This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/london/7663014.stm
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 6 | Version 7 |
|---|---|
| Probe into lawyer killing lawful | Probe into lawyer killing lawful |
| (about 6 hours later) | |
| An independent inquiry into the killing of a barrister shot dead by police during a five-hour armed siege was lawful, the High Court has ruled. | An independent inquiry into the killing of a barrister shot dead by police during a five-hour armed siege was lawful, the High Court has ruled. |
| A judge dismissed a claim by the family of Mark Saunders, 32, that the probe into his death was unlawful. | A judge dismissed a claim by the family of Mark Saunders, 32, that the probe into his death was unlawful. |
| But the judge did raise questions about the police practice of allowing the officers involved to confer. | But the judge did raise questions about the police practice of allowing the officers involved to confer. |
| The judge granted the Saunders family leave to appeal, possibly in order to address the issue in a higher court. | The judge granted the Saunders family leave to appeal, possibly in order to address the issue in a higher court. |
| Mr Saunders died in a stand-off at his flat in Chelsea, west London in May. | Mr Saunders died in a stand-off at his flat in Chelsea, west London in May. |
| BBC crime reporter Ben Ando said Mr Justice Underhill acknowledged that permitting officers to collaborate before they gave their statements meant "the opportunity for collusion is, so to speak, institutionalised". | BBC crime reporter Ben Ando said Mr Justice Underhill acknowledged that permitting officers to collaborate before they gave their statements meant "the opportunity for collusion is, so to speak, institutionalised". |
| The judge said the practice was "highly vulnerable" to challenge under the Human Rights Act, but also said that in this case "...prohibiting collaboration would have been likely to hinder rather than promote an effective investigation." | The judge said the practice was "highly vulnerable" to challenge under the Human Rights Act, but also said that in this case "...prohibiting collaboration would have been likely to hinder rather than promote an effective investigation." |
| Charlotte Saunders said the balance of power seemed wrong | Charlotte Saunders said the balance of power seemed wrong |
| Mr Saunders' family had said the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPPC) inquiry was unlawful as the officers were allowed to confer. | Mr Saunders' family had said the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPPC) inquiry was unlawful as the officers were allowed to confer. |
| The IPCC said it welcomed the High Court's judgement. | The IPCC said it welcomed the High Court's judgement. |
| "The IPCC agrees with Mr Saunders' family that the way officers currently confer after a fatal shooting does not provide best evidence or secure public confidence and should change," said an IPCC spokesman. | "The IPCC agrees with Mr Saunders' family that the way officers currently confer after a fatal shooting does not provide best evidence or secure public confidence and should change," said an IPCC spokesman. |
| "We differed only on how that change should be achieved." | "We differed only on how that change should be achieved." |
| During the siege Mr Saunders fired at police officers, neighbours and buildings with a legally-owned shotgun from his £2.2m home in Markham Square. | During the siege Mr Saunders fired at police officers, neighbours and buildings with a legally-owned shotgun from his £2.2m home in Markham Square. |
| 'Insulting, inaccurate' | 'Insulting, inaccurate' |
| A post-mortem examination revealed that he died from multiple injuries. | A post-mortem examination revealed that he died from multiple injuries. |
| His family believes he posed no risk to the public when he was shot, as the area had been evacuated. | His family believes he posed no risk to the public when he was shot, as the area had been evacuated. |
| Mr Saunders' sister Charlotte said: "I brought these proceedings because I was concerned that the police officers who shot Mark were allowed to confer before giving their accounts to the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC)." | Mr Saunders' sister Charlotte said: "I brought these proceedings because I was concerned that the police officers who shot Mark were allowed to confer before giving their accounts to the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC)." |
| The police denied the family's central claim that conferring mounted to collusion. | The police denied the family's central claim that conferring mounted to collusion. |
| "Conferring is not colluding," said Paul Davis, of the Police Federation. | "Conferring is not colluding," said Paul Davis, of the Police Federation. |
| "To suggest otherwise is as insulting as it is inaccurate and does nothing to reassure members of the public that the police are there to defend and protect them. There is a huge difference between colluding and conferring." | "To suggest otherwise is as insulting as it is inaccurate and does nothing to reassure members of the public that the police are there to defend and protect them. There is a huge difference between colluding and conferring." |