This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/jun/13/i-have-to-go-pru-goward-hangs-up-on-interview-over-secret-report
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| 'I have to go': Pru Goward hangs up on interview over secret report | 'I have to go': Pru Goward hangs up on interview over secret report |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| NSW minister for family services Pru Goward blamed the premier’s department for the decision to withhold a damning report into NSW’s out-of-home care system . | NSW minister for family services Pru Goward blamed the premier’s department for the decision to withhold a damning report into NSW’s out-of-home care system . |
| Goward appeared on ABC Canberra radio on Wednesday morning and when the questioning turned from local issues to the Tune report she appeared to end the interview abruptly with: “I have to go.” | Goward appeared on ABC Canberra radio on Wednesday morning and when the questioning turned from local issues to the Tune report she appeared to end the interview abruptly with: “I have to go.” |
| A spokesman said the ABC was aware Goward had limited time available and had now agreed to an on-air apology, after broadcasting her hang-up and then tweeting about it. The ABC said they acknowledged she did not leave the interview because of the questioning. | |
| The Tune report into the NSW child protection system, which was delivered to the cabinet in 2016, was withheld from the public for two years. | The Tune report into the NSW child protection system, which was delivered to the cabinet in 2016, was withheld from the public for two years. |
| It was released this week, after the Upper House of the NSW parliament ordered the release. The move was supported by a maverick Liberal Matthew Mason-Cox, who crossed the floor to support the minor parties and Labor. | It was released this week, after the Upper House of the NSW parliament ordered the release. The move was supported by a maverick Liberal Matthew Mason-Cox, who crossed the floor to support the minor parties and Labor. |
| Sign up to receive the top stories in Australia every day at noon | Sign up to receive the top stories in Australia every day at noon |
| Asked why it had been kept secret, Goward said: “It was a decision made by a previous minister, and of course it was written for the cabinet.” | Asked why it had been kept secret, Goward said: “It was a decision made by a previous minister, and of course it was written for the cabinet.” |
| “The premier’s department particularly gave very strong advice that we need to preserve the rights of the cabinet to have confidential information provided to it and for it to remain confidential,” she said. | “The premier’s department particularly gave very strong advice that we need to preserve the rights of the cabinet to have confidential information provided to it and for it to remain confidential,” she said. |
| The report, by the former senior public servant David Tune, paints a damning picture of out-of home care in NSW, finding the government spent $1.86bn on vulnerable families in 2015-16 but spending was “crisis-oriented” and had “evolved in an ad hoc way”. | The report, by the former senior public servant David Tune, paints a damning picture of out-of home care in NSW, finding the government spent $1.86bn on vulnerable families in 2015-16 but spending was “crisis-oriented” and had “evolved in an ad hoc way”. |
| Goward said she was “perfectly comfortable” with the Tune report being released. | Goward said she was “perfectly comfortable” with the Tune report being released. |
| “We have done wonderful things in child protection as a result of that report and I think the challenge is to find areas where we have failed to act.” | “We have done wonderful things in child protection as a result of that report and I think the challenge is to find areas where we have failed to act.” |
| The minister, who is also the member for Goulburn, had been asked to appear on the program to discuss the Murrumbateman school. The interview ran for 13 minutes and after dealing with the school issue, veered onto the Tune report. | The minister, who is also the member for Goulburn, had been asked to appear on the program to discuss the Murrumbateman school. The interview ran for 13 minutes and after dealing with the school issue, veered onto the Tune report. |
| Tune said in the report there was “significant unmet demand” and inefficiency, with only one in three reports of children at risk of significant harm being investigated by a family and community services (Facs) worker. | Tune said in the report there was “significant unmet demand” and inefficiency, with only one in three reports of children at risk of significant harm being investigated by a family and community services (Facs) worker. |
| The report said the cost of providing out-of-home care – mainly foster home placements – had risen sharply since the government began transferring responsibility to non-government organisations in 2012. | The report said the cost of providing out-of-home care – mainly foster home placements – had risen sharply since the government began transferring responsibility to non-government organisations in 2012. |
| “The average unit cost of a child in care of an NGO is $41,000 ... while a child in [Facs] care is $27,000,” Tune said. | “The average unit cost of a child in care of an NGO is $41,000 ... while a child in [Facs] care is $27,000,” Tune said. |
| • The number of children in out-of-home care has doubled in 10 years due to increases in factors driving demand, like mental health issues, as well as a lack of investment in vulnerable families’ needs before they enter OOHC | • The number of children in out-of-home care has doubled in 10 years due to increases in factors driving demand, like mental health issues, as well as a lack of investment in vulnerable families’ needs before they enter OOHC |
| • The cost of providing OOHC is growing, with the expanding NGO sector costing significantly more than the government sector | • The cost of providing OOHC is growing, with the expanding NGO sector costing significantly more than the government sector |
| • The government spends a lot on OOHC but it is not well-targeted and there is still significant unmet demand and inefficiency: “Overall, the system is ineffective and unsustainable” | • The government spends a lot on OOHC but it is not well-targeted and there is still significant unmet demand and inefficiency: “Overall, the system is ineffective and unsustainable” |
| • Millions of dollars' worth of programs are delivered in agency silos and are not evaluated | • Millions of dollars' worth of programs are delivered in agency silos and are not evaluated |
| • Outcomes are particularly poor for Aboriginal children and families, who are the highest growing population in OOHC. The number of Aboriginal children being restored to their families has dropped significantly | • Outcomes are particularly poor for Aboriginal children and families, who are the highest growing population in OOHC. The number of Aboriginal children being restored to their families has dropped significantly |
| • Current programs are not aligned with what children and families need | • Current programs are not aligned with what children and families need |
| • Expenditure is crisis-driven, rather than going towards early intervention or family preservation | • Expenditure is crisis-driven, rather than going towards early intervention or family preservation |
| • “The system is failing to improve the long term outcomes for children and to arrest the devastating cycles of intergenerational abuse and neglect” | • “The system is failing to improve the long term outcomes for children and to arrest the devastating cycles of intergenerational abuse and neglect” |
| • A new entity, a NSW family investment commission, is needed to drive and implement personalised packages for vulnerable children and families | • A new entity, a NSW family investment commission, is needed to drive and implement personalised packages for vulnerable children and families |
| Almost 60% of children were now in the care of NGOs and they were staying there longer because the bulk of funding was spent on out-of-home care “instead of addressing family needs earlier”, the report found. | Almost 60% of children were now in the care of NGOs and they were staying there longer because the bulk of funding was spent on out-of-home care “instead of addressing family needs earlier”, the report found. |
| Aboriginal children are disproportionately represented in out-of-home care. | Aboriginal children are disproportionately represented in out-of-home care. |
| In a statement responding to the release of the report, Goward said the government had committed $190m over four years from 2016-17 as an immediate response and that early results were promising, with the numbers of children in care falling. | In a statement responding to the release of the report, Goward said the government had committed $190m over four years from 2016-17 as an immediate response and that early results were promising, with the numbers of children in care falling. |
| New South Wales | New South Wales |
| Child protection | Child protection |
| Children | Children |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |