This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/17/world/americas/culiacan-mexico-chapo.html

The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 6 Version 7
Battles Break Out in Culiacán, Mexico, as El Chapo’s Son Is Arrested and Released Mexico’s President Defends Response to Drug Cartel Mayhem
(about 11 hours later)
MEXICO CITY — Cartel gunmen paralyzed a major Mexican city on Thursday, unleashing hails of automatic gunfire in broad daylight in a staggering show of force after soldiers arrested and then released Ovidio Guzmán López, the son of the infamous drug lord Joaquín Guzmán Loera. MEXICO CITY — The president of Mexico on Friday defended the conciliatory response of his country’s security forces to the mayhem that a drug cartel unleashed in a major Mexican city a day earlier. President Andrés Manuel López Obrador said that the soldiers had saved the lives of innocent civilians by releasing the man whose arrest ignited the violence, a son of the infamous jailed drug lord El Chapo.
The violence began shortly after 3:30 p.m. in the city of Culiacán, the capital of Sinaloa State, when a patrol of 30 soldiers came under attack by individuals in a home in the neighborhood of Tres Ríos, according to government officials. Mr. López Obrador spoke a day after well-armed cartel gunmen paralyzed the northwestern city of Culiacán, unleashing hails of automatic gunfire in broad daylight in response to the arrest of Ovidio Guzmán López, one of the children of El Chapo, whose real name is Joaquín Guzmán Loera. The son was later released by the outgunned soldiers.
“Decisions were made that I support, that I endorse because the situation turned very bad and lots of citizens were at risk, lots of people and it was decided to protect the life of the people,” Mr. López Obrador said. “You cannot value the life of a delinquent more than the lives of the people.”
The scope of the violence on Thursday, and the decision to release the son, was stunning even in Mexico, where life is frequently punctuated by drug-related violence and impunity by cartel fighters. It was a major humiliation for the government of President López Obrador, who has struggled to articulate a clear security strategy to combat Mexico’s record violence.
Questions over it quickly came up at Mr. López Obrador’s regular morning news conference on Friday, but he sought to frame what had happened as a responsible action by government security forces.
“The officials who took this decision did well,” the president said, arguing that it had averted civilian casualties.
The violence began shortly after 3:30 p.m. in Culiacán, the capital of Sinaloa State, when a patrol of 30 soldiers came under attack by individuals in a home in the neighborhood of Tres Ríos, according to government officials.
After taking control of the home, the security forces encountered and detained four men — among them Mr. Guzmán López, a leader in the Sinaloa cartel. Cartel gunmen then surrounded the home and engaged the armed forces, the officials said. But they ultimately decided to release him.After taking control of the home, the security forces encountered and detained four men — among them Mr. Guzmán López, a leader in the Sinaloa cartel. Cartel gunmen then surrounded the home and engaged the armed forces, the officials said. But they ultimately decided to release him.
Later, the cartel deployed fighters throughout the neighborhood and began burning vehicles and blockading streets throughout the city.Later, the cartel deployed fighters throughout the neighborhood and began burning vehicles and blockading streets throughout the city.
Gunfire continued into Thursday night, as soldiers and cartel fighters battled in the streets. In its brief statement, the government said it had opted to suspend its operation, but did not elaborate on what exactly that meant. Later, it became clear through local media that the government forces had indeed released Mr. Guzmán López back into the custody of the cartel. Gunfire continued into Thursday night, as soldiers and cartel fighters battled in the streets. In its brief statement, the government said it had opted to suspend its operation, but did not elaborate on what exactly that meant. Later, it became clear through local media that the government forces had indeed released Mr. Guzmán López, who returned to the cartel.
The development was a major humiliation for the government of President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, who has struggled to articulate a clear security strategy to combat Mexico’s record violence. Some analysts even cast doubt on the government narrative that 30 soldiers and national guardsmen were patrolling and came under attack by a small contingent of gunmen.
“My suspicion is that they went after him and they lost,” said Eduardo Guerrero, a security analyst in Mexico City.
