This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-49930863
The article has changed 13 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 8 | Version 9 |
---|---|
Trump-Ukraine: Text messages show diplomat's alarm over plans | Trump-Ukraine: Text messages show diplomat's alarm over plans |
(about 1 hour later) | |
Texts show how US officials worked to prod the Ukrainian president into opening a public inquiry into President Trump's leading opponent, Joe Biden. | Texts show how US officials worked to prod the Ukrainian president into opening a public inquiry into President Trump's leading opponent, Joe Biden. |
The messages, released by congressional Democrats, emerge as Mr Trump faces an impeachment inquiry over the matter. | The messages, released by congressional Democrats, emerge as Mr Trump faces an impeachment inquiry over the matter. |
The exchanges show a senior diplomat saying it would be "crazy" to withhold military aid to Ukraine for Mr Trump's political gain in the 2020 election. | The exchanges show a senior diplomat saying it would be "crazy" to withhold military aid to Ukraine for Mr Trump's political gain in the 2020 election. |
US law bans soliciting foreign help for electoral purposes. | US law bans soliciting foreign help for electoral purposes. |
But Mr Trump denies any wrongdoing and, on Friday, said there was "no quid pro quo" in the communications. | But Mr Trump denies any wrongdoing and, on Friday, said there was "no quid pro quo" in the communications. |
His remarks came a day after he publicly called on Ukraine and China to investigate Mr Biden, a top Democratic White House candidate, and his son, Hunter. | His remarks came a day after he publicly called on Ukraine and China to investigate Mr Biden, a top Democratic White House candidate, and his son, Hunter. |
The Republican president accuses his political opponents of a "witch hunt". | The Republican president accuses his political opponents of a "witch hunt". |
Impeachment in the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives would trigger a trial in the Senate. | Impeachment in the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives would trigger a trial in the Senate. |
Senators would have to vote to convict Mr Trump by a two-thirds majority to remove him from office. | Senators would have to vote to convict Mr Trump by a two-thirds majority to remove him from office. |
But that outcome is seen as unlikely given that the president's fellow Republicans control the upper chamber. | But that outcome is seen as unlikely given that the president's fellow Republicans control the upper chamber. |
What do the texts say? | What do the texts say? |
The impeachment inquiry stems from a 25 July call in which Mr Trump asked President Volodymyr Zelensky to investigate his rival. | The impeachment inquiry stems from a 25 July call in which Mr Trump asked President Volodymyr Zelensky to investigate his rival. |
The wide-ranging text message discussions are connected to allegations by the Democrats that Mr Trump dangled military aid as a way to press Ukraine to dig dirt on Mr Biden. | The wide-ranging text message discussions are connected to allegations by the Democrats that Mr Trump dangled military aid as a way to press Ukraine to dig dirt on Mr Biden. |
Sent between July and September, they involve high-ranking officials: | Sent between July and September, they involve high-ranking officials: |
On 19 July, the three diplomats discussed arranging a phone call between Mr Zelensky and Mr Trump. | On 19 July, the three diplomats discussed arranging a phone call between Mr Zelensky and Mr Trump. |
Mr Volker told the other two he had had breakfast with Mr Trump's lawyer, Rudy Giuliani that morning - and identified the main purpose of the upcoming phone call. | Mr Volker told the other two he had had breakfast with Mr Trump's lawyer, Rudy Giuliani that morning - and identified the main purpose of the upcoming phone call. |
"Most impt [important] is for Zelensky to say that he will help the investigation," he told the others. | "Most impt [important] is for Zelensky to say that he will help the investigation," he told the others. |
But Bill Taylor, the senior US diplomat in Ukraine, warned that President Zelensky "is sensitive" about Ukraine being seen "as an instrument in Washington domestic, re-election politics". | But Bill Taylor, the senior US diplomat in Ukraine, warned that President Zelensky "is sensitive" about Ukraine being seen "as an instrument in Washington domestic, re-election politics". |
Ahead of the call, Mr Volker texted that he had heard from the White House that Mr Zelensky would be offered a formal visit to Washington "assuming President Z convinces Trump he will investigate / 'get to the bottom of what happened in 2016'". | Ahead of the call, Mr Volker texted that he had heard from the White House that Mr Zelensky would be offered a formal visit to Washington "assuming President Z convinces Trump he will investigate / 'get to the bottom of what happened in 2016'". |
This is a reference to unfounded allegations that Ukraine interfered in the 2016 US presidential election and worked to help the Democrats. | This is a reference to unfounded allegations that Ukraine interfered in the 2016 US presidential election and worked to help the Democrats. |
In the call, Mr Trump asked Mr Zelensky to investigate Joe Biden. | In the call, Mr Trump asked Mr Zelensky to investigate Joe Biden. |
But text messages show US officials discussed what the Ukrainian president should say in a statement afterwards. | But text messages show US officials discussed what the Ukrainian president should say in a statement afterwards. |
By 13 August, Kurt Volker advised that Mr Zelensky's statement should address interference in US politics, "especially with the alleged involvement of some Ukrainian politicians" - and Burisma, the company Joe Biden's son was involved in. | By 13 August, Kurt Volker advised that Mr Zelensky's statement should address interference in US politics, "especially with the alleged involvement of some Ukrainian politicians" - and Burisma, the company Joe Biden's son was involved in. |
There has been no evidence of wrongdoing by Hunter Biden. | There has been no evidence of wrongdoing by Hunter Biden. |
