This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/7749433.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
'Hands off English football' | 'Hands off English football' |
(about 6 hours later) | |
By Chris Mason Europe correspondent, BBC News The new Arsenal captain Fabregas was signed at the age of 16 | |
There is growing opposition to European plans that would ban British football clubs from transferring players aged under 18. | |
The proposals are due to be discussed by Europe's sports ministers later this week - alongside the idea of having a European-wide super regulator that would be able to impose rules on clubs' debts. | The proposals are due to be discussed by Europe's sports ministers later this week - alongside the idea of having a European-wide super regulator that would be able to impose rules on clubs' debts. |
The government, the Premier League and Euro MPs from all the main British parties flatly reject the case for a new authority. | |
And they will be relieved that Michel Platini, the President of European football's governing body Uefa, has backed away from the idea, originally proposed by the French. | |
But stopping clubs transferring under-18s is still up for negotiation. | |
It is argued that very young players, particularly from Africa and South America, need protection to ensure, for instance, they get sufficient education. | |
We should celebrate the success of English football clubs, not apologise for it Chris Heaton Harris, MEP | We should celebrate the success of English football clubs, not apologise for it Chris Heaton Harris, MEP |
Premier League clubs accept this but are adamant they should still be able to sign young players like Arsenal's Cesc Fabregas. | |
Fabregas, who is Spanish, was signed by the North London club when he was just 16. | Fabregas, who is Spanish, was signed by the North London club when he was just 16. |
"We will call for a ban on underage transfers, and to stop the raiding of academies worldwide," said William Gaillard, Uefa's director of communications and Platini's special adviser. | |
"We feel this is a really dangerous situation which borders on a violation of human rights." | |
But Richard Scudamore, chief executive of the Premier League, insisted that while he was wholly supportive of a tightening up of the rules, a blanket ban would be unnecessarily restrictive. | |
This row, and the broader issue of the legitimacy or otherwise of a European sports regulator, is provoking a strong political reaction. | |
There is growing irritation among British MEPs in Brussels at what many see as unnecessary meddling in national sport. | |
One Liberal Democrat told me it was bad enough when sport and politics mixed, let alone sport and the European Union. | |
'Dangerous game' | 'Dangerous game' |
And the Conservatives agree. | And the Conservatives agree. |
"We should celebrate the success of English football clubs, not apologise for it," Tory MEP Chris Heaton Harris, who represents the East Midlands, said. | |
Mr Heaton Harris, who chairs the European Parliament Sports Group, added: "If you give the European Union any kind of power over sport it will be very difficult to get it back. | |
"Uefa are playing a dangerous game if they think they can curb the success of Premier League clubs by appealing to the EU. | |
"British Ministers must stick up for sports governing bodies and English football clubs and tell their European counterparts to keep their hands off British sport." | "British Ministers must stick up for sports governing bodies and English football clubs and tell their European counterparts to keep their hands off British sport." |
If that is a message Sports Minister Gerry Sutcliffe was not aware of a few days ago, he is now. | |
Leading figures in football, cricket, rugby union, rugby league and tennis have met Mr Sutcliffe to register their opposition. | |
And the British government has made its opposition clear to French Sports Minister Bernard Laporte, who has been pushing the idea. | |
As the current holders of the rotating Presidency of the EU, the French have been anything but inactive in recent months. | As the current holders of the rotating Presidency of the EU, the French have been anything but inactive in recent months. |
These latest proposals, to be discussed in Biarritz in France on Thursday and Friday, are likely to provoke very heated debate. | |
And there is very little, if any, support in British sport or politics for much of what is being suggested. |
Previous version
1
Next version