This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/26/nyregion/nyc-housing-violations-landlords-tenants.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Leaks, Mold and Rats: Why New York City Goes Easy on Its Worst Landlords | Leaks, Mold and Rats: Why New York City Goes Easy on Its Worst Landlords |
| (1 day later) | |
| [What you need to know to start your day: Get New York Today in your inbox.] | [What you need to know to start your day: Get New York Today in your inbox.] |
| Jose Polanco lives in one of the worst buildings in New York City. In his 18 years there, the apartment has had leaks, mold, roaches and rodents — sometimes all at once. Last winter, Mr. Polanco was stepping out of the shower when the bathroom ceiling collapsed. | Jose Polanco lives in one of the worst buildings in New York City. In his 18 years there, the apartment has had leaks, mold, roaches and rodents — sometimes all at once. Last winter, Mr. Polanco was stepping out of the shower when the bathroom ceiling collapsed. |
| His neighbor had it even worse; his pet parrots were eaten by rats. | His neighbor had it even worse; his pet parrots were eaten by rats. |
| The city is aware of the issues in the West Harlem building. Over the course of a decade, it has sued the landlord over hazardous conditions 21 times and could have imposed as much as $900,000 in fines. But each time, officials accepted a low settlement and the landlord’s promise to make repairs. | The city is aware of the issues in the West Harlem building. Over the course of a decade, it has sued the landlord over hazardous conditions 21 times and could have imposed as much as $900,000 in fines. But each time, officials accepted a low settlement and the landlord’s promise to make repairs. |
| Often, the repairs were quick-fix solutions — like a fresh coat of paint on a moldy bathroom ceiling — that did not solve the underlying problem. | Often, the repairs were quick-fix solutions — like a fresh coat of paint on a moldy bathroom ceiling — that did not solve the underlying problem. |
| “They would come and patch it up every year,” said Mr. Polanco, 68, a retired maintenance worker who pays $1,500 a month in rent. “It was the same leak every time.” | “They would come and patch it up every year,” said Mr. Polanco, 68, a retired maintenance worker who pays $1,500 a month in rent. “It was the same leak every time.” |
| The Department of Housing Preservation and Development is supposed to ensure that the city’s 2.2 million rental apartments are habitable. But the agency takes a gentle hand with landlords who deprive tenants of basic services, declining to enforce the maximum penalties for even the worst offenders, a review of city records shows. | The Department of Housing Preservation and Development is supposed to ensure that the city’s 2.2 million rental apartments are habitable. But the agency takes a gentle hand with landlords who deprive tenants of basic services, declining to enforce the maximum penalties for even the worst offenders, a review of city records shows. |
| To examine how the city handled these cases, The Times analyzed city housing data, interviewed tenants and advocates and reviewed hundreds of housing court cases, taking as a sample the 126 cases filed for serious building-wide issues in Manhattan last year. | To examine how the city handled these cases, The Times analyzed city housing data, interviewed tenants and advocates and reviewed hundreds of housing court cases, taking as a sample the 126 cases filed for serious building-wide issues in Manhattan last year. |
| In more than two-thirds of the cases, the city settled for less than 15 percent of penalties available under the law. Most were closer to 10 percent. The median settlement was $4,000. | In more than two-thirds of the cases, the city settled for less than 15 percent of penalties available under the law. Most were closer to 10 percent. The median settlement was $4,000. |
| Landlords who lie about making repairs also face minimal repercussions. One landlord who filed 40 certifications with the city over two years that falsely claimed violations had been fixed paid less than $3,000 in fines, The Times found. | Landlords who lie about making repairs also face minimal repercussions. One landlord who filed 40 certifications with the city over two years that falsely claimed violations had been fixed paid less than $3,000 in fines, The Times found. |
| The problem is particularly acute for people living in the roughly one million rent-regulated apartments that make up the largest source of affordable housing in the city. | The problem is particularly acute for people living in the roughly one million rent-regulated apartments that make up the largest source of affordable housing in the city. |
