This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2019/jul/24/rspca-seriously-concerned-about-sanitised-live-export-observer-reports

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
RSPCA seriously concerned about 'sanitised' live export observer reports RSPCA seriously concerned about 'sanitised' live export observer reports
(about 1 hour later)
The Senate has called on the Department of Agriculture to release dozens of outstanding reports from independent observers on live export ships, more than a year after some of those voyages have ended.The Senate has called on the Department of Agriculture to release dozens of outstanding reports from independent observers on live export ships, more than a year after some of those voyages have ended.
The calls comes amid concern from the RSPCA the department is presenting a “sanitised” account of the voyages in some of the summarised reports.The calls comes amid concern from the RSPCA the department is presenting a “sanitised” account of the voyages in some of the summarised reports.
The Coalition introduced the requirement for independent observers on live export ships in April last year, after whistleblower footage of a ship taking sheep from Australia to the Middle East showed sheep suffering from extreme heat stress.The Coalition introduced the requirement for independent observers on live export ships in April last year, after whistleblower footage of a ship taking sheep from Australia to the Middle East showed sheep suffering from extreme heat stress.
A subsequent three-month ban on shipments during the Middle Eastern summer could be extended to the end of September.A subsequent three-month ban on shipments during the Middle Eastern summer could be extended to the end of September.
Australia's ban on live sheep trade could be extended due to heat stress riskAustralia's ban on live sheep trade could be extended due to heat stress risk
The Coalition backed the motion from the Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi on Wednesday, saying the observers were intended to provide greater transparency over the live export trade. Labor also backed the motion, which called on the government to release the outstanding reports and committed to releasing future reports in a timely manner.The Coalition backed the motion from the Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi on Wednesday, saying the observers were intended to provide greater transparency over the live export trade. Labor also backed the motion, which called on the government to release the outstanding reports and committed to releasing future reports in a timely manner.
Summary reports have only been completed for 20 of the 45 voyages for which an independent observer report was filed last year. No reports from 2019 have been published.Summary reports have only been completed for 20 of the 45 voyages for which an independent observer report was filed last year. No reports from 2019 have been published.
According to Vets Against Live Export, which has been requesting copies of the full observer reports under freedom of information laws, the summary reports frequently did not mention heat stress, even when the full reports show high wet bulb temperatures on deck or a significant number of mortalities caused by heat stress.According to Vets Against Live Export, which has been requesting copies of the full observer reports under freedom of information laws, the summary reports frequently did not mention heat stress, even when the full reports show high wet bulb temperatures on deck or a significant number of mortalities caused by heat stress.
They have echoed concerns raised by the RSPCA about the reports.They have echoed concerns raised by the RSPCA about the reports.
The RSPCA has previously criticised the department for refusing to release video footage filmed by the observers. Information about heat stress risk assessment plans, a key part of improving live export policy, was also redacted.The RSPCA has previously criticised the department for refusing to release video footage filmed by the observers. Information about heat stress risk assessment plans, a key part of improving live export policy, was also redacted.
“The RSPCA is very concerned about the extensive delays in publishing the summary observer reports,” RSPCA senior policy officer Jed Goodfellow said.“The RSPCA is very concerned about the extensive delays in publishing the summary observer reports,” RSPCA senior policy officer Jed Goodfellow said.
“The whole point of introducing the observer program was to improve transparency and get the ‘truth and proof’ about conditions onboard live export vessels. Having to wait up to a year before receiving a short, highly selective summary of the observer’s report is undermining the very purpose of the program.”“The whole point of introducing the observer program was to improve transparency and get the ‘truth and proof’ about conditions onboard live export vessels. Having to wait up to a year before receiving a short, highly selective summary of the observer’s report is undermining the very purpose of the program.”
Goodfellow said that when the reports were released, they sometimes contained “positive editorial,” like a remark in a report on a shipment of sheep and cattle to the Middle East on the Al Shuwaikh in June 2018 which noted that the observer’s “three subsequent voyages on board the Al Shuwaikh have not identified any further problems regarding the potential smothering, and this will be monitored on an on-going basis.”Goodfellow said that when the reports were released, they sometimes contained “positive editorial,” like a remark in a report on a shipment of sheep and cattle to the Middle East on the Al Shuwaikh in June 2018 which noted that the observer’s “three subsequent voyages on board the Al Shuwaikh have not identified any further problems regarding the potential smothering, and this will be monitored on an on-going basis.”
“The RSPCA also holds serious concerns over the sanitised nature of some of the summary reports,” Goodfellow said.“The RSPCA also holds serious concerns over the sanitised nature of some of the summary reports,” Goodfellow said.
Live exports: government refuses to release video showing heat stressLive exports: government refuses to release video showing heat stress
The department has said that all summary reports are approved by the independent observer in question before publication. Guardian Australia understands that concerns raised by observers about the nature of summaries was one of the reasons for the lengthy publication delay.The department has said that all summary reports are approved by the independent observer in question before publication. Guardian Australia understands that concerns raised by observers about the nature of summaries was one of the reasons for the lengthy publication delay.
Faruqi said the government’s promised transparency system had “fallen apart just eight months after it was established.”Faruqi said the government’s promised transparency system had “fallen apart just eight months after it was established.”
“It seems like the government is continuing to run interference for the live exports industry by delaying the release of these reports,” she said.“It seems like the government is continuing to run interference for the live exports industry by delaying the release of these reports,” she said.
Faruqi said continued reference to heat stress and unsanitary conditions in the 2018 reports, despite regulators introducing measures designed to reduce those issues, showed the industry could not be reformed.Faruqi said continued reference to heat stress and unsanitary conditions in the 2018 reports, despite regulators introducing measures designed to reduce those issues, showed the industry could not be reformed.
“This industry can’t be reformed, which is why we need to shut it down for good,” she said.“This industry can’t be reformed, which is why we need to shut it down for good,” she said.
The department has been contacted for comment. The department said it published the reports “as soon as practicable.”
“The timeframe to complete summary reports can vary depending on a number of factors, including the length of the journey,” a spokeswoman said.
“Un-redacted reports contain commercial-in-confidence information and will not be released as a matter of course ... The summary reports accurately reflect what has been observed and are checked for factual correctness by the observer prior to publication.”
Live exportsLive exports
Australian GreensAustralian Greens
Animal welfareAnimal welfare
AnimalsAnimals
Australian politicsAustralian politics
newsnews
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content