This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/02/business/airlines-cameras-privacy.html

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
There Are Probably Cameras on Your Flight, but Relax, They’re Not On (Yet) There Are Probably Cameras on Your Flight, but Relax, They’re Not On (Yet)
(about 11 hours later)
Vitaly Kamluk, a cybersecurity and malware expert, was returning from vacation on Singapore Airlines in February when his wife noticed a small circle that looked like a camera lens along the lower edge of the video screen in the seat back.Vitaly Kamluk, a cybersecurity and malware expert, was returning from vacation on Singapore Airlines in February when his wife noticed a small circle that looked like a camera lens along the lower edge of the video screen in the seat back.
“It really looked like a camera to me, but you can never be sure,” Mr. Kamluk said. So he took a photo of the circle and tweeted it to the airline.“It really looked like a camera to me, but you can never be sure,” Mr. Kamluk said. So he took a photo of the circle and tweeted it to the airline.
He got a quick response from Singapore, which acknowledged that it was a camera but said it had been “disabled.” He also got plenty of attention on Twitter.He got a quick response from Singapore, which acknowledged that it was a camera but said it had been “disabled.” He also got plenty of attention on Twitter.
Now, two senators have asked eight airlines based in the United States to respond in the next few weeks to questions about the cameras, including whether the airlines have used them “to monitor passengers” and whether passengers have been “informed of this practice.”Now, two senators have asked eight airlines based in the United States to respond in the next few weeks to questions about the cameras, including whether the airlines have used them “to monitor passengers” and whether passengers have been “informed of this practice.”
“I think it’s just outrageous,” said Senator Jeff Merkley, Democrat of Oregon, who sent the letter along with Senator John Kennedy, Republican of Louisiana. “I don’t want a camera staring at me, and I don’t think most passengers do.”“I think it’s just outrageous,” said Senator Jeff Merkley, Democrat of Oregon, who sent the letter along with Senator John Kennedy, Republican of Louisiana. “I don’t want a camera staring at me, and I don’t think most passengers do.”
Of the carriers that received the letter, at least three do not have any kind of embedded seat back screen. According to the Airline Passenger Experience Association, an airline trade group, the American carriers that do have cameras have not made them operational.Of the carriers that received the letter, at least three do not have any kind of embedded seat back screen. According to the Airline Passenger Experience Association, an airline trade group, the American carriers that do have cameras have not made them operational.
The high-definition cameras and the microphones that go with them are part of a new generation of systems offered by Panasonic and Thales, the two biggest airline entertainment system manufacturers. David Bartlett, chief technology officer for Panasonic, said the devices allowed passengers to have the same kind of interactive technology in the sky that they use on the ground.The high-definition cameras and the microphones that go with them are part of a new generation of systems offered by Panasonic and Thales, the two biggest airline entertainment system manufacturers. David Bartlett, chief technology officer for Panasonic, said the devices allowed passengers to have the same kind of interactive technology in the sky that they use on the ground.
“Whenever you introduce a new technology, you’re going to have challenges,” Mr. Bartlett said. “But I would say the demand for it has never been stronger than today. The expectation of a connected experience has never been stronger than it is today.”“Whenever you introduce a new technology, you’re going to have challenges,” Mr. Bartlett said. “But I would say the demand for it has never been stronger than today. The expectation of a connected experience has never been stronger than it is today.”
Mr. Bartlett gave a number of potential uses for the cameras, including seat-to-seat or seat-to-ground video chats, motion-activated control of movies, games and other options displayed on the screen and smart lighting that dims when the camera detects that the passenger is sleeping. Airlines, he said, could also create digitally branded frames so passengers could take selfies and share them on social media.Mr. Bartlett gave a number of potential uses for the cameras, including seat-to-seat or seat-to-ground video chats, motion-activated control of movies, games and other options displayed on the screen and smart lighting that dims when the camera detects that the passenger is sleeping. Airlines, he said, could also create digitally branded frames so passengers could take selfies and share them on social media.
The entertainment system manufacturers are embedding the cameras across all their product lines, which means, according to Joe Leader, chief executive officer of the Airline Passenger Experience Association, that airlines had no choice but to install them. And though the cameras have been on airliners for several years, most passengers did not seem to notice them.The entertainment system manufacturers are embedding the cameras across all their product lines, which means, according to Joe Leader, chief executive officer of the Airline Passenger Experience Association, that airlines had no choice but to install them. And though the cameras have been on airliners for several years, most passengers did not seem to notice them.
Of the reaction to Mr. Kamluk’s tweet, Dr. Leader said, “When people are surprised, it hits a nerve,” especially if they see a camera where they do not expect one.Of the reaction to Mr. Kamluk’s tweet, Dr. Leader said, “When people are surprised, it hits a nerve,” especially if they see a camera where they do not expect one.
Emirates, based in Dubai, seems to be one of the few airlines that have found a use for the camera installed on a portable tablet in its first-class suite. Using an app called Room Service, a passenger can talk to flight attendants. Emirates, based in Dubai, has found a use for the camera installed on a portable tablet in its first-class suite. Using an app called Room Service, a passenger can talk to flight attendants.