The echo of gunfire sent citizens fleeing for safety as the assault began, while others sat trapped in their vehicles, capturing footage on cellphone cameras. The harrowing videos, uploaded onto social media, showed heavily armed men in ski masks blocking streets and halting traffic while plumes of black smoke filled the sky.The echo of gunfire sent citizens fleeing for safety as the assault began, while others sat trapped in their vehicles, capturing footage on cellphone cameras. The harrowing videos, uploaded onto social media, showed heavily armed men in ski masks blocking streets and halting traffic while plumes of black smoke filled the sky.
Others showed the powerful weaponry wielded by the traffickers, including mounted .50-caliber guns.Others showed the powerful weaponry wielded by the traffickers, including mounted .50-caliber guns.
In capturing Mr. Guzmán López on his home turf, at least before handing him back over, the government had hoped to deal yet another blow to the Sinaloa cartel, which has struggled to regain its footing after the arrest and conviction of the elder Mr. Guzman, its longtime leader, known as El Chapo. In capturing Mr. Guzmán López on his home turf, the government had hoped to deal yet another blow to the Sinaloa cartel, which has struggled to regain its footing after the arrest and conviction of the elder Mr. Guzmán, its longtime leader.
In its response, the cartel appeared to be sending a message of its own — and a far more powerful one.In its response, the cartel appeared to be sending a message of its own — and a far more powerful one.
“In my 21 years of covering crime at the heart of drug world, this has been the worst shootout and the most horrible situation I have ever encountered,” said Ernesto Martínez, a local crime reporter who was caught in the middle of a gun battle only a few feet away from his vehicle.“In my 21 years of covering crime at the heart of drug world, this has been the worst shootout and the most horrible situation I have ever encountered,” said Ernesto Martínez, a local crime reporter who was caught in the middle of a gun battle only a few feet away from his vehicle.
Mr. Martínez had gone to report on a separate shooting when he ran into an army vehicle, which had stopped a car with individuals carrying machine guns. Suddenly, he said, the gunfire started and the soldiers yelled: “Everybody down, shootout!”Mr. Martínez had gone to report on a separate shooting when he ran into an army vehicle, which had stopped a car with individuals carrying machine guns. Suddenly, he said, the gunfire started and the soldiers yelled: “Everybody down, shootout!”
Mr. Martínez said he then noticed a white vehicle with masked men shooting at the soldiers. He was still recording video of the scene as he drove to the nearest gas station looking for shelter.Mr. Martínez said he then noticed a white vehicle with masked men shooting at the soldiers. He was still recording video of the scene as he drove to the nearest gas station looking for shelter.
“The sound of the bullets was so strong I could almost smell the gunpowder,” he said.“The sound of the bullets was so strong I could almost smell the gunpowder,” he said.
The gunfight lasted for 20 minutes before another one erupted, he said. The second shootout lasted for almost four hours, he said, and continued late into Thursday.The gunfight lasted for 20 minutes before another one erupted, he said. The second shootout lasted for almost four hours, he said, and continued late into Thursday.
Mr. Martínez said most of the confrontations took place in Tres Ríos, an upscale commercial and business district, but he said chaos reigned throughout the city with burned vehicles and houses and roadblocks in different locations, and gunshots being fired at government buildings, including the state attorney’s office.Mr. Martínez said most of the confrontations took place in Tres Ríos, an upscale commercial and business district, but he said chaos reigned throughout the city with burned vehicles and houses and roadblocks in different locations, and gunshots being fired at government buildings, including the state attorney’s office.
Hours after the mayhem began, most businesses had closed, with people locked down in their houses and public transportation suspended in what Mr. Martínez described as a “self-imposed” state of emergency.Hours after the mayhem began, most businesses had closed, with people locked down in their houses and public transportation suspended in what Mr. Martínez described as a “self-imposed” state of emergency.
Mexico is facing its deadliest year since the country began recording homicide statistics more than 20 years ago. Warfare between rival cartels fighting for control of the drug trade to the United States has turned parts of the country into some of the deadliest places on earth.Mexico is facing its deadliest year since the country began recording homicide statistics more than 20 years ago. Warfare between rival cartels fighting for control of the drug trade to the United States has turned parts of the country into some of the deadliest places on earth.
The government has continued to target top cartel leaders in its now 13-year war on drugs. This despite the fact that the so-called kingpin strategy has helped usher in the nation’s most violent period in recent history. The government has continued to target top cartel leaders in its now 13-year war on drugs. This so-called kingpin strategy has helped usher in the nation’s most violent period in recent history.
