This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/17/us/california-boardroom-gender-quota.html

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
California Companies Are Rushing to Find Female Board Members California Companies Are Rushing to Find Female Board Members
(25 days later)
— Jeanne Branthover, managing partner at the executive-level recruiting firm DHR International.— Jeanne Branthover, managing partner at the executive-level recruiting firm DHR International.
In the early 1990s, Bill Entringer, then chief executive of Selective Insurance, decided he wanted Joan Lamm-Tennant — a tenured professor at Villanova University with a Ph.D. in finance — to join his board.In the early 1990s, Bill Entringer, then chief executive of Selective Insurance, decided he wanted Joan Lamm-Tennant — a tenured professor at Villanova University with a Ph.D. in finance — to join his board.
Lamm-Tennant had never served on a board before and certainly didn’t have the letters C.E.O. on her résumé.Lamm-Tennant had never served on a board before and certainly didn’t have the letters C.E.O. on her résumé.
Without that kind of background, a search firm “would have never called me,” Lamm-Tennant said. Entringer appointed her anyway — the company’s first and only female director.Without that kind of background, a search firm “would have never called me,” Lamm-Tennant said. Entringer appointed her anyway — the company’s first and only female director.
Fast forward almost three decades and things are starting to change.Fast forward almost three decades and things are starting to change.
In September 2018, California became the first state to legally compel corporate board diversity with a law mandating that every public company in the state have at least one female director by the end of 2019. The law set off a scramble to find hundreds of female directors, many of whom don’t fit the traditional mold.In September 2018, California became the first state to legally compel corporate board diversity with a law mandating that every public company in the state have at least one female director by the end of 2019. The law set off a scramble to find hundreds of female directors, many of whom don’t fit the traditional mold.
If companies fail to comply with that mandate, they face a one-time fine of $100,000.If companies fail to comply with that mandate, they face a one-time fine of $100,000.
By the end of 2021, the law’s requirements ramp up, compelling companies with five board members to have at least two female directors and at least three on six-person boards. If companies continue to break the law, they face a steeper penalty of $300,000 for every seat that should be filled by a woman.By the end of 2021, the law’s requirements ramp up, compelling companies with five board members to have at least two female directors and at least three on six-person boards. If companies continue to break the law, they face a steeper penalty of $300,000 for every seat that should be filled by a woman.
The text of the law, signed by former Gov. Jerry Brown, cites several studies that found an association between diverse boards and enhanced company performance, though researchers also emphasized that the link wasn’t evidence of cause and effect.The text of the law, signed by former Gov. Jerry Brown, cites several studies that found an association between diverse boards and enhanced company performance, though researchers also emphasized that the link wasn’t evidence of cause and effect.
For years, governments across Europe have been pushing similar efforts, with Norway becoming the world’s first country to put in place a gender quota in 2008, and France, Germany, Spain and Italy following suit.For years, governments across Europe have been pushing similar efforts, with Norway becoming the world’s first country to put in place a gender quota in 2008, and France, Germany, Spain and Italy following suit.
But the California mandate isn’t without controversy.But the California mandate isn’t without controversy.
Two lawsuits filed this year argue that the law is unconstitutional because it “seeks to force shareholders to perpetuate sex-based discrimination,” according to one of the plaintiffs, Creighton Meland Jr., a shareholder in OSI Securities. Two lawsuits filed this year argue that the law is unconstitutional because it “seeks to force shareholders to perpetuate sex-based discrimination,” according to one of the plaintiffs, Creighton Meland Jr., a shareholder in OSI Systems.
In the U.S., women hold about 20 percent of board seats at companies listed in the Russell 3000 stock index, up from 17 percent in 2018, according to the nonprofit 2020 Women on Boards. Of the more than 600 companies based in California that are listed on a major stock exchange, almost one-third had no women on the board when the law was passed.In the U.S., women hold about 20 percent of board seats at companies listed in the Russell 3000 stock index, up from 17 percent in 2018, according to the nonprofit 2020 Women on Boards. Of the more than 600 companies based in California that are listed on a major stock exchange, almost one-third had no women on the board when the law was passed.
