This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/25/us/politics/benjamin-netanyahu-donald-trump-meeting.html

The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
Trump, With Netanyahu, Formally Recognizes Israel’s Authority Over Golan Heights Trump, With Netanyahu, Formally Recognizes Israel’s Authority Over Golan Heights
(about 5 hours later)
WASHINGTON — President Trump signed a proclamation on Monday formally recognizing Israel’s authority over the long-disputed Golan Heights, handing the pen to his grateful guest, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Israel. WASHINGTON — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu compared President Trump to Cyrus the Great, Lord Balfour and Harry S. Truman — historic giants who helped secure the future of the Israeli people. Mr. Trump called Mr. Netanyahu a “very special man.”
Mr. Trump’s decision, first announced last week, reverses decades of American policy and is starkly at odds with international law. But it is a valuable political gift to Mr. Netanyahu a few weeks before he faces voters in Israel in a closely fought election. If the expressions of praise seemed unequal, they accurately conveyed the political dynamic between Mr. Trump and Mr. Netanyahu during the Israeli leader’s visit to the White House on Monday.
“Today I am taking historic action to promote Israel’s ability to defend itself,” Mr. Trump said, “and really to have a very powerful, very strong national security, which they’re entitled to have.” Mr. Netanyahu was thanking Mr. Trump for signing a proclamation recognizing Israel’s authority over the long-disputed Golan Heights — a valuable political gift to the prime minister two weeks before he faces voters in a hard-fought election back home.
Israel’s permanent sovereignty over the Golan Heights was vital, he said, because otherwise, Iran and Iranian-backed militants operating in southern Syria would use the territory as a launching pad for attacks on Israeli towns. [Read why the Golan Heights is no longer an Arab rallying cry.]
In a joint appearance with Mr. Netanyahu at the White House, Mr. Trump cited a rocket attack from Gaza, which struck a house in central Israel early Monday morning, injuring seven people, as an example of “the significant security challenges that Israel faces every single day.” Mr. Trump, fresh off news that an investigation of his possible ties to Russia did not find evidence of a conspiracy, was happy to show support to an ally who still faces indictment in Israel on charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust.
Mr. Netanyahu announced earlier that he was cutting short his trip to Washington to return home Monday afternoon to marshal Israel’s military response to the attack. He had been scheduled to have dinner with the president on Tuesday and to address a conference organized by a pro-Israeli lobbying group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or Aipac. “Mr. President,” the prime minister said, “over the years, Israel has been blessed to have many friends who sat in the Oval Office, but Israel has never had a better friend than you.”
“Israel is responding forcefully to this wanton aggression,” the prime minister said. “I have a simple message to Israel’s enemies: We will do whatever we must do to defend our people and defend our state.” Certainly, Mr. Netanyahu has never had a friendlier president during his 13 years in office. In addition to his decision on the Golan Heights, Mr. Trump pulled the United States out of the Iran nuclear deal, which Mr. Netanyahu had long reviled, and moved the American Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, which the prime minister had long advocated.
Mr. Netanyahu spoke of the linchpin role the Golan Heights had played in Israel’s defense. He recalled that his brother was among the soldiers who scaled the rocky heights during the Arab-Israeli war of 1967. Later on, Mr. Netanyahu himself, as a young officer, led a covert unit from Syria into the Golan Heights in the midst of a snowstorm. “Today I am taking historic action to promote Israel’s ability to defend itself,” Mr. Trump said as he signed the proclamation and handed the pen to Mr. Netanyahu.
Mr. Trump’s decision, first announced last week, reverses decades of American policy and is at odds with United Nations resolutions rejecting the seizure of land by force. But the president said it was necessary because otherwise, Iran and its proxies in southern Syria would use the Golan Heights as a launching ground for attacks on Israel.
Mr. Trump cited a rocket attack from Gaza, which struck a house near Tel Aviv early Monday morning, injuring seven, as an example of “the significant security challenges that Israel faces every single day.”