| Over time, neglected repairs can amount to a form of harassment that forces tenants to leave their homes, advocates for affordable housing said. Once they do, landlords can renovate, raise the rent and, ultimately, move the apartment into the free market, exacerbating the city’s housing crisis. | Over time, neglected repairs can amount to a form of harassment that forces tenants to leave their homes, advocates for affordable housing said. Once they do, landlords can renovate, raise the rent and, ultimately, move the apartment into the free market, exacerbating the city’s housing crisis. |
| A similar pattern has been playing out in other cities with rent regulations, like San Francisco and Los Angeles. “This is a huge issue nationwide. We’re relying on residents and tenants themselves to enforce housing conditions,” said Deborah Thrope, supervising attorney with the National Housing Law Project. “The structure is flawed.” | |
| At Mr. Polanco’s building at 520 West 136th Street, a quarter of the apartments — nine rent-stabilized units — have been moved into the free market since the current landlord took ownership 15 years ago. Meanwhile, the building around them has deteriorated. | At Mr. Polanco’s building at 520 West 136th Street, a quarter of the apartments — nine rent-stabilized units — have been moved into the free market since the current landlord took ownership 15 years ago. Meanwhile, the building around them has deteriorated. |
| The city is aware of these problems: Mayor Bill de Blasio has staked his legacy on increasing the city’s affordable housing stock. A city-state task force has tried to fight tenant harassment for years; the City Council passed a package of bills aimed at curbing landlord abuses last year. In June, one month after articles in The New York Times highlighted tenant harassment and the loss of rent-regulated apartments, the city established a tenant anti-harassment unit. | The city is aware of these problems: Mayor Bill de Blasio has staked his legacy on increasing the city’s affordable housing stock. A city-state task force has tried to fight tenant harassment for years; the City Council passed a package of bills aimed at curbing landlord abuses last year. In June, one month after articles in The New York Times highlighted tenant harassment and the loss of rent-regulated apartments, the city established a tenant anti-harassment unit. |
| Even so, the city’s housing department says its goal is to correct violations, not to punish landlords. | Even so, the city’s housing department says its goal is to correct violations, not to punish landlords. |
| Pushing for higher penalties could prolong cases, the agency says, leaving tenants to wait longer for repairs. There is also a concern that issuing hefty fines could make it more difficult for landlords to make necessary fixes. | Pushing for higher penalties could prolong cases, the agency says, leaving tenants to wait longer for repairs. There is also a concern that issuing hefty fines could make it more difficult for landlords to make necessary fixes. |
| “Our primary mission has been and will continue to be ensuring New Yorkers live in safe and secure homes, which is why we concentrate our efforts on correcting conditions for tenants,” said Matthew Creegan, a spokesman for the housing department, known as H.P.D., adding that the agency continues to “develop new tools to aggressively combat tenant harassment.” | “Our primary mission has been and will continue to be ensuring New Yorkers live in safe and secure homes, which is why we concentrate our efforts on correcting conditions for tenants,” said Matthew Creegan, a spokesman for the housing department, known as H.P.D., adding that the agency continues to “develop new tools to aggressively combat tenant harassment.” |
| When a tenant calls the city, the system creaks to life: Inspectors evaluate the building for hazards and issue violations if they find them. If landlords fail to respond, the city can send out emergency repair crews, but generally does so only for problems deemed imminently hazardous. If the landlord refuses to let crews in to address the conditions, which may range from toxic lead to defective window guards, the city can sue in housing court. | When a tenant calls the city, the system creaks to life: Inspectors evaluate the building for hazards and issue violations if they find them. If landlords fail to respond, the city can send out emergency repair crews, but generally does so only for problems deemed imminently hazardous. If the landlord refuses to let crews in to address the conditions, which may range from toxic lead to defective window guards, the city can sue in housing court. |
| This work is billed to the owner, but city housing officials acknowledge these cases rarely result in fines. Even landlords who lie escape tough punishment. | This work is billed to the owner, but city housing officials acknowledge these cases rarely result in fines. Even landlords who lie escape tough punishment. |
