This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/dec/20/cross-border-aid-syria-risk-amid-un-security-council-split
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Cross-border aid to Syria at risk amid UN security council split | Cross-border aid to Syria at risk amid UN security council split |
| (about 7 hours later) | |
| Impasse continues as Russia calls for reduction in number of crossings for delivering aid | Impasse continues as Russia calls for reduction in number of crossings for delivering aid |
| Vital cross-border aid to Syria is under threat after the UN security council was unable to overcome Russian and Chinese objections to the programme. | Vital cross-border aid to Syria is under threat after the UN security council was unable to overcome Russian and Chinese objections to the programme. |
| The aid, which is sent over borders at four UN approved checkpoints and without the formal permission of the Syrian regime, is seen as critical as the humanitarian crisis in Idlib and north-east Syria continues to mount. | The aid, which is sent over borders at four UN approved checkpoints and without the formal permission of the Syrian regime, is seen as critical as the humanitarian crisis in Idlib and north-east Syria continues to mount. |
| Throughout the past fortnight , the UN security council has been considering two alternative resolutions on cross-border aid deliveries to Syria. | |
| On Friday, Russia, backed by China, cast its 14th UN security council veto since the start of the Syrian conflict in 2011 to block cross-border aid deliveries from Turkey and Iraq to millions of Syrian civilians. | |
| The resolution drafted by Belgium, Kuwait and Germany would have allowed cross-border humanitarian deliveries for another year from two points in Turkey and one in Iraq. But Syrian ally Russia only wanted to approve the two Turkish crossings for six months. | |
| The Russia-proposed resolution suggests extending the mechanism of cross-border aid deliveries to Syria, but through only two checkpoints, at Bab al-Salam and Bab al-Hawa, on the Syria-Turkey border. Renewal of the mandate would last only six months, until 10 July 2020. | The Russia-proposed resolution suggests extending the mechanism of cross-border aid deliveries to Syria, but through only two checkpoints, at Bab al-Salam and Bab al-Hawa, on the Syria-Turkey border. Renewal of the mandate would last only six months, until 10 July 2020. |
| Russia wants to end crossings at Ramtha on the Jordanian border and at Yaroubiyeh on the border with Iraq. | Russia wants to end crossings at Ramtha on the Jordanian border and at Yaroubiyeh on the border with Iraq. |
| Western diplomats say the Yaroubiyh crossing is of crucial importance because it allows 40% of the medicines for humanitarian operations to be transported to the north-east. Some diplomats also believe the closure of Yaroubiyeh, which is on the main highway between Syria and northern Iraq, would undercut autonomy in the north-east of the mainly Kurdish SDF forces and make the US presence in the area harder to maintain. | Western diplomats say the Yaroubiyh crossing is of crucial importance because it allows 40% of the medicines for humanitarian operations to be transported to the north-east. Some diplomats also believe the closure of Yaroubiyeh, which is on the main highway between Syria and northern Iraq, would undercut autonomy in the north-east of the mainly Kurdish SDF forces and make the US presence in the area harder to maintain. |
| The area served by Yaroubiyeh includes the high-profile al-Hawl camp, which houses nearly 69,000 people, including imprisoned foreign Islamic State fighters and their families. | The area served by Yaroubiyeh includes the high-profile al-Hawl camp, which houses nearly 69,000 people, including imprisoned foreign Islamic State fighters and their families. |
| Ankara had suggested opening a fifth crossing through Tal Abyad on Syria’s north-eastern border with Turkey. | Ankara had suggested opening a fifth crossing through Tal Abyad on Syria’s north-eastern border with Turkey. |
| In an effort to secure Russian support, the draft proposed by Germany, Belgium and Kuwait suggests delivering aid through three as opposed to the current four checkpoints. The Jordanian crossing would be closed under this proposal. | In an effort to secure Russian support, the draft proposed by Germany, Belgium and Kuwait suggests delivering aid through three as opposed to the current four checkpoints. The Jordanian crossing would be closed under this proposal. |
| Cross-border aid deliveries do not require permission from Damascus. Moscow argues the mechanism has lost its relevance as the Syrian government is gradually regaining control over the country’s territory. It also believes the checkpoints are used by terrorist groups, a charge the UN strongly denies. | Cross-border aid deliveries do not require permission from Damascus. Moscow argues the mechanism has lost its relevance as the Syrian government is gradually regaining control over the country’s territory. It also believes the checkpoints are used by terrorist groups, a charge the UN strongly denies. |
| UN diplomats are eager to reach an agreement before Christmas, fearing it will be more difficult to solve the issue close to the deadline of 10 January since in the new year there will be a new UN security council membership. | UN diplomats are eager to reach an agreement before Christmas, fearing it will be more difficult to solve the issue close to the deadline of 10 January since in the new year there will be a new UN security council membership. |
| The decision to introduce cross-border aid deliveries to Syria was first made in July 2014 after the civil war made it impossible for civilians to access humanitarian aid. | The decision to introduce cross-border aid deliveries to Syria was first made in July 2014 after the civil war made it impossible for civilians to access humanitarian aid. |
| The assistant secretary-general of OCHA, the UN humanitarian agency, Ursula Mueller, said the humanitarian position was worse than last year, and reducing in the number of crossings was not justified. | The assistant secretary-general of OCHA, the UN humanitarian agency, Ursula Mueller, said the humanitarian position was worse than last year, and reducing in the number of crossings was not justified. |
| She added: “Without the cross-border operation, we would see an immediate end of aid supporting millions of civilians. That would cause a rapid increase in hunger and disease, resulting in death, suffering and further displacement – including across-borders – for a vulnerable population who have already suffered unspeakable tragedy as a result of almost nine years of conflict.” | She added: “Without the cross-border operation, we would see an immediate end of aid supporting millions of civilians. That would cause a rapid increase in hunger and disease, resulting in death, suffering and further displacement – including across-borders – for a vulnerable population who have already suffered unspeakable tragedy as a result of almost nine years of conflict.” |
| The UK ambassador to the UN, Karen Pierce, said: “If the UN does not help these communities, there is no evidence, no evidence at all to believe that the Syrian government either wants to or can or will provide that assistance.” | The UK ambassador to the UN, Karen Pierce, said: “If the UN does not help these communities, there is no evidence, no evidence at all to believe that the Syrian government either wants to or can or will provide that assistance.” |
| The International Rescue Committee, alongside a host of other aid agencies, has been urging the security council not to scale back on aid delivery. | The International Rescue Committee, alongside a host of other aid agencies, has been urging the security council not to scale back on aid delivery. |
| In a statement, it said: “In 2014, when this resolution was first adopted, the security council expressed ‘grave alarm’ that the number of people in need of assistance had risen to more than 10 million. At the end of 2019, that number stands at more than 11 million – almost 3 million of whom are only able to receive aid thanks to the cross-border response. The situation inside Syria remains a humanitarian catastrophe. Now is not the time to scale back on humanitarian access.” | In a statement, it said: “In 2014, when this resolution was first adopted, the security council expressed ‘grave alarm’ that the number of people in need of assistance had risen to more than 10 million. At the end of 2019, that number stands at more than 11 million – almost 3 million of whom are only able to receive aid thanks to the cross-border response. The situation inside Syria remains a humanitarian catastrophe. Now is not the time to scale back on humanitarian access.” |