying into the family was always more aspirational than reasonable, a white dress and tiara acting as camouflage for the futility of it all. |
| A surface reading might present Harry’s desire to break away from the parts of royal life he finds stultifying as a victory his mother could have been proud of. But, as Tina Brown noted in “The Diana Chronicles,” Diana’s definition of victory was not always reliable. “She thought this deafening public scream would solve the matter once and for all,” Brown wrote of Diana’s decision to collaborate with Morton on a tell-all book. “It was her pattern, the belief that a single volcanic act could fix everything.” | A surface reading might present Harry’s desire to break away from the parts of royal life he finds stultifying as a victory his mother could have been proud of. But, as Tina Brown noted in “The Diana Chronicles,” Diana’s definition of victory was not always reliable. “She thought this deafening public scream would solve the matter once and for all,” Brown wrote of Diana’s decision to collaborate with Morton on a tell-all book. “It was her pattern, the belief that a single volcanic act could fix everything.” |
| So far, Harry’s story has a happier ending than his mother’s. He is stepping back as a senior royal with his marriage intact. He and his wife do appear to have some plan for the days to come, or at least a new website with a Frequently Asked Questions section. And yet there are certain chilly echoes between Diana’s defenestration from the royal family and the departure of her younger son. | So far, Harry’s story has a happier ending than his mother’s. He is stepping back as a senior royal with his marriage intact. He and his wife do appear to have some plan for the days to come, or at least a new website with a Frequently Asked Questions section. And yet there are certain chilly echoes between Diana’s defenestration from the royal family and the departure of her younger son. |
| When Diana announced that she had agreed to a divorce from the Prince of Wales, Buckingham Palace declared frostily that “this will take time.” This time around, there was perhaps a hint less condescension in the official statement that “We understand [the Sussexes’] desire to take a different approach, but these are complicated issues that will take time to work through.” | When Diana announced that she had agreed to a divorce from the Prince of Wales, Buckingham Palace declared frostily that “this will take time.” This time around, there was perhaps a hint less condescension in the official statement that “We understand [the Sussexes’] desire to take a different approach, but these are complicated issues that will take time to work through.” |
| That hint of steel should be a caution to anyone who is busily revising Harry and Meghan’s escape into a modern fairy tale, one in which the duchess rescues the prince and carries him off to a happily-ever-after in Canada. The thing about riding off into the sunset is that, depending on the terms of your departure, it means leaving your once-beloved brother, father and grandmother behind. The folly would be in forgetting what kind of story this is, and refusing to see that another word for “drama” is “pain.” | That hint of steel should be a caution to anyone who is busily revising Harry and Meghan’s escape into a modern fairy tale, one in which the duchess rescues the prince and carries him off to a happily-ever-after in Canada. The thing about riding off into the sunset is that, depending on the terms of your departure, it means leaving your once-beloved brother, father and grandmother behind. The folly would be in forgetting what kind of story this is, and refusing to see that another word for “drama” is “pain.” |
| Read more: | Read more: |
| Alexandra Petri and Jessica M. Goldstein: Honestly, I, Meghan Markle, have been plotting this my entire life | Alexandra Petri and Jessica M. Goldstein: Honestly, I, Meghan Markle, have been plotting this my entire life |
| Autumn Brewington: The royal family said their situation is complicated. The reality is more dire. | Autumn Brewington: The royal family said their situation is complicated. The reality is more dire. |
| Yomi Adegoke: British tabloids drove Meghan away. They’ll never learn. | |
| David Von Drehle: Harry and Meghan show us what happens when you have ‘an heir and a spare’ | |
| Karen Attiah: No, Meghan Markle is not the ‘modernizing’ force Britain truly needs | Karen Attiah: No, Meghan Markle is not the ‘modernizing’ force Britain truly needs |
| Read the transcript of Alyssa Rosenberg’s Jan. 7 live chat: The gems were cut | Read the transcript of Alyssa Rosenberg’s Jan. 7 live chat: The gems were cut |
| Submit a question for Alyssa Rosenberg’s Jan. 13 live chat | Submit a question for Alyssa Rosenberg’s Jan. 13 live chat |