As the Dec. 31 deadline creeps closer, 30 to 60 companies still haven’t added a woman to the board. Researchers who have been tracking the shift over the past year don’t agree on the final figure because of a flurry of recent activity, with some companies naming female directors in just the past few weeks. One firm, Clean Energy Fuel Corp., named a woman to its board last Tuesday and, two days later, OSI Securities named a female director. As the Dec. 31 deadline creeps closer, 30 to 60 companies still haven’t added a woman to the board. Researchers who have been tracking the shift over the past year don’t agree on the final figure because of a flurry of recent activity, with some companies naming female directors in just the past few weeks. One firm, Clean Energy Fuel Corp., named a woman to its board last Tuesday and, two days later, OSI Systems named a female director.
The companies that have not yet added any women tend to be young firms in the high-tech or biotech industries with small boards to begin with and relatively smaller market capitalizations, explained Kathleen Kahle, a professor of finance at the University of Arizona who has been closely monitoring the change in California.The companies that have not yet added any women tend to be young firms in the high-tech or biotech industries with small boards to begin with and relatively smaller market capitalizations, explained Kathleen Kahle, a professor of finance at the University of Arizona who has been closely monitoring the change in California.
For these companies, adding an additional board member can be costly. The average director pay for all California firms hovers around $181,000 (nearly double the $100,000 fine), and there are additional costs of travel related to board meetings, Kahle added.For these companies, adding an additional board member can be costly. The average director pay for all California firms hovers around $181,000 (nearly double the $100,000 fine), and there are additional costs of travel related to board meetings, Kahle added.
Another hindrance is the perceived lack of experience. Historically, boards sought candidates who had served as a public company chief executive. And because public companies, for decades, have largely been run by men, director candidates have typically been limited to, well, men.Another hindrance is the perceived lack of experience. Historically, boards sought candidates who had served as a public company chief executive. And because public companies, for decades, have largely been run by men, director candidates have typically been limited to, well, men.
“We’re trying to teach boards to let us introduce ‘board-ready’ women,” said Jeanne Branthover, a managing partner at the executive-level recruiting firm DHR International, referring to women with senior, C-Suite level experience who might have served on nonprofit boards or school boards or presented to their own boards. However, that doesn’t mean the quality of the female candidates dips, Branthover was quick to emphasize.“We’re trying to teach boards to let us introduce ‘board-ready’ women,” said Jeanne Branthover, a managing partner at the executive-level recruiting firm DHR International, referring to women with senior, C-Suite level experience who might have served on nonprofit boards or school boards or presented to their own boards. However, that doesn’t mean the quality of the female candidates dips, Branthover was quick to emphasize.
“They’re qualified and they’re ready,” Branthover said.“They’re qualified and they’re ready,” Branthover said.
Other companies have put forward women within their own network, Kahle said. “In many cases, the woman that was added was someone who was already a company insider,” she added. “So maybe the legal adviser or, on the biotech companies, often some sort of doctor.”Other companies have put forward women within their own network, Kahle said. “In many cases, the woman that was added was someone who was already a company insider,” she added. “So maybe the legal adviser or, on the biotech companies, often some sort of doctor.”
That shift has reimagined what each board member should bring to the table and thus widened the talent pool.That shift has reimagined what each board member should bring to the table and thus widened the talent pool.
Board seats are being redefined as functional roles “instead of everybody being former C.E.O.s and C.F.O.s who don’t have deep knowledge of certain functions,” said Robin Toft, founder of the San Francisco-based Toft Group Executive Search, who specializes in placing women on boards. In the past year, her firm did more board searches than it had done in the past 10 years.Board seats are being redefined as functional roles “instead of everybody being former C.E.O.s and C.F.O.s who don’t have deep knowledge of certain functions,” said Robin Toft, founder of the San Francisco-based Toft Group Executive Search, who specializes in placing women on boards. In the past year, her firm did more board searches than it had done in the past 10 years.
The California law has also had a ripple effect, as state lawmakers in New York and New Jersey consider similar mandates. Companies across the country, spurred on by activist investors, such as BlackRock, have been actively diversifying their boards.The California law has also had a ripple effect, as state lawmakers in New York and New Jersey consider similar mandates. Companies across the country, spurred on by activist investors, such as BlackRock, have been actively diversifying their boards.
“You know, there’s that old saying, ‘One woman is a presence, three is a voice,’” said Lamm-Tennant, who now serves on the boards of AXA Equitable Holdings, Element Financial Management Corp. and Ambac Financial Group.“You know, there’s that old saying, ‘One woman is a presence, three is a voice,’” said Lamm-Tennant, who now serves on the boards of AXA Equitable Holdings, Element Financial Management Corp. and Ambac Financial Group.
