This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/11/us/white-house-tree-macron-trump.html

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Oak Tree Given to Trump by French President Has Died, Official Says Oak Tree Given to Trump by French President Has Died, Official Says
(about 4 hours later)
It wasn’t long after the oak tree arrived on the South Lawn of the White House, a gift from a World War I battlefield in France, that it suddenly disappeared.It wasn’t long after the oak tree arrived on the South Lawn of the White House, a gift from a World War I battlefield in France, that it suddenly disappeared.
The oak, which was supposed to be a symbol of a longstanding French-American alliance, had been placed in quarantine, because it was a living thing imported to the United States, the French ambassador said. It would be replanted, he said.The oak, which was supposed to be a symbol of a longstanding French-American alliance, had been placed in quarantine, because it was a living thing imported to the United States, the French ambassador said. It would be replanted, he said.
But that didn’t happen. Now, more than a year later, it appears we know why.But that didn’t happen. Now, more than a year later, it appears we know why.
The European sessile oak had died, a diplomatic official said. The European sessile oak had died, the French president, Emmanuel Macron, confirmed.
The circumstances of its death are a bit of a mystery. According to the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the person was not authorized to speak about the situation, experts who were consulted during the process said differences in soil composition often make it difficult for a foreign tree to take root. “It’s not a tragedy,” Mr. Macron said in an interview in Geneva with the Swiss broadcaster RTS. “One shouldn’t see symbols where there are none.”
The circumstances of its death are a bit of a mystery. According to a diplomatic official, experts who were consulted during the process said differences in soil composition often make it difficult for a foreign tree to take root.
“It so happens that for American sanitary reasons it underwent a quarantine, and the poor thing didn’t survive because it was subjected to a slightly difficult regimen,” Mr. Macron said in the interview, which was published on Tuesday, without specifying the exact circumstances of the tree’s demise.
The White House did not respond to requests for comment. The news first emerged in French media reports.The White House did not respond to requests for comment. The news first emerged in French media reports.
The European sessile oak was about five to 10 years old, according to the White House, when it was delivered in April 2018, a gift from President Emmanuel Macron on his first official state visit of the Trump administration. The European sessile oak was about five to 10 years old, according to the White House, when it was delivered in April 2018, a gift from Mr. Macron on his first official state visit of the Trump administration.
The tree stood less than five feet tall.The tree stood less than five feet tall.
But what it lacked in size and longevity (oaks in its family have been known to live for hundreds of years), it made up in the symbolism it was said to possess.But what it lacked in size and longevity (oaks in its family have been known to live for hundreds of years), it made up in the symbolism it was said to possess.
It was transplanted from Belleau Wood, a battlefield 60 miles east of Paris where thousands of Marines died in a battle against the Germans who were pushing toward the French capital.It was transplanted from Belleau Wood, a battlefield 60 miles east of Paris where thousands of Marines died in a battle against the Germans who were pushing toward the French capital.
When the oak was planted on the South Lawn, Mr. Macron, who had already enjoyed a rapport with President Trump, said he was pleased the tree “can now take root here at the White House in front of us as a symbol of the sacrifice and the common battles that France and the United States have led together,” according to a transcript of his remarks.When the oak was planted on the South Lawn, Mr. Macron, who had already enjoyed a rapport with President Trump, said he was pleased the tree “can now take root here at the White House in front of us as a symbol of the sacrifice and the common battles that France and the United States have led together,” according to a transcript of his remarks.
Mr. Trump and Mr. Macron stood for photos, shovels in hand, as the tree was planted. During the visit, the presidents hugged. There was a mutual kiss on the cheek.Mr. Trump and Mr. Macron stood for photos, shovels in hand, as the tree was planted. During the visit, the presidents hugged. There was a mutual kiss on the cheek.
The next day, Vice President Mike Pence said, “In the words of the Psalmist, may this relationship grow ‘like a tree firmly planted by streams of water, and produces its fruit in season whose leaf also does not wither.’”The next day, Vice President Mike Pence said, “In the words of the Psalmist, may this relationship grow ‘like a tree firmly planted by streams of water, and produces its fruit in season whose leaf also does not wither.’”
The relationship between Mr. Trump and Mr. Macron soured in the coming months over differences in approaches to security and trade, particularly Mr. Trump’s decision to withdraw from the multinational nuclear deal with Iran and to reimpose sanctions on the country.The relationship between Mr. Trump and Mr. Macron soured in the coming months over differences in approaches to security and trade, particularly Mr. Trump’s decision to withdraw from the multinational nuclear deal with Iran and to reimpose sanctions on the country.
At a meeting last November in France for the 100th anniversary of the end of World War I, the relationship appeared strained and forced — a marked contrast to Mr. Macron’s visit that April.At a meeting last November in France for the 100th anniversary of the end of World War I, the relationship appeared strained and forced — a marked contrast to Mr. Macron’s visit that April.
News of the oak’s death came as Mr. Trump again visited France, this time on the 75th anniversary of the D-Day invasion of World War II. The men tried to put their differences behind them.News of the oak’s death came as Mr. Trump again visited France, this time on the 75th anniversary of the D-Day invasion of World War II. The men tried to put their differences behind them.
Doug Tallamy, a professor at the University of Delaware who teaches courses on ecology, said it was not a surprise that the oak died. While oaks in the same family as the European oak exist in the United States, including the Washington area, he said a transplant of an oak already five to 10 years old necessarily involves damage to the roots.Doug Tallamy, a professor at the University of Delaware who teaches courses on ecology, said it was not a surprise that the oak died. While oaks in the same family as the European oak exist in the United States, including the Washington area, he said a transplant of an oak already five to 10 years old necessarily involves damage to the roots.
“Everybody wants instant gratification, so they want big trees,” he said. “You get a long-lasting wonderful tree if you plant it small and let the roots develop.”“Everybody wants instant gratification, so they want big trees,” he said. “You get a long-lasting wonderful tree if you plant it small and let the roots develop.”
In the interview, Mr. Macron vowed to send Mr. Trump a new oak from Belleau Wood.
“The shoveling Donald Trump and I did was a symbolic moment; it was strong,” Mr. Macron said. But what the oak itself symbolized was stronger, he added: the sacrifice of American Marines during World War I, and the friendship between France and the United States.
“And that’s much more important than us,” Mr. Macron said.