| Take the case of Jason Green, a lawyer who first made a name for himself in housing court by representing mega-landlords repeatedly accused of harassing tenants with spurious lawsuits and poor services. Now a landlord in his own right, Mr. Green has been sued by the city 34 times in the last decade — cited for withholding heat and hot water, denying city emergency crews access and falsely certifying that violations had been corrected. | Take the case of Jason Green, a lawyer who first made a name for himself in housing court by representing mega-landlords repeatedly accused of harassing tenants with spurious lawsuits and poor services. Now a landlord in his own right, Mr. Green has been sued by the city 34 times in the last decade — cited for withholding heat and hot water, denying city emergency crews access and falsely certifying that violations had been corrected. |
| In 2016 and 2017, the city sued Mr. Green seven times, saying he had filed 40 different certifications falsely claiming that violations had been fixed in regulated buildings. The total fines came to just $2,750 — a small amount for the owner of property worth millions. | In 2016 and 2017, the city sued Mr. Green seven times, saying he had filed 40 different certifications falsely claiming that violations had been fixed in regulated buildings. The total fines came to just $2,750 — a small amount for the owner of property worth millions. |
| Seven of those violations were in Diana Tise’s apartment on West 138th Street. For months, Ms. Tise, 24, had been struggling to fix up the apartment she shared with her blind grandmother, who has lived in the building more than 40 years. Pregnant with her first child, Ms. Tise worried about the loose and uneven floorboards, crumbling plaster walls and collapsing ceilings. She called the city over and over. | Seven of those violations were in Diana Tise’s apartment on West 138th Street. For months, Ms. Tise, 24, had been struggling to fix up the apartment she shared with her blind grandmother, who has lived in the building more than 40 years. Pregnant with her first child, Ms. Tise worried about the loose and uneven floorboards, crumbling plaster walls and collapsing ceilings. She called the city over and over. |
| “I did not want to bring a new baby into this,” she said. | “I did not want to bring a new baby into this,” she said. |
| But city inspectors did not come for weeks, and the repairs lagged for months, she said. What Ms. Tise did not know was that Mr. Green had told the city that the repairs were complete, even though he had not even started them. The city found out and sued Mr. Green, but then settled at the first court date for $600. | But city inspectors did not come for weeks, and the repairs lagged for months, she said. What Ms. Tise did not know was that Mr. Green had told the city that the repairs were complete, even though he had not even started them. The city found out and sued Mr. Green, but then settled at the first court date for $600. |
| Work started only after Ms. Tise gave birth. The floors and subfloors were replaced in the hallway. Inspectors found lead paint on several walls, and Mr. Green chose to cover those walls with drywall, an inexpensive strategy for mitigating the problem. Everything else got another coat of Spackle. That work is already falling apart, Ms. Tise said. | Work started only after Ms. Tise gave birth. The floors and subfloors were replaced in the hallway. Inspectors found lead paint on several walls, and Mr. Green chose to cover those walls with drywall, an inexpensive strategy for mitigating the problem. Everything else got another coat of Spackle. That work is already falling apart, Ms. Tise said. |
| “You can see the walls, literally cracks everywhere, like an old manicure,” Ms. Tise said. “They did a patch job.” | “You can see the walls, literally cracks everywhere, like an old manicure,” Ms. Tise said. “They did a patch job.” |
| Mr. Green denied requests for interviews. In an email, he said that The Times’s information was “inaccurate” but would not elaborate. | Mr. Green denied requests for interviews. In an email, he said that The Times’s information was “inaccurate” but would not elaborate. |
| In extreme cases, the city can file a lawsuit against the landlord for a raft of violations found at a single building. The Times reviewed all 126 of these “comprehensive” cases filed in Manhattan last year. Most were settled for relatively little. In one, the city accepted $1,500 for $28,800 worth of fines. In another, the city accepted $4,000 out of a possible $100,000. | In extreme cases, the city can file a lawsuit against the landlord for a raft of violations found at a single building. The Times reviewed all 126 of these “comprehensive” cases filed in Manhattan last year. Most were settled for relatively little. In one, the city accepted $1,500 for $28,800 worth of fines. In another, the city accepted $4,000 out of a possible $100,000. |