Then, on 29 August, the tone of discussions changed. Mr Zelenksy's aide Andriy Yermak sent a curt message to Mr Volker, including a link to a Politico story headlined "Trump holds up Ukraine military aid meant to confront Russia". | Then, on 29 August, the tone of discussions changed. Mr Zelenksy's aide Andriy Yermak sent a curt message to Mr Volker, including a link to a Politico story headlined "Trump holds up Ukraine military aid meant to confront Russia". |
Mr Taylor, the senior diplomat in Ukraine, seemed to voice his concerns about the motives for the delay. | Mr Taylor, the senior diplomat in Ukraine, seemed to voice his concerns about the motives for the delay. |
"I think it's crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign," he said. | "I think it's crazy to withhold security assistance for help with a political campaign," he said. |
That suggestion, however, was firmly pushed back by Ambassador Gordon Sondland, who said Mr Taylor was misunderstanding the president's intentions. | That suggestion, however, was firmly pushed back by Ambassador Gordon Sondland, who said Mr Taylor was misunderstanding the president's intentions. |
What are Democrats and Republicans saying? | What are Democrats and Republicans saying? |
In a letter alongside the release of the texts, the Democratic chairmen of three committees investigating Mr Trump criticised his "now open defiance of our core values as American citizens". | |
"The President and his aides are engaging in a campaign of misinformation and misdirection in an attempt to normalise the act of soliciting foreign powers to interfere in our elections," wrote congressmen Eliot Engel, Adam Schiff and Elijah Cummings. | |
"This is not normal or acceptable. It is unethical, unpatriotic, and wrong." | "This is not normal or acceptable. It is unethical, unpatriotic, and wrong." |
But Republican Jim Jordan said Mr Volker's testimony on Thursday had "undercut the salacious narrative that Representative Adam Schiff is using to sell his impeachment ambitions". | But Republican Jim Jordan said Mr Volker's testimony on Thursday had "undercut the salacious narrative that Representative Adam Schiff is using to sell his impeachment ambitions". |
The House Oversight Committee - of which Mr Jordan is the ranking Republican member - tweeted that "this information [contained in the text messages] cannot possibly be understood without Volker's explanations from yesterday's testimony". | The House Oversight Committee - of which Mr Jordan is the ranking Republican member - tweeted that "this information [contained in the text messages] cannot possibly be understood without Volker's explanations from yesterday's testimony". |
He has called for the entire transcript of the testimony to be released. | He has called for the entire transcript of the testimony to be released. |
Mr Trump and his defenders have insisted there was no quid-pro-quo in his dealings with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Text messages between members of the US team involved in Ukrainian diplomacy, however, suggest a different story. | Mr Trump and his defenders have insisted there was no quid-pro-quo in his dealings with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Text messages between members of the US team involved in Ukrainian diplomacy, however, suggest a different story. |
It was very clear to them what Mr Trump wanted: a publicly announced Ukrainian investigation of political rival Joe Biden and the 2016 election hacking. | It was very clear to them what Mr Trump wanted: a publicly announced Ukrainian investigation of political rival Joe Biden and the 2016 election hacking. |
It also was very clear what they had to offer the Ukrainians: not only US military aid, which had been put on hold by the White House, but also a meeting between the two presidents in Washington that would have be extremely valuable in bolstering the legitimacy of the newly elected Ukrainian leader. | It also was very clear what they had to offer the Ukrainians: not only US military aid, which had been put on hold by the White House, but also a meeting between the two presidents in Washington that would have be extremely valuable in bolstering the legitimacy of the newly elected Ukrainian leader. |
Drawing a straight line between the offer and the ask doesn't take much imagination. | Drawing a straight line between the offer and the ask doesn't take much imagination. |
It may not be long before the White House falls back to its final line of defence - that threatening and cajoling Ukraine to investigate Mr Biden was justified by the egregiousness of Mr Biden's alleged corruption. | It may not be long before the White House falls back to its final line of defence - that threatening and cajoling Ukraine to investigate Mr Biden was justified by the egregiousness of Mr Biden's alleged corruption. |
With Mr Trump backed into a corner, it's a recipe for all-out political warfare. | With Mr Trump backed into a corner, it's a recipe for all-out political warfare. |
Four quick questions on Trump-Ukraine | Four quick questions on Trump-Ukraine |
Why is Mr Trump being investigated? | Why is Mr Trump being investigated? |
A whistleblower alleges he used "the power of his office to solicit interference from a foreign country in the US 2020 election", by asking Ukraine to investigate his main rival, Joe Biden. | A whistleblower alleges he used "the power of his office to solicit interference from a foreign country in the US 2020 election", by asking Ukraine to investigate his main rival, Joe Biden. |
Is this illegal? | Is this illegal? |
If this is what he's proven to have done, then yes: it's illegal to ask foreign entities for help winning a US election. Mr Trump says it's a witch-hunt and he did nothing wrong. | If this is what he's proven to have done, then yes: it's illegal to ask foreign entities for help winning a US election. Mr Trump says it's a witch-hunt and he did nothing wrong. |
What could happen next? | What could happen next? |
If the Democrat-controlled House of Representatives voted to impeach Mr Trump, there'd be a trial in the Senate. | If the Democrat-controlled House of Representatives voted to impeach Mr Trump, there'd be a trial in the Senate. |
Could he be removed? | Could he be removed? |
A Senate vote needs a two-thirds majority to convict, but Mr Trump's Republican party controls the Senate so that's unlikely. And the Mueller inquiry made clear you can't charge a sitting president with a crime. | A Senate vote needs a two-thirds majority to convict, but Mr Trump's Republican party controls the Senate so that's unlikely. And the Mueller inquiry made clear you can't charge a sitting president with a crime. |