By the time she left her position as director at Selective Insurance in 2015, she had helped get three other women onto the board there.By the time she left her position as director at Selective Insurance in 2015, she had helped get three other women onto the board there.
Readers, does the California mandate strike you as a good way to narrow the gender gap on boards? Share your views.Readers, does the California mandate strike you as a good way to narrow the gender gap on boards? Share your views.
Here are five articles from The Times you might have missed.Here are five articles from The Times you might have missed.
“We are truly sorry for the hurt and disappointment this has caused.” The Hallmark Channel pulled four TV ads for the wedding website Zola that featured brides kissing, then apologized for its decision after days of backlash. [Read the story]“We are truly sorry for the hurt and disappointment this has caused.” The Hallmark Channel pulled four TV ads for the wedding website Zola that featured brides kissing, then apologized for its decision after days of backlash. [Read the story]
#wildwoman #witch #laloba Decades after it was published, “Women Who Run With the Wolves” has returned to a culture suddenly lush with primal visions of women’s bodies — dripping with blood, coursing with hormones and pulsing with pain and arousal. [Read the essay]#wildwoman #witch #laloba Decades after it was published, “Women Who Run With the Wolves” has returned to a culture suddenly lush with primal visions of women’s bodies — dripping with blood, coursing with hormones and pulsing with pain and arousal. [Read the essay]
“This crown is not mine but yours.” With Toni-Ann Singh of Jamaica winning the Miss World pageant on Saturday, black women now hold crowns in five major beauty pageants. [Read the story]“This crown is not mine but yours.” With Toni-Ann Singh of Jamaica winning the Miss World pageant on Saturday, black women now hold crowns in five major beauty pageants. [Read the story]
“I felt so scared. I didn’t know that I was going to be cut open.” Uganda’s 800-meter Olympic hopeful says she was advised to undergo an irreversible operation because of naturally elevated testosterone levels. Her career never recovered. [Read the story]“I felt so scared. I didn’t know that I was going to be cut open.” Uganda’s 800-meter Olympic hopeful says she was advised to undergo an irreversible operation because of naturally elevated testosterone levels. Her career never recovered. [Read the story]
“People just don’t want to believe it’s true in their own backyard.” Fashion Nova makes fast fashion for the Instagram elite, but its clothes are stitched together by a work force in the United States that is paid illegally low wages. [Read the story]“People just don’t want to believe it’s true in their own backyard.” Fashion Nova makes fast fashion for the Instagram elite, but its clothes are stitched together by a work force in the United States that is paid illegally low wages. [Read the story]
Two new surveys — one by New America and the other by Boston College Center for Work and Family — paint a stereotypical picture of the state of parental leave in the U.S.Two new surveys — one by New America and the other by Boston College Center for Work and Family — paint a stereotypical picture of the state of parental leave in the U.S.
When push comes to shove, men and women resort to traditional roles: Women will take a step back at work to prioritize family, and men will do less at home to prioritize work.When push comes to shove, men and women resort to traditional roles: Women will take a step back at work to prioritize family, and men will do less at home to prioritize work.
About one-third of the almost 3,000 parents surveyed by New America said they hadn’t taken any leave to care for a new child.About one-third of the almost 3,000 parents surveyed by New America said they hadn’t taken any leave to care for a new child.
And while more men want to take paid parental leave, 55 percent of respondents in the study by Boston College Center for Work and Family said they were less likely to feel supported by senior management in doing so.And while more men want to take paid parental leave, 55 percent of respondents in the study by Boston College Center for Work and Family said they were less likely to feel supported by senior management in doing so.
In Her Words is written by Alisha Haridasani Gupta and edited by Francesca Donner. Our art director is Catherine Gilmore-Barnes, and our photo editor is Sandra Stevenson.In Her Words is written by Alisha Haridasani Gupta and edited by Francesca Donner. Our art director is Catherine Gilmore-Barnes, and our photo editor is Sandra Stevenson.
Did someone forward you this email? Sign up here to get future installments. You can also follow us on Instagram or email us at inherwords@nytimes.com.Did someone forward you this email? Sign up here to get future installments. You can also follow us on Instagram or email us at inherwords@nytimes.com.