This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/live/2019/dec/19/queens-speech-boris-johnson-jeremy-corbyn-blames-corbyns-advisers-for-election-defeat-and-suggests-they-should-be-sacked-live-news
The article has changed 21 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 16 | Version 17 |
|---|---|
| Clive Lewis enters Labour leadership race – live news | |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happen, including the Queen’s speech and Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn speaking in the subsequent Commons debate | Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happen, including the Queen’s speech and Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn speaking in the subsequent Commons debate |
| In the Queen’s Speech debate, which has not exactly been troubled by many moments of soaring oratory, the Liberal Democrats’ joint leader Sir Ed Davey warned the prime minister that his “willingness to jump unashamedly over every red line he had previously been willing to die in the ditch for will have been noted in Brussels by Europe’s rather more skilful negotiators”, suggesting that Boris Johnson’s greatest weapon in the negotiations to come would be his “unmatched flexibility with the truth”. | |
| “His so-called triumph of achieving a deal for Brexit phase one was only possible because he betrayed his big promise to the DUP,” Davey added, describing the PM’s tactics as “bulldog bluster combined with the record of a turncoat”. | |
| He said: “I don’t believe this is the right approach and I don’t believe he’ll succeed without reneging on almost all of his previous promises to Leave voters. | |
| “Whether or not, in the dark Conservative forests of the Brexit Spartans, his erstwhile friends have yet smelt betrayal.” | |
| The Northern Ireland secretary, Julian Smith, has announced that there will be no return to power-sharing in the region before Christmas, blaming the DUP for preventing the move which would have seen the government release extra money for the NHS there. | |
| Smith said: “I am deeply disappointed that we have not got all five parties in agreement,” and asked the DUP, the largest party in Northern Ireland, to reconsider. | |
| The party said there were outstanding issues under negotiation that would not be resolved in the coming days, and work remained to be done to achieve a “fair and balanced” agreement. | |
| The second largest party, Sinn Féin, had joined the British and Irish governments in making a push to re-establish devolved institutions, ending a three-year hiatus. | |
| Smith said: “We want all parties to be positively part of the new Stormont. The DUP is a crucial part of that. | |
| “I don’t think time is going to make any difference, I think hanging around, delay, not making decisions is not going to make any difference, it is only going to cause more heartache and problems for citizens in Northern Ireland. | |
| “I just hope there is time tonight to reflect on that decision.” | |
| People in the DUP did want to break the deadlock, he said, and he asked them to make their voices heard. | |
| “I would urge them to move forward so that we can get this done.” | |
| The shadow Treasury minister, Clive Lewis, has thrown his hat into the ring to become the next Labour leader. Writing in the Guardian, the 48-year-old MP for Norwich North, who is seen to be on the left of the party, said that Labour had suffered “its own Dunkirk” at the election, but that they could bounce back if they gave activists a stake in any changes. | |
| Lewis claims that the party still has to make a clear break with the New Labour era: | Lewis claims that the party still has to make a clear break with the New Labour era: |
| Yvette Cooper, who has yet to comment on whether she will run for the Labour leadership, has also responded to the lack of a commitment to negotiate an agreement to allow unaccompanied refugee children to come to the UK to join relatives (see 17:27). | Yvette Cooper, who has yet to comment on whether she will run for the Labour leadership, has also responded to the lack of a commitment to negotiate an agreement to allow unaccompanied refugee children to come to the UK to join relatives (see 17:27). |
| Paul Golding, the leader of the far-right group Britain First, said that he has attempted to join the Conservative party, to show his support for comments that Boris Johnson has previously made about Islam. | Paul Golding, the leader of the far-right group Britain First, said that he has attempted to join the Conservative party, to show his support for comments that Boris Johnson has previously made about Islam. |
| Golding told the Press Association that he liked the “cut of the cloth” of Johnson when the prime minister described women wearing the burqa as resembling “letterboxes” in a column in the Daily Telegraph. | Golding told the Press Association that he liked the “cut of the cloth” of Johnson when the prime minister described women wearing the burqa as resembling “letterboxes” in a column in the Daily Telegraph. |
