This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/wales/7638919.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Asbo OAP 'will appeal home ban' | Asbo OAP 'will appeal home ban' |
(30 minutes later) | |
An 82-year-old pensioner banned from her home after being handed a second antisocial behaviour order is set to appeal, her daughter has insisted. | An 82-year-old pensioner banned from her home after being handed a second antisocial behaviour order is set to appeal, her daughter has insisted. |
Dorothy Evans was found guilty on two counts of breaching an Asbo imposed on her to prevent her from harassing neighbours in Abergavenny, south Wales. | Dorothy Evans was found guilty on two counts of breaching an Asbo imposed on her to prevent her from harassing neighbours in Abergavenny, south Wales. |
The order, issued on Friday, means she is banned from her home of 41 years for the next five years. | The order, issued on Friday, means she is banned from her home of 41 years for the next five years. |
She was also given a nine month jail sentence, suspended for two years. | She was also given a nine month jail sentence, suspended for two years. |
At the end of a two-week trial, a jury at Cardiff Crown Court found Evans not guilty of eight other counts of breaching her first Asbo. | At the end of a two-week trial, a jury at Cardiff Crown Court found Evans not guilty of eight other counts of breaching her first Asbo. |
Judge Nicholas Cooke QC said he ordered the ban "with regret". | |
Evans had denied 10 breaches of her Asbo which was served in 2005 and which banned her from causing harassment, alarm or distress to her neighbours. I think it is very harsh to put an 82-year-old out of her home Barbara Thomas | Evans had denied 10 breaches of her Asbo which was served in 2005 and which banned her from causing harassment, alarm or distress to her neighbours. I think it is very harsh to put an 82-year-old out of her home Barbara Thomas |
The new order bans her from coming within one square mile of the house she shared with daughter Barbara Thomas, to the north of Abergavenny town centre, with immediate effect. | The new order bans her from coming within one square mile of the house she shared with daughter Barbara Thomas, to the north of Abergavenny town centre, with immediate effect. |
The judge said the only alternative to the order would be a lengthy prison sentence. | The judge said the only alternative to the order would be a lengthy prison sentence. |
Appeal | Appeal |
Speaking after the case, Mrs Thomas said an appeal against the order "would be launched immediately". | Speaking after the case, Mrs Thomas said an appeal against the order "would be launched immediately". |
"I am very pleased she has been found not guilty on eight charges," she said. | "I am very pleased she has been found not guilty on eight charges," she said. |
"I think it is very harsh to put an 82-year-old out of her home." | "I think it is very harsh to put an 82-year-old out of her home." |
When asked if her mother had a bed for the night, Mrs Thomas said: "We haven't even thought about it. I don't know. | When asked if her mother had a bed for the night, Mrs Thomas said: "We haven't even thought about it. I don't know. |
"She is very upset and she is far from well and she has not been for a long time." | "She is very upset and she is far from well and she has not been for a long time." |
The court was told Evans has convictions dating back to 1999 for harassment and breaching a restraining order. | The court was told Evans has convictions dating back to 1999 for harassment and breaching a restraining order. |
Last year, she was jailed for six months, later reduced to four months, for breaches of the Asbo. | Last year, she was jailed for six months, later reduced to four months, for breaches of the Asbo. |
The pensioner has been in a long-running feud with neighbours triggered by a boundary dispute with Gemma and Leon Stafford on one side and a parking row with Angela and Roberto Casa on the other side. | The pensioner has been in a long-running feud with neighbours triggered by a boundary dispute with Gemma and Leon Stafford on one side and a parking row with Angela and Roberto Casa on the other side. |
The jury found Evans guilty of breaching her Asbo by harassing the Casa family in September 2007 and by harassing the Stafford family on 5 June this year. She has not learned, and she has had too many chances, and there is to be no repetition Judge Nicholas Cooke QC | The jury found Evans guilty of breaching her Asbo by harassing the Casa family in September 2007 and by harassing the Stafford family on 5 June this year. She has not learned, and she has had too many chances, and there is to be no repetition Judge Nicholas Cooke QC |
In sentencing Evans, Judge Cooke said he thought nothing else would bring her offending to an end. | In sentencing Evans, Judge Cooke said he