The attack prompted Mr. Netanyahu to announce he was cutting short his trip to return home after his meeting to oversee Israel’s military response. He had been scheduled to have dinner with Mr. Trump on Tuesday and to address a pro-Israeli lobbying group, the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or Aipac. Mr. Netanyahu stayed in Washington until Monday evening, as Israeli forces began striking Hamas targets in Gaza.
“Israel is responding forcefully to this wanton aggression,” he said. “We will do whatever we must do to defend our people and defend our state.”
Mr. Netanyahu spoke of the vital role that the Golan Heights had played in Israel’s defense. He recalled that his brother was among the soldiers who scaled its rocky slopes during the Arab-Israeli war of 1967. Later on, Mr. Netanyahu himself, as a young officer, led a covert unit from Syria into the Golan Heights in the midst of a snowstorm.
“We hold the high ground, and we shall never give it up,” he said.“We hold the high ground, and we shall never give it up,” he said.
Though Israel effectively annexed the Golan Heights in 1981, Mr. Netanyahu said it had to wait half a century for Mr. Trump “to translate our military victory into a diplomatic victory.”Though Israel effectively annexed the Golan Heights in 1981, Mr. Netanyahu said it had to wait half a century for Mr. Trump “to translate our military victory into a diplomatic victory.”
The meeting between the two leaders was meant to showcase their enduring alliance — Mr. Netanyahu hailed Mr. Trump as the greatest friend Israel has ever had in the Oval Office — but it was disrupted, not only by the violence in Israel but also by their own changing political and legal fortunes. Mr. Trump’s decision continued to ripple throughout the region. Al-Marsad, which defends the rights of native Syrians in the Golan Heights, said the decision to recognize Israeli sovereignty could provoke violence in a territory that has been remarkably tranquil.
Mr. Trump was fresh off news that a lengthy investigation of his presidential campaign’s possible ties to Russia’s 2016 election interference did not find evidence of a conspiracy, while Mr. Netanyahu still faces indictment in Israel on charges of bribery, fraud and breach of trust. “The decision sets a dangerous standard that glorifies systematic human rights abuses, legitimizes illegal aggression and occupation, and endangers peace in the Middle East,” the group said in a statement.
The curtailed visit came at a critical moment in Israeli politics, when the prime minister’s legal woes are proliferating and he faces a fierce election challenge from Benny Gantz, a retired military chief. Mr. Netanyahu’s truncated visit came at a critical moment in Israeli politics, when his legal woes are multiplying and he faces a fierce challenge from Benny Gantz, a retired military chief. Analysts said the show of support could tilt the balance in his favor.
The prime minister was hit by two new accusations shortly before his departure for Washington: that he improperly authorized the sale of German-made submarines to Egypt without the approval of top military officials, and that he engaged in self-dealing, through an undisclosed stake in a company that supplied the German builder of both the Egyptian subs and several new Israeli warships. “Trump’s embrace and Hamas rockets may well make the difference in helping Netanyahu form the next Israeli government,” said Aaron David Miller, a former peace negotiator now at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.
Mr. Trump, on the other hand, was still exulting in the letter to congressional leaders on Sunday from Attorney General William P. Barr, in which he reported that the special counsel, Robert S. Mueller III, had not found collusion between Mr. Trump’s presidential campaign and Russia. The prime minister was hit by two new accusations shortly before he left for Washington: that he improperly authorized the sale of German-made submarines to Egypt, and that he engaged in self-dealing, through an undisclosed stake in a company that supplied the German builder of both the Egyptian subs and several new Israeli warships.
The president did not mention the Russia investigation during the signing ceremony, though in a later photo session with Mr. Netanyahu in the Oval Office, he accused his opponents of being “treasonous” in pushing the narrative of collusion with Russia. Mr. Trump, on the other hand, was still exulting in the letter to Congress sent by Attorney General William P. Barr, in which Mr. Barr reported that the special counsel, Robert S. Mueller III, had not found collusion between Mr. Trump’s presidential campaign and Russia.
At the signing ceremony, Mr. Trump listed all the steps he had taken to benefit Israel, including pulling out of the Iran nuclear deal and moving the American Embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. After thanking the American ambassador to Israel, David M. Friedman, Mr. Trump asked him whether he was enjoying the relocated embassy. The president did not mention the Russia investigation during the signing ceremony, though in a later session with Mr. Netanyahu in the Oval Office, he told reporters that his opponents were “treasonous.”
Mr. Netanyahu made light of the legal issues facing both of them. He told Mr. Trump that he had brought him a case of wine from the Golan Heights. Noting that the president was not a wine drinker, he asked if he could give the bottles to the White House staff.
After Mr. Trump agreed, Mr. Netanyahu joked, “I hope they don’t open an investigation on it.”
For his part, Mr. Trump listed all the steps he had taken to benefit Israel, including moving the embassy. After thanking the American ambassador to Israel, David M. Friedman, Mr. Trump asked him whether he was enjoying the relocated embassy.
“Yes,” said Mr. Friedman, who was standing behind the leaders.“Yes,” said Mr. Friedman, who was standing behind the leaders.
“And you love Israel?” Mr. Trump asked.“And you love Israel?” Mr. Trump asked.
“And America,” Mr. Friedman added. Nodding, Mr. Friedman added, “And America.”
“And America,” Mr. Trump repeated with a grin. “I was waiting for him to say that.”“And America,” Mr. Trump repeated with a grin. “I was waiting for him to say that.”
Even in its abbreviated form, Mr. Netanyahu’s meeting with Mr. Trump overshadowed a major speech to Aipac by Mr. Gantz at the same time as the Oval Office session.Even in its abbreviated form, Mr. Netanyahu’s meeting with Mr. Trump overshadowed a major speech to Aipac by Mr. Gantz at the same time as the Oval Office session.
Mr. Gantz told his audience that the prime minister had “done well” by deciding to return home, and said he intended to return as well, “and if needed to fight in defense of our people.”Mr. Gantz told his audience that the prime minister had “done well” by deciding to return home, and said he intended to return as well, “and if needed to fight in defense of our people.”
But in what amounted to a campaign speech before thousands of pro-Israel lobbyists, Mr. Gantz, a former chief of the Israeli Army’s general staff, also took shots at Mr. Netanyahu, while portraying himself as a soldier who would be tough on defense while running a cleaner and more inclusive government. But in what amounted to a campaign speech, Mr. Gantz, a former chief of the Israeli Army’s general staff, also took shots at Mr. Netanyahu, while portraying himself as a soldier who would be tough on defense while running a cleaner and more inclusive government.
“There will be no Kahanists running our country. There will be no racists leading our state institutions and there will be no corruption,” Mr. Gantz declared in a not-so-subtle reference to Mr. Netanyahu’s embrace of a far-right party, Otzma Yehudit, and to his indictment on corruption charges. “There will be no racists leading our state institutions and there will be no corruption,” Mr. Gantz declared in a not-so-subtle reference to Mr. Netanyahu’s embrace of a far-right party, Otzma Yehudit, and to his indictment on corruption charges.
In a line that brought the crowd to its feet, he declared: “As a proud owner of the red beret, worn by the liberator of the Kotel, I can tell you with confidence that the Western Wall is long enough to accommodate everyone. Everyone!”
At a time when Israel policy in the United States has become divisive, with many progressives and young Jews taking a highly critical view of the Netanyahu government, Mr. Gantz also sought to cast himself as a leader who would build bridges between Jews in the two countries.At a time when Israel policy in the United States has become divisive, with many progressives and young Jews taking a highly critical view of the Netanyahu government, Mr. Gantz also sought to cast himself as a leader who would build bridges between Jews in the two countries.
“As an abba, as a father, I’m doing it for my kids,” he said, wrapping up his scripted speech with an ad-libbed last line. “But I’m doing it for your kids as well.” “As an abba, as a father, I’m doing it for my kids,” he said. “But I’m doing it for your kids as well.”