| Golding, who has been convicted and imprisoned for religiously aggravated harassment and is a former British National Party councillor, said: “Primarily, we had the experience of Momentum joining the Labour party en masse to consolidate the leadership position of Jeremy Corbyn. | Golding, who has been convicted and imprisoned for religiously aggravated harassment and is a former British National Party councillor, said: “Primarily, we had the experience of Momentum joining the Labour party en masse to consolidate the leadership position of Jeremy Corbyn. |
| “We have decided to do the same but in reverse. We are all joining to see if we can consolidate Boris’s leadership over the Tory party. He is getting Brexit done but, as well as that, he has made a lot of comments in the past referring to burqa and niqab-wearing women as ‘letterboxes’. | “We have decided to do the same but in reverse. We are all joining to see if we can consolidate Boris’s leadership over the Tory party. He is getting Brexit done but, as well as that, he has made a lot of comments in the past referring to burqa and niqab-wearing women as ‘letterboxes’. |
| “After the London Bridge attack, he said he wanted to crack down on the early release of terrorist prisoners. We like the cut of the cloth on Boris Johnson.” | “After the London Bridge attack, he said he wanted to crack down on the early release of terrorist prisoners. We like the cut of the cloth on Boris Johnson.” |
| Golding added: “He is more of a populist leader and I think in recent weeks he has nailed his colours to the mast against immigration and being for Brexit.” | Golding added: “He is more of a populist leader and I think in recent weeks he has nailed his colours to the mast against immigration and being for Brexit.” |
| Golding shared a screenshot of an email from the Tories following his application which was electronically signed by Tory chairmen and MPs James Cleverly and Ben Elliot, welcoming him to the party at 2pm on Thursday. | Golding shared a screenshot of an email from the Tories following his application which was electronically signed by Tory chairmen and MPs James Cleverly and Ben Elliot, welcoming him to the party at 2pm on Thursday. |
| It reads: “Your membership is now activated. You can now attend party events both locally and nationally. Your membership card will be sent out shortly.” | It reads: “Your membership is now activated. You can now attend party events both locally and nationally. Your membership card will be sent out shortly.” |
| However a Tory spokeswoman said today: “Paul Golding’s application for membership of the Conservative party has not been approved. | However a Tory spokeswoman said today: “Paul Golding’s application for membership of the Conservative party has not been approved. |
| “While we welcome new members from a wide variety of backgrounds, we are vigilant against those seeking to join the party who do not share our aims. There is a process in place for local Conservative associations to approve members who apply to join, or to reject those who do not share the party’s values or objects. | “While we welcome new members from a wide variety of backgrounds, we are vigilant against those seeking to join the party who do not share our aims. There is a process in place for local Conservative associations to approve members who apply to join, or to reject those who do not share the party’s values or objects. |
| “We support local associations with this work to ensure they can and do take action where needed.” | “We support local associations with this work to ensure they can and do take action where needed.” |
| The Independent Group for Change, the party formally known as Change UK which launched in February 2019, has announced that it is beginning the process of winding itself up. | The Independent Group for Change, the party formally known as Change UK which launched in February 2019, has announced that it is beginning the process of winding itself up. |
| At its high-water mark the party boasted 11 MPs from the two main parties, but after failing to make any electoral headway in May’s European elections, six of the party’s MPs left, many to join the Lib Dems. Only three MPs stood in last week’s election, all of them losing their seats. | At its high-water mark the party boasted 11 MPs from the two main parties, but after failing to make any electoral headway in May’s European elections, six of the party’s MPs left, many to join the Lib Dems. Only three MPs stood in last week’s election, all of them losing their seats. |