| In all, the city left $4.7 million in civil penalties on the table in those cases — nearly five times the amount it actually levied. | In all, the city left $4.7 million in civil penalties on the table in those cases — nearly five times the amount it actually levied. |
| And just because a fine is levied does not mean it will be paid: In 2016, the city admitted that its collection rate for unpaid judgments was just 13 percent over a year-and-a-half period. A comptroller’s report from the same year said that by allowing so many judgments to go uncollected for so long, “H.P.D. might actually be creating the unintended impression that building owners face little immediate risk of penalty for such violations.” | And just because a fine is levied does not mean it will be paid: In 2016, the city admitted that its collection rate for unpaid judgments was just 13 percent over a year-and-a-half period. A comptroller’s report from the same year said that by allowing so many judgments to go uncollected for so long, “H.P.D. might actually be creating the unintended impression that building owners face little immediate risk of penalty for such violations.” |
| Of the $10.1 million in judgments owed last year, the city says it has collected just $766,000, a little less than 8 percent. | Of the $10.1 million in judgments owed last year, the city says it has collected just $766,000, a little less than 8 percent. |
| Hamid Khan, a landlord and property manager, is no stranger to these comprehensive cases, having been charged in nine of them in the last 10 years. Mr. Khan, 73, is No. 27 on a list of worst landlords compiled by the New York City public advocate. In 2008, he served nine days in jail for code violations at one of his Bronx buildings. Since then, he has been sued almost 50 times over conditions at buildings he manages, all of which contain rent-regulated apartments. | Hamid Khan, a landlord and property manager, is no stranger to these comprehensive cases, having been charged in nine of them in the last 10 years. Mr. Khan, 73, is No. 27 on a list of worst landlords compiled by the New York City public advocate. In 2008, he served nine days in jail for code violations at one of his Bronx buildings. Since then, he has been sued almost 50 times over conditions at buildings he manages, all of which contain rent-regulated apartments. |
| One such building is 235 West 103rd Street, which has been the target of two comprehensive lawsuits since May 2017. Both were settled, and out of the possible $120,000 in penalties, the owners paid just $11,000. | One such building is 235 West 103rd Street, which has been the target of two comprehensive lawsuits since May 2017. Both were settled, and out of the possible $120,000 in penalties, the owners paid just $11,000. |
| “You’re basically patting them on the head and saying don’t do that again,” said Anthony Thornton, 59, the leader of the tenants’ association. | “You’re basically patting them on the head and saying don’t do that again,” said Anthony Thornton, 59, the leader of the tenants’ association. |
| This peculiar system of incentives means that landlords often let regulated apartments with longtime tenants fall apart while they renovate market-rate units right next door. A renovated apartment with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops in Mr. Khan’s building on West 103rd Street was recently advertised for $2,800 a month. Neighboring regulated apartments, meanwhile, lacked cooking gas for more than two years. | This peculiar system of incentives means that landlords often let regulated apartments with longtime tenants fall apart while they renovate market-rate units right next door. A renovated apartment with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops in Mr. Khan’s building on West 103rd Street was recently advertised for $2,800 a month. Neighboring regulated apartments, meanwhile, lacked cooking gas for more than two years. |
| In 2003, Mr. Khan and his partners purchased the building at 520 West 136th Street in Harlem where Mr. Polanco, the maintenance man, lives with his family. Five years later, the city filed a comprehensive suit against the building for issues including mice, roaches and lead. That case would be reopened three times before the building’s 303 violations were closed. | In 2003, Mr. Khan and his partners purchased the building at 520 West 136th Street in Harlem where Mr. Polanco, the maintenance man, lives with his family. Five years later, the city filed a comprehensive suit against the building for issues including mice, roaches and lead. That case would be reopened three times before the building’s 303 violations were closed. |
| Felix Salazar, who lived in another apartment in the building, sued Mr. Khan and his partners in 2013 after he tripped on an uneven floor. In a deposition, he described the deplorable conditions. “I had two parrots in the house and the rats ate them up,” Mr. Salazar said. “They ate their beaks and their eyes out.” | Felix Salazar, who lived in another apartment in the building, sued Mr. Khan and his partners in 2013 after he tripped on an uneven floor. In a deposition, he described the deplorable conditions. “I had two parrots in the house and the rats ate them up,” Mr. Salazar said. “They ate their beaks and their eyes out.” |
| In June 2014, the city again sued, to compel the building’s owners to correct its 236 open violations. The next month, the city settled for $2,500, out of a potential $31,000 in fines. When an inspector found that 75 violations had not been corrected, the city reopened the case. | In June 2014, the city again sued, to compel the building’s owners to correct its 236 open violations. The next month, the city settled for $2,500, out of a potential $31,000 in fines. When an inspector found that 75 violations had not been corrected, the city reopened the case. |
| This time it settled for $5,000 — out of a possible $200,000. | This time it settled for $5,000 — out of a possible $200,000. |
| By 2016, Mr. Polanco’s building had landed in the Alternative Enforcement Program, which is the city’s harshest punishment for neglectful landlords. Once in the program, landlords have four months to correct the most serious issues and face fines each year that they fail to do so. | By 2016, Mr. Polanco’s building had landed in the Alternative Enforcement Program, which is the city’s harshest punishment for neglectful landlords. Once in the program, landlords have four months to correct the most serious issues and face fines each year that they fail to do so. |
| Last year, two out of every five buildings in the program failed to make the necessary repairs, city records show. It was the program’s best year yet. | Last year, two out of every five buildings in the program failed to make the necessary repairs, city records show. It was the program’s best year yet. |
| In the end, Mr. Khan’s partners became alarmed by the mountain of fines and replaced him as a property manager at the two West Side buildings. | In the end, Mr. Khan’s partners became alarmed by the mountain of fines and replaced him as a property manager at the two West Side buildings. |
| A co-owner of several buildings Mr. Khan managed, Ruth Shomron, said that he had hidden the lawsuits and violations from his partners, adding that the program and its steep fines alerted them to the decay of the property. “He betrayed us as people, as a partner,” she said. | A co-owner of several buildings Mr. Khan managed, Ruth Shomron, said that he had hidden the lawsuits and violations from his partners, adding that the program and its steep fines alerted them to the decay of the property. “He betrayed us as people, as a partner,” she said. |
| When reached by phone, Mr. Khan said he managed the building as instructed but could not remember any details. | When reached by phone, Mr. Khan said he managed the building as instructed but could not remember any details. |
| After two and a half years in the program, Mr. Polanco’s building is finally being improved. The roof and elevator have been replaced. Many apartments have been upgraded. Mr. Polanco’s bathroom and kitchen were renovated, after a fashion. The faucet knobs in the kitchen were installed backward. The countertops were never secured to the cabinets below, leaving a half-inch gap that Mr. Polanco tried to fill with wood chips. | After two and a half years in the program, Mr. Polanco’s building is finally being improved. The roof and elevator have been replaced. Many apartments have been upgraded. Mr. Polanco’s bathroom and kitchen were renovated, after a fashion. The faucet knobs in the kitchen were installed backward. The countertops were never secured to the cabinets below, leaving a half-inch gap that Mr. Polanco tried to fill with wood chips. |
| Following The Times’s inquiries into 520 West 136th Street, the building was selected for a new pilot program to combat tenant harassment. | Following The Times’s inquiries into 520 West 136th Street, the building was selected for a new pilot program to combat tenant harassment. |
| But improvements came too late for Mr. Salazar, the man whose parrots were eaten. He moved out, and a new family lives there now, paying nearly $3,000 a month. | But improvements came too late for Mr. Salazar, the man whose parrots were eaten. He moved out, and a new family lives there now, paying nearly $3,000 a month. |
| They like the renovations — new floors, new kitchen, new bathroom. They have only one complaint. They are starting to think they might have rats. | They like the renovations — new floors, new kitchen, new bathroom. They have only one complaint. They are starting to think they might have rats. |