This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/london/7729267.stm
The article has changed 15 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 8 | Version 9 |
---|---|
PM rejects Baby P 'buck-passing' | PM rejects Baby P 'buck-passing' |
(about 1 hour later) | |
The prime minister has rejected claims of "buck-passing" in the Baby P case. | |
The Tories have accused ministers of not doing enough despite being told of alleged failings in Haringey Council. | |
They were reacting to news a whistle-blower raised concerns about child protection six months before Baby P's death in August 2007. | |
An investigation was launched by the Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI) and Gordon Brown's spokesman said correct procedures were followed. | |
Baby P died aged 17 months following abuse. His mother and two men were convicted of causing his death. | |
The CSCI said it was satisfied Haringey had dealt properly with the case after it raised the concerns at a meeting. | |
Gordon Brown's spokesman said: "It is right that complaints should be directed to the Commission for Social Care Inspection to take appropriate action." | |
The public are tired of hearing that 'correct procedures have been followed' when a child died in agony Michael GoveTory spokesman | The public are tired of hearing that 'correct procedures have been followed' when a child died in agony Michael GoveTory spokesman |
The spokesman could not say when the prime minister had become aware of the whistle-blower's claims, but added: "He's remained in very close touch with the secretary of state and has clearly taken a close interest..." | |
Speaking in New York ahead of a global summit on the financial crisis, Mr Brown said he would do "everything in my power" to prevent a repeat of the case. | |
"I am determined that everything we do, the inquiries we are having in this case, reveal everything that went on," he said. | |
Earlier, it emerged that a lawyer acting for former Haringey social worker Nevres Kemal sent a letter about her concerns about the council to the Department of Health in February 2007. | |
She was worried that children in the borough continued to be "at risk". | She was worried that children in the borough continued to be "at risk". |
This was despite an inquiry into the killing of eight-year-old Victoria Climbie - she died from abuse and neglect in the same borough eight years ago. | This was despite an inquiry into the killing of eight-year-old Victoria Climbie - she died from abuse and neglect in the same borough eight years ago. |
Ms Kemal believed recommendations made by Lord Laming following that inquiry were still not being followed. | Ms Kemal believed recommendations made by Lord Laming following that inquiry were still not being followed. |
Her letter was passed to the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF), which said proper procedures were followed. | Her letter was passed to the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF), which said proper procedures were followed. |
Lawyer Lawrence Davies: 'We had been pushed from pillar to post' | Lawyer Lawrence Davies: 'We had been pushed from pillar to post' |
Haringey Council has issued an injunction against Ms Kemal so that she cannot talk directly about the case or anything to do with "child protection matters". | Haringey Council has issued an injunction against Ms Kemal so that she cannot talk directly about the case or anything to do with "child protection matters". |
She is now pursuing a claim of constructive dismissal from the council. | She is now pursuing a claim of constructive dismissal from the council. |
The DCSF confirmed it received a letter dated 16 February 2007 containing allegations "that child protection procedures were not being followed in Haringey". | The DCSF confirmed it received a letter dated 16 February 2007 containing allegations "that child protection procedures were not being followed in Haringey". |
A spokesman claimed "standard procedures" were followed and after the letter went between various departments, Ms Kemal was told to notify the CSCI as it would take "appropriate action". | |
It is not thought that ministers saw the letter, and BBC home affairs editor Mark Easton said it appeared to have failed to reach the people who could have acted upon it. | |
He said: "When the letter was sent back in February 2007 the then body that was looking after inspecting children's services in England was the Commission for Social Care Inspection. | He said: "When the letter was sent back in February 2007 the then body that was looking after inspecting children's services in England was the Commission for Social Care Inspection. |
"Ofsted, perhaps surprising to some people, actually took over the inspection of children's services in April 2007 and what they say is that only ongoing complaints that were still live - as it were - were passed to them. | "Ofsted, perhaps surprising to some people, actually took over the inspection of children's services in April 2007 and what they say is that only ongoing complaints that were still live - as it were - were passed to them. |
"They only received paper details from the commission and I think there is a suggestion that in a way this complaint fell through the gap - that somehow concerns about what was going on in Haringey were not passed on to the body which was responsible for inspecting them." | "They only received paper details from the commission and I think there is a suggestion that in a way this complaint fell through the gap - that somehow concerns about what was going on in Haringey were not passed on to the body which was responsible for inspecting them." |
HAVE YOUR SAY Nothing will be learned from this. Most of what will be done will be damage limitation Jay Steele, DerbySend us your comments | HAVE YOUR SAY Nothing will be learned from this. Most of what will be done will be damage limitation Jay Steele, DerbySend us your comments |
Ms Kemal's lawyer, Lawrence Davies said: "If the social care inspectorate had acted on it or the ministers had acted on it [the letter], it seems hard to believe that the situation in which Baby P was seen 60 times in total... presumably several times after February, couldn't have been averted." | Ms Kemal's lawyer, Lawrence Davies said: "If the social care inspectorate had acted on it or the ministers had acted on it [the letter], it seems hard to believe that the situation in which Baby P was seen 60 times in total... presumably several times after February, couldn't have been averted." |
The CSCI said it did investigate the claims and "was satisfied that the council had dealt properly with the individual case raised by Ms Kemal". | The CSCI said it did investigate the claims and "was satisfied that the council had dealt properly with the individual case raised by Ms Kemal". |
The body also said it - in conjunction with Ofsted - had identified broader areas where improvement was needed and ordered the council to make changes. | |
Its statement added: "The transfer [of responsibility to Ofsted] included the handover of all previous case files, inspection reports, databases and all of our staff working on children's services." | Its statement added: "The transfer [of responsibility to Ofsted] included the handover of all previous case files, inspection reports, databases and all of our staff working on children's services." |
Public inquiry call | |
The shadow children's secretary, Michael Gove, said no government department appeared to have been willing to act on the warning. | The shadow children's secretary, Michael Gove, said no government department appeared to have been willing to act on the warning. |
He said: "The public are tired of hearing that 'correct procedures have been followed' when a child died in agony. | He said: "The public are tired of hearing that 'correct procedures have been followed' when a child died in agony. |
"Ministers were told six months before Baby P's death that there were profound problems in Haringey's children's services department. | "Ministers were told six months before Baby P's death that there were profound problems in Haringey's children's services department. |
"Yet all that appears to have happened is the... gagging of the whistleblower and bureaucratic buck-passing in Whitehall." | "Yet all that appears to have happened is the... gagging of the whistleblower and bureaucratic buck-passing in Whitehall." |
Local Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone wants a public inquiry and she told the BBC that someone at the council should take responsibility. | Local Lib Dem MP Lynne Featherstone wants a public inquiry and she told the BBC that someone at the council should take responsibility. |
No-one at Haringey Council has lost their job over the case. | No-one at Haringey Council has lost their job over the case. |
The council welcomed a government review, saying it would be "open and co-operative" with inspectors and would implement the findings "swiftly and comprehensively". | The council welcomed a government review, saying it would be "open and co-operative" with inspectors and would implement the findings "swiftly and comprehensively". |