This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/09/04/world/europe/uk-labour-anti-semitism-corbyn.html
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Labour Party in U.K. Snatches Defeat From Victory’s Jaws | |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| LONDON — As Prime Minister Theresa May’s government tears itself apart over plans to quit the European Union, there could scarcely be a better time for the opposition Labour Party to exploit the disarray and press its case to govern Britain. | LONDON — As Prime Minister Theresa May’s government tears itself apart over plans to quit the European Union, there could scarcely be a better time for the opposition Labour Party to exploit the disarray and press its case to govern Britain. |
| Instead, Labour’s left-wing leader, Jeremy Corbyn, is embroiled in a crisis largely of his own making over anti-Semitism — one that has crystallized internal divisions and stirred speculation about a breakaway by centrist lawmakers. | Instead, Labour’s left-wing leader, Jeremy Corbyn, is embroiled in a crisis largely of his own making over anti-Semitism — one that has crystallized internal divisions and stirred speculation about a breakaway by centrist lawmakers. |
| And hanging over that squabble are two other divisive issues with the potential to split Mr. Corbyn’s Labour Party: its position on Brexit, Britain’s planned withdrawal from the European Union, and possible changes in party rules that centrists fear could be used to purge them. | And hanging over that squabble are two other divisive issues with the potential to split Mr. Corbyn’s Labour Party: its position on Brexit, Britain’s planned withdrawal from the European Union, and possible changes in party rules that centrists fear could be used to purge them. |
| The stakes are high because the Labour Party has split before, in 1981, when a group broke away to found a centrist organization, the Social Democratic Party. That experiment did not end well for Labour or for the rebels, one reason Mr. Corbyn’s critics are being cautious. | The stakes are high because the Labour Party has split before, in 1981, when a group broke away to found a centrist organization, the Social Democratic Party. That experiment did not end well for Labour or for the rebels, one reason Mr. Corbyn’s critics are being cautious. |
| On Tuesday, Labour’s National Executive Committee, its ruling body, was trying to calm the latest chapter in the seemingly endless disputes over anti-Semitism, this time centering on the party’s reluctance to fully adopt an internationally recognized definition of anti-Semitism. | On Tuesday, Labour’s National Executive Committee, its ruling body, was trying to calm the latest chapter in the seemingly endless disputes over anti-Semitism, this time centering on the party’s reluctance to fully adopt an internationally recognized definition of anti-Semitism. |
| At Tuesday’s meeting the committee tried to redress that by including the full text of the working definition of anti-Semitism compiled by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance. But it also attempted to make clear that this should not prevent criticism of Israeli government policies, particularly toward the Palestinians. | At Tuesday’s meeting the committee tried to redress that by including the full text of the working definition of anti-Semitism compiled by the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance. But it also attempted to make clear that this should not prevent criticism of Israeli government policies, particularly toward the Palestinians. |
| It remained unclear whether that would end months of bitter criticism of Labour from faith leaders and Jewish newspapers that has tarnished the party’s image. | It remained unclear whether that would end months of bitter criticism of Labour from faith leaders and Jewish newspapers that has tarnished the party’s image. |
| “Most voters don’t pay a lot of attention to the Westminster bubble,” said Tom Quinn, a senior lecturer in government at the University of Essex, referring to the seat of Parliament. “But when something rumbles on and on and on, that’s when it seeps into the public consciousness and helps to create an image in the voter’s mind about what a party represents, and there is a danger that this creates a perception of a party that doesn’t like certain groups.” | “Most voters don’t pay a lot of attention to the Westminster bubble,” said Tom Quinn, a senior lecturer in government at the University of Essex, referring to the seat of Parliament. “But when something rumbles on and on and on, that’s when it seeps into the public consciousness and helps to create an image in the voter’s mind about what a party represents, and there is a danger that this creates a perception of a party that doesn’t like certain groups.” |
| Mr. Corbyn is Labour’s most left-wing leader in decades, his politics forged in more than three decades of activism on the party’s fringes. After he won the leadership in 2015, internal critics tried and failed to unseat him. Then, last year, Mr. Corbyn performed better than expected in a general election, consolidating his internal position and sending his opponents into retreat. | Mr. Corbyn is Labour’s most left-wing leader in decades, his politics forged in more than three decades of activism on the party’s fringes. After he won the leadership in 2015, internal critics tried and failed to unseat him. Then, last year, Mr. Corbyn performed better than expected in a general election, consolidating his internal position and sending his opponents into retreat. |
| But Mr. Corbyn’s leadership presents problems for Labour. One legacy of his past is his ingrained skepticism about the European Union, which Britain’s far left once saw as a bankers’ club. During Britain’s 2016 referendum on membership, Mr. Corbyn did the bare minimum to help the campaign for a remain vote. Since then Labour has fudged its Brexit stance, managing more or less successfully to appease both pro- and anti-Europe factions within its ranks. | But Mr. Corbyn’s leadership presents problems for Labour. One legacy of his past is his ingrained skepticism about the European Union, which Britain’s far left once saw as a bankers’ club. During Britain’s 2016 referendum on membership, Mr. Corbyn did the bare minimum to help the campaign for a remain vote. Since then Labour has fudged its Brexit stance, managing more or less successfully to appease both pro- and anti-Europe factions within its ranks. |