“We use it to allow the passenger to ask the crew for something, and they have a crew screen and camera in the galley,” said Patrick Brannelly, vice president for passenger experience at Emirates. The passenger has to enable the camera to be seen by the crew, but the passenger cannot see the crew in the galley, he said. “Emirates would never allow the camera to be on without making it 100 percent clear to the passenger that it was on.”“We use it to allow the passenger to ask the crew for something, and they have a crew screen and camera in the galley,” said Patrick Brannelly, vice president for passenger experience at Emirates. The passenger has to enable the camera to be seen by the crew, but the passenger cannot see the crew in the galley, he said. “Emirates would never allow the camera to be on without making it 100 percent clear to the passenger that it was on.”
After the tweet by Mr. Kamluk in February, the Airline Passenger Experience Association said its members were committed to obtaining “advance explicit customer permission” before using the cameras. In a statement, the association added that airline passengers were “typically tracked outside the aircraft dozens of times on a typical journey through stores, security, roadways and airports by cameras without any permission.”After the tweet by Mr. Kamluk in February, the Airline Passenger Experience Association said its members were committed to obtaining “advance explicit customer permission” before using the cameras. In a statement, the association added that airline passengers were “typically tracked outside the aircraft dozens of times on a typical journey through stores, security, roadways and airports by cameras without any permission.”
The two senators, in a statement, said that Americans “have an expectation that they are monitored in airports as a necessary security measure.” But they added, “The notion that in-flight cameras may monitor passengers while they sleep, eat or have private conversations is troubling.”The two senators, in a statement, said that Americans “have an expectation that they are monitored in airports as a necessary security measure.” But they added, “The notion that in-flight cameras may monitor passengers while they sleep, eat or have private conversations is troubling.”
Mr. Kamluk said he saw cybersecurity risks in the seat back cameras and the microphones attached to them.Mr. Kamluk said he saw cybersecurity risks in the seat back cameras and the microphones attached to them.
“It’s all connected to a computer system, and that is connected to the network, which is connected to the internet, so I see a way it can be accessed remotely,” he said.“It’s all connected to a computer system, and that is connected to the network, which is connected to the internet, so I see a way it can be accessed remotely,” he said.
Mr. Merkley said he was concerned that airlines might misuse the cameras. Even before receiving airlines’ replies to his letter, he said he was unlikely to be convinced by the responses.Mr. Merkley said he was concerned that airlines might misuse the cameras. Even before receiving airlines’ replies to his letter, he said he was unlikely to be convinced by the responses.
“I have paid a fair amount of attention to privacy issues,” he said. “They’re not going to convince me to trust them when there’s a camera and mic in front of me. I don’t want them there. It is a huge violation of trust.”“I have paid a fair amount of attention to privacy issues,” he said. “They’re not going to convince me to trust them when there’s a camera and mic in front of me. I don’t want them there. It is a huge violation of trust.”
As far as turning cameras into revenue-producing tools, the airline industry’s holy grail, several people who work on the revenue-generating side of the business say that’s not in the near future.As far as turning cameras into revenue-producing tools, the airline industry’s holy grail, several people who work on the revenue-generating side of the business say that’s not in the near future.
“I’m not aware of any practical use for these cameras,” said Jay Sorensen, a consultant specializing in airline revenue. “There’s no role they can play.”“I’m not aware of any practical use for these cameras,” said Jay Sorensen, a consultant specializing in airline revenue. “There’s no role they can play.”
He added, “In my role trying to generate revenue for an airline, the best way to sell more stuff on board is to have humans trained and motivated to sell things to passengers.”He added, “In my role trying to generate revenue for an airline, the best way to sell more stuff on board is to have humans trained and motivated to sell things to passengers.”
Mr. Kamluk suggested the new technology might be improved with an old-fashioned mechanical solution.Mr. Kamluk suggested the new technology might be improved with an old-fashioned mechanical solution.
“A better option for those who are concerned is to introduce a way to disconnect the microphone and camera with a click of the button so that passengers could disable the hardware,” he said. “Disconnect the wires by pushing a button.”“A better option for those who are concerned is to introduce a way to disconnect the microphone and camera with a click of the button so that passengers could disable the hardware,” he said. “Disconnect the wires by pushing a button.”
A spokeswoman for United Airlines, Maddie King, said in an email that her airline was working on something similar — covering all of the cameras on its in-flight entertainment systems.A spokeswoman for United Airlines, Maddie King, said in an email that her airline was working on something similar — covering all of the cameras on its in-flight entertainment systems.
But Dr. Leader said the airline industry group’s members were confident passengers would want the cameras in the future.But Dr. Leader said the airline industry group’s members were confident passengers would want the cameras in the future.
“Threatening legislation to penalize airlines for providing next-generation in-flight entertainment, with cameras that are not in use, and installed only for future possibilities with explicit passenger approvals, would be a disservice to airline passengers,” Dr. Leader said. He predicted that the senators would eventually agree.“Threatening legislation to penalize airlines for providing next-generation in-flight entertainment, with cameras that are not in use, and installed only for future possibilities with explicit passenger approvals, would be a disservice to airline passengers,” Dr. Leader said. He predicted that the senators would eventually agree.