| Here is Sir Keir Starmer, the shadow Brexit secretary, responding to the revelation that the new EU (withdrawal agreement) bill does not contain a commitment to negotiate an agreement to allow unaccompanied refugee children to come to the UK to join a relative that was in the original version. | Here is Sir Keir Starmer, the shadow Brexit secretary, responding to the revelation that the new EU (withdrawal agreement) bill does not contain a commitment to negotiate an agreement to allow unaccompanied refugee children to come to the UK to join a relative that was in the original version. |
| LabourList has a full story on this here. | LabourList has a full story on this here. |
| No 10 says the absence of this clause from the bill does not mean its policy has changed. A spokesman said: | No 10 says the absence of this clause from the bill does not mean its policy has changed. A spokesman said: |
| That’s all from me for today. | That’s all from me for today. |
| My colleague Seth Jacobson is now taking over. | My colleague Seth Jacobson is now taking over. |
| No 10 is now ruling out making judicial appointments subject to political approval, the Sun’s Tom Newton Dunn says. An earlier briefing did not rule this out, leaving reporters to conclude it was an option (particularly in the light of the PM’s previous remarks on this). See 5.01pm. | No 10 is now ruling out making judicial appointments subject to political approval, the Sun’s Tom Newton Dunn says. An earlier briefing did not rule this out, leaving reporters to conclude it was an option (particularly in the light of the PM’s previous remarks on this). See 5.01pm. |
| The government stuck to its existing priorities for education in the Queen’s speech, ticking off the policies in its manifesto and beforehand. Apart from vague comments on free schools (“continue to expand”) and university tuition fees (“delivering value for money”), it reaffirms the improvement in school funding for pupils aged 4 to 16 in England, eventually increasing the annual schools budget by £7.1bn in 2022-23. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has estimated that the extra spending is £4.3bn a year in real-terms | The government stuck to its existing priorities for education in the Queen’s speech, ticking off the policies in its manifesto and beforehand. Apart from vague comments on free schools (“continue to expand”) and university tuition fees (“delivering value for money”), it reaffirms the improvement in school funding for pupils aged 4 to 16 in England, eventually increasing the annual schools budget by £7.1bn in 2022-23. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has estimated that the extra spending is £4.3bn a year in real-terms |
| From next year some of the extra funding will be distributed by minimum per-pupil funding via the new national funding formula, the Department for Education has announced. That helps the most poorly funded schools outside of cities, with £3,750 for each primary pupil and £5,000 for secondary pupils, with primaries rising again to £4,000 per pupil in 2021. Schools in Bedfordshire appear to be the biggest winners by 2021.But the government’s notes on the Queen’s speech also mention its plans to raise starting pay for qualified teachers to £30,000 by 2022, a pledge which will have to be funded out of school budgets.And while the government is correct to claim that the extra £400m for post-16 education is the biggest increase since 2010, the college sector has been starved of funds in that time. Geoff Barton, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, says: | From next year some of the extra funding will be distributed by minimum per-pupil funding via the new national funding formula, the Department for Education has announced. That helps the most poorly funded schools outside of cities, with £3,750 for each primary pupil and £5,000 for secondary pupils, with primaries rising again to £4,000 per pupil in 2021. Schools in Bedfordshire appear to be the biggest winners by 2021.But the government’s notes on the Queen’s speech also mention its plans to raise starting pay for qualified teachers to £30,000 by 2022, a pledge which will have to be funded out of school budgets.And while the government is correct to claim that the extra £400m for post-16 education is the biggest increase since 2010, the college sector has been starved of funds in that time. Geoff Barton, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders, says: |
| While the Commons continues to debate the Queen’s speech, at Holyrood MSPs have been debating the final stage of the referendums (Scotland) bill, the framework bill which paves the way for a second independence referendum, should it be approved by Westminster, as the first minster, Nicola Sturgeon, demanded earlier today. This framework bill does not set the date or question on the ballot, which have to be specified in further primary legislation, and much of the debate has centred around that question and whether it will be the same yes/no as 2014. | While the Commons continues to debate the Queen’s speech, at Holyrood MSPs have been debating the final stage of the referendums (Scotland) bill, the framework bill which paves the way for a second independence referendum, should it be approved by Westminster, as the first minster, Nicola Sturgeon, demanded earlier today. This framework bill does not set the date or question on the ballot, which have to be specified in further primary legislation, and much of the debate has centred around that question and whether it will be the same yes/no as 2014. |
| The draft bill originally stated the Electoral Commission would not be consulted if it had previously assessed or recommended a question, as with the yes/no format for the 2014 referendum. | The draft bill originally stated the Electoral Commission would not be consulted if it had previously assessed or recommended a question, as with the yes/no format for the 2014 referendum. |
| Critics argued yes/no favoured the affirmative side, and the commission subsequently recommended the options of leave and remain for the 2016 EU referendum. | Critics argued yes/no favoured the affirmative side, and the commission subsequently recommended the options of leave and remain for the 2016 EU referendum. |
| While the commission has not ruled out a future yes/no question on independence, it believes the assessment should be based on current evidence and political context, and now a compromise amendment has been accepted which states, in summary: if the question has been asked within the same parliamentary session then the commission does not automatically have to assess the question (though Holyrood can ask for it to do so), and if the question has been asked in the previous parliamentary session then Scottish ministers can lodge a motion to extend the ‘validity period’ of the question which, if passed, would mean the question did not need to be reassessed. | While the commission has not ruled out a future yes/no question on independence, it believes the assessment should be based on current evidence and political context, and now a compromise amendment has been accepted which states, in summary: if the question has been asked within the same parliamentary session then the commission does not automatically have to assess the question (though Holyrood can ask for it to do so), and if the question has been asked in the previous parliamentary session then Scottish ministers can lodge a motion to extend the ‘validity period’ of the question which, if passed, would mean the question did not need to be reassessed. |
| This really only matters if a second independence referendum is held next year – beyond 2021, the question will not have been asked in the past two sessions and so will automatically have to be assessed again. | This really only matters if a second independence referendum is held next year – beyond 2021, the question will not have been asked in the past two sessions and so will automatically have to be assessed again. |
| Theresa May, the former prime minister, spoke in the Queen’s speech debate after Ian Blackford. On election night, when interviewed by the BBC’s Andrew Neil, she had difficulty answering a question from him about why Boris Johnson had been able to win dozens of leave-voting Labour seats when her attempt to do the same thing in 2017 failed. This afternoon she had a clear answer to that question. She said: | Theresa May, the former prime minister, spoke in the Queen’s speech debate after Ian Blackford. On election night, when interviewed by the BBC’s Andrew Neil, she had difficulty answering a question from him about why Boris Johnson had been able to win dozens of leave-voting Labour seats when her attempt to do the same thing in 2017 failed. This afternoon she had a clear answer to that question. She said: |
| Here are some lines from the afternoon No 10 briefing. These are from the Sun’s Tom Newton Dunn and the Daily Mirror’s Pippa Crerar. | Here are some lines from the afternoon No 10 briefing. These are from the Sun’s Tom Newton Dunn and the Daily Mirror’s Pippa Crerar. |
| In an interview at the time of the Conservative party conference Boris Johnson hinted that he was in favour of confirmation hearings of this kind. He said: | In an interview at the time of the Conservative party conference Boris Johnson hinted that he was in favour of confirmation hearings of this kind. He said: |
| But Geoffrey Cox, the attorney general, has said he would not be enthusiastic about this. | But Geoffrey Cox, the attorney general, has said he would not be enthusiastic about this. |
| That is a reference to this HuffPost story. | That is a reference to this HuffPost story. |
| Zac Goldsmith, who lost his seat as MP for Richmond Park last week, is being given a peerage, No 10 has announced. This will allow him to carry on as an environment minister based jointly in the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and in the Department for International Development, an appointment that No 10 has also confirmed. | Zac Goldsmith, who lost his seat as MP for Richmond Park last week, is being given a peerage, No 10 has announced. This will allow him to carry on as an environment minister based jointly in the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and in the Department for International Development, an appointment that No 10 has also confirmed. |
