This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/7773112.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| 'Hybrid embryo' legal block lost | 'Hybrid embryo' legal block lost |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| Christian campaigners have lost their High Court challenge to scientists being allowed to create human-animal embryos for research purposes. | Christian campaigners have lost their High Court challenge to scientists being allowed to create human-animal embryos for research purposes. |
| The Christian Legal Centre and Comment on Reproductive Ethics were refused permission to bring a test case application for judicial review. | The Christian Legal Centre and Comment on Reproductive Ethics were refused permission to bring a test case application for judicial review. |
| They had wanted to overturn a decision of the research regulator the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. | They had wanted to overturn a decision of the research regulator the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. |
| But the judge ruled their challenge was unarguable. | But the judge ruled their challenge was unarguable. |
| Mrs Justice Dobbs, sitting at the High Court in London, ruled that the application was "totally without merit". | Mrs Justice Dobbs, sitting at the High Court in London, ruled that the application was "totally without merit". |
| The Christian Legal Centre (CLC) and Comment on Reproductive Ethics had claimed the HFEA had operated unfairly in permitting the work. | |
| Curative work | Curative work |
| But the HFEA said all decisions were made in a transparent way that followed correct procedures. | But the HFEA said all decisions were made in a transparent way that followed correct procedures. |
| The challenge was against an HFEA ruling earlier this year to grant licences to scientists at Newcastle University and King's College London in January. A third team in Warwick has subsequently been granted a licence as well. We always believed that we acted lawfully and responsibly when considering these research licence applications An HFEA spokeswoman | The challenge was against an HFEA ruling earlier this year to grant licences to scientists at Newcastle University and King's College London in January. A third team in Warwick has subsequently been granted a licence as well. We always believed that we acted lawfully and responsibly when considering these research licence applications An HFEA spokeswoman |
| Supporters of inter-species research say their work could one day help treat or even cure patients with serious medical conditions. | Supporters of inter-species research say their work could one day help treat or even cure patients with serious medical conditions. |
| But Josephine Quintavalle, spokeswoman for Core and a named party in the action, said the regulator was "too pro-embryo research" and did not give opponents enough of a voice in the decision-making process. | But Josephine Quintavalle, spokeswoman for Core and a named party in the action, said the regulator was "too pro-embryo research" and did not give opponents enough of a voice in the decision-making process. |
| "The way the regulator works is not fair. No-one representing the interests of the embryo can sit on the committees that make decisions and once a decision has been reached we cannot appeal it." | "The way the regulator works is not fair. No-one representing the interests of the embryo can sit on the committees that make decisions and once a decision has been reached we cannot appeal it." |
| She also said the HFEA acted outside its jurisdiction - at the time of the January verdict a bill was still in the process of being drawn up covering this very issue. | She also said the HFEA acted outside its jurisdiction - at the time of the January verdict a bill was still in the process of being drawn up covering this very issue. |
| That bill has now been passed and will come into force next year allowing such applications to be considered. | That bill has now been passed and will come into force next year allowing such applications to be considered. |
| The HFEA has always maintained it was right to consider the original application as the 1990 law it was working under stipulated the regulator was able to interpret guidance as science progressed so as not to slow down research. | The HFEA has always maintained it was right to consider the original application as the 1990 law it was working under stipulated the regulator was able to interpret guidance as science progressed so as not to slow down research. |
| A spokeswoman said: "The HFEA is pleased with the court's decision. We always believed that we acted lawfully and responsibly when considering these research licence applications." | A spokeswoman said: "The HFEA is pleased with the court's decision. We always believed that we acted lawfully and responsibly when considering these research licence applications." |
| Andrea Minichiello Williams, spokeswoman for CLC, said: "This is a sad day for justice in this country." | |
| The CLC now faces a legal bill for £20,000. |