| But it cannot postpone indefinitely the moment of decision. With the Conservative government’s Brexit plan under attack from some of Mrs. May’s own lawmakers, Labour’s pro-Europeans, including some influential trade unions, are pressing Mr. Corbyn to shift policy and either embrace closer ties to Europe or call for a referendum on the terms of withdrawal. | But it cannot postpone indefinitely the moment of decision. With the Conservative government’s Brexit plan under attack from some of Mrs. May’s own lawmakers, Labour’s pro-Europeans, including some influential trade unions, are pressing Mr. Corbyn to shift policy and either embrace closer ties to Europe or call for a referendum on the terms of withdrawal. |
| All this comes as rumors swirl about Labour rebels joining a possible new centrist and pro-European party modeled on En Marche, the movement founded by President Emmanuel Macron of France. | All this comes as rumors swirl about Labour rebels joining a possible new centrist and pro-European party modeled on En Marche, the movement founded by President Emmanuel Macron of France. |
| But with an eye to the previous, disastrous split of 1981, no one is running for the exits; not now, at least. Some fear their hands may be forced, however. At Labour’s annual party conference this month, left-wing activists may press plans that could make it easier to remove lawmakers critical of Mr. Corbyn, whose leadership has attracted many new party members. | But with an eye to the previous, disastrous split of 1981, no one is running for the exits; not now, at least. Some fear their hands may be forced, however. At Labour’s annual party conference this month, left-wing activists may press plans that could make it easier to remove lawmakers critical of Mr. Corbyn, whose leadership has attracted many new party members. |
| Giving these activists greater power over the selection of lawmakers could threaten the future of Mr. Corbyn’s critics, perhaps even inducing them to quit the party before they are driven out. | Giving these activists greater power over the selection of lawmakers could threaten the future of Mr. Corbyn’s critics, perhaps even inducing them to quit the party before they are driven out. |
| Tensions have been heightened by the rift over anti-Semitism, which seemingly should have been resolved relatively easily. Yet accusations against Mr. Corbyn have refused to die, since it emerged this year that in 2012 he had endorsed a mural that was widely considered anti-Semitic — something for which he has since apologized. | Tensions have been heightened by the rift over anti-Semitism, which seemingly should have been resolved relatively easily. Yet accusations against Mr. Corbyn have refused to die, since it emerged this year that in 2012 he had endorsed a mural that was widely considered anti-Semitic — something for which he has since apologized. |
| There was more controversy last month over photos of a wreath-laying ceremony Mr. Corbyn attended in Tunisia in 2014 that took place near memorials for people accused of being linked to a terrorist attack at the 1972 Olympic Games. | There was more controversy last month over photos of a wreath-laying ceremony Mr. Corbyn attended in Tunisia in 2014 that took place near memorials for people accused of being linked to a terrorist attack at the 1972 Olympic Games. |
| While Mr. Corbyn insists he abhors racism and has offered several expressions of regret and apologies over the anti-Semitism claims, he is in no mood to hide either his criticism of Israel or the support he has given to pro-Palestinian causes for decades. | While Mr. Corbyn insists he abhors racism and has offered several expressions of regret and apologies over the anti-Semitism claims, he is in no mood to hide either his criticism of Israel or the support he has given to pro-Palestinian causes for decades. |
| Last week the crisis worsened with the resignation from Labour’s parliamentary party of Frank Field, a veteran and independent-minded lawmaker. In his resignation letter, Mr. Field accused the leadership of “becoming a force for anti-Semitism in British politics,” adding that a “culture of intolerance, nastiness and intimidation now reigns in too many parts of the party.” | Last week the crisis worsened with the resignation from Labour’s parliamentary party of Frank Field, a veteran and independent-minded lawmaker. In his resignation letter, Mr. Field accused the leadership of “becoming a force for anti-Semitism in British politics,” adding that a “culture of intolerance, nastiness and intimidation now reigns in too many parts of the party.” |
| While most of Mr. Corbyn’s internal critics come from the party’s pro-European center and right wing, Mr. Field is one of a handful of Labour lawmakers who campaigned for withdrawal from the bloc and have since voted for Brexit measures in support of Mrs. May. | While most of Mr. Corbyn’s internal critics come from the party’s pro-European center and right wing, Mr. Field is one of a handful of Labour lawmakers who campaigned for withdrawal from the bloc and have since voted for Brexit measures in support of Mrs. May. |
| That underscores the fact that Mr. Corbyn’s internal critics operate out of a variety of objectives, none of which call for immediate action. | That underscores the fact that Mr. Corbyn’s internal critics operate out of a variety of objectives, none of which call for immediate action. |
| Pro-Europeans, still hopeful of a shift in Labour policy against Brexit, are unlikely to attempt any breakaway before March, when Britain is scheduled to leave the European Union. Those who worry about being pushed out by left-wing activists will probably wait until such a threat materializes. | Pro-Europeans, still hopeful of a shift in Labour policy against Brexit, are unlikely to attempt any breakaway before March, when Britain is scheduled to leave the European Union. Those who worry about being pushed out by left-wing activists will probably wait until such a threat materializes. |
| While it is impossible to say how these various strands will play out, it is clear that the discord and weeks of bad publicity have revealed weaknesses in a party that, only a year ago, believed it was on the threshold of power after depriving Mrs. May of her parliamentary majority. | While it is impossible to say how these various strands will play out, it is clear that the discord and weeks of bad publicity have revealed weaknesses in a party that, only a year ago, believed it was on the threshold of power after depriving Mrs. May of her parliamentary majority. |
| “Despite the government’s Brexit fiascos and problems it is still two or three points ahead in most of the opinion polls,” Mr. Quinn said. “That wouldn’t happen if voters were convinced that Labour offered a strong and practical alternative to the government.” | “Despite the government’s Brexit fiascos and problems it is still two or three points ahead in most of the opinion polls,” Mr. Quinn said. “That wouldn’t happen if voters were convinced that Labour offered a strong and practical alternative to the government.” |