It is not unheard-of for cartel assassins to stage brazen attacks in broad daylight, often in response to an arrest of a high-ranking member or to target their enemies. In May of last year, gunmen stormed a Japanese restaurant in Guadalajara, targeting a former state prosecutor and setting off a gun battle in an upscale area of the city.It is not unheard-of for cartel assassins to stage brazen attacks in broad daylight, often in response to an arrest of a high-ranking member or to target their enemies. In May of last year, gunmen stormed a Japanese restaurant in Guadalajara, targeting a former state prosecutor and setting off a gun battle in an upscale area of the city.
Rumors quickly began circulating on social media late Thursday that the gunfights were related to the cartel that was run by Joaquín Guzmán Loera, which remains powerful in Sinaloa, his home state. He was convicted in February in the United States on drug, murder and money laundering charges, and was sentenced to life in prison. Rumors quickly began circulating on social media late Thursday that the gunfights were related to the Sinaloa cartel, which remains powerful locally.
The elder Mr. Guzmán was convicted in February in the United States on drug, murder and money laundering charges, and was sentenced to life in prison.
In February, the Justice Department charged two of his sons, Joaquín Guzmán López and Ovidio Guzmán López, with one count each of conspiracy to “knowingly, intentionally, and willfully” distribute cocaine, methamphetamine and marijuana for import into the United States.In February, the Justice Department charged two of his sons, Joaquín Guzmán López and Ovidio Guzmán López, with one count each of conspiracy to “knowingly, intentionally, and willfully” distribute cocaine, methamphetamine and marijuana for import into the United States.
Two of Joaquín Guzmán López Loera’s older sons who helped take over his business after his arrest in 2016, Iván Archivaldo Guzmán Salazar and Jesús Alfredo Guzmán Salazar, also face charges in the United States. The drug kingpin’s sons were often mentioned during his trial, and they were accused of helping to orchestrate his tunnel escape from a maximum-security prison in Almoloya, Mexico, in 2015. Two more of Joaquín Guzmán López Loera’s sons who helped take over his business after his arrest in 2016, Iván Archivaldo Guzmán Salazar and Jesús Alfredo Guzmán Salazar, also face charges in the United States. The drug kingpin’s sons were often mentioned during his trial, and they were accused of helping to orchestrate his tunnel escape from a maximum-security prison in Almoloya, Mexico, in 2015.
But Thursday’s brazen display of firepower in the streets of Culiacán was extraordinary behavior for the Sinaloa cartel, which has generally tried to keep a lower profile, analysts said, a potential harbinger of a split in the nation’s once-dominant criminal organization.But Thursday’s brazen display of firepower in the streets of Culiacán was extraordinary behavior for the Sinaloa cartel, which has generally tried to keep a lower profile, analysts said, a potential harbinger of a split in the nation’s once-dominant criminal organization.
Some believe the cartel’s show of force might reflect a schism within the group, one that deepened with the arrest of El Chapo. Since then, various factions have been jockeying for control and some suspected that it might have been one of those factions that engaged in Thursday’s mayhem.Some believe the cartel’s show of force might reflect a schism within the group, one that deepened with the arrest of El Chapo. Since then, various factions have been jockeying for control and some suspected that it might have been one of those factions that engaged in Thursday’s mayhem.
“This break from the pattern signals a major disruption,” said Jaime López Aranda, a security analyst based in Mexico City. “I think that being so brazen and so open is the kind of thing done by organizations that are less disciplined and coherent and organized.”“This break from the pattern signals a major disruption,” said Jaime López Aranda, a security analyst based in Mexico City. “I think that being so brazen and so open is the kind of thing done by organizations that are less disciplined and coherent and organized.”
“The ability to exercise restraint is key to an organization’s survival in the long term,” he added. “Successful criminal organizations are able to restrain themselves, and Sinaloa has been successful for a long time.”“The ability to exercise restraint is key to an organization’s survival in the long term,” he added. “Successful criminal organizations are able to restrain themselves, and Sinaloa has been successful for a long time.”
Paulina Villegas and Kirk Semple contributed reporting.Paulina Villegas and Kirk Semple contributed reporting.