| In this role he will attend cabinet, as he did when he was doing this job before the election, government sources have confirmed. | In this role he will attend cabinet, as he did when he was doing this job before the election, government sources have confirmed. |
| It was widely expected that Goldsmith would get a peerage. A lifelong environmentalist, he was regarded as particularly well qualified for his ministerial post. He is also a committed Brexiter (his billionaire father set up the Referendum party, an early Eurosceptic party that made the case for a referendum on the EU in the 1990s) and he is good friends with the PM’s partner Carrie Symonds, who once worked for Goldsmith as an adviser and who campaigned for him during the election. Like Johnson, Goldsmith is also an Old Etonian. | It was widely expected that Goldsmith would get a peerage. A lifelong environmentalist, he was regarded as particularly well qualified for his ministerial post. He is also a committed Brexiter (his billionaire father set up the Referendum party, an early Eurosceptic party that made the case for a referendum on the EU in the 1990s) and he is good friends with the PM’s partner Carrie Symonds, who once worked for Goldsmith as an adviser and who campaigned for him during the election. Like Johnson, Goldsmith is also an Old Etonian. |
| In his speech in the Queen’s speech debate Ian Blackford, the SNP’s leader at Westminster, challenged Boris Johnson to explain why he would not allow the Scottish government to hold another independence referendum. Blackford said: | In his speech in the Queen’s speech debate Ian Blackford, the SNP’s leader at Westminster, challenged Boris Johnson to explain why he would not allow the Scottish government to hold another independence referendum. Blackford said: |
| At one point Blackford criticised Johnson for looking at his phone during the speech. It was “not a good look”, Blackford said. In response, Johnson said Blackford should say something interesting. Blackford replied: | At one point Blackford criticised Johnson for looking at his phone during the speech. It was “not a good look”, Blackford said. In response, Johnson said Blackford should say something interesting. Blackford replied: |
| This is what my colleague Simon Murphy wrote in September on the feasibility of building a bridge between Scotland and Northern Ireland. | This is what my colleague Simon Murphy wrote in September on the feasibility of building a bridge between Scotland and Northern Ireland. |
| Boris Johnson’s comment about a bridge between Northern Ireland and Scotland may help to explain this reference to a large-scale infrastructure project in a letter (pdf) published this week by the advisory committee on business appointments, approving a part-time job with an iron and steel making company being taken by the former minister Jo Johnson (the PM’s brother). At one point Jo Johnson was a transport minister. | Boris Johnson’s comment about a bridge between Northern Ireland and Scotland may help to explain this reference to a large-scale infrastructure project in a letter (pdf) published this week by the advisory committee on business appointments, approving a part-time job with an iron and steel making company being taken by the former minister Jo Johnson (the PM’s brother). At one point Jo Johnson was a transport minister. |
| Towards the end of Boris Johnson’s speech, the DUP MP Ian Paisley intervened and asked him to go ahead with the proposal to build a “Boris bridge” between Scotland and Northern Ireland. In response, Johnson hinted that he does want to pursue the idea. He said: | Towards the end of Boris Johnson’s speech, the DUP MP Ian Paisley intervened and asked him to go ahead with the proposal to build a “Boris bridge” between Scotland and Northern Ireland. In response, Johnson hinted that he does want to pursue the idea. He said: |
| Johnson has hinted at his support for the construction of a bridge linking Scotland and Northern Ireland several times in the past, most recently in September, although one expert has described the idea as “about as feasible as building a bridge to the moon”. | Johnson has hinted at his support for the construction of a bridge linking Scotland and Northern Ireland several times in the past, most recently in September, although one expert has described the idea as “about as feasible as building a bridge to the moon”. |
| In the Commons, Boris Johnson is now winding up. He says, after dithering and platitudes, the time has come for action. That is what is is offering, he says. | In the Commons, Boris Johnson is now winding up. He says, after dithering and platitudes, the time has come for action. That is what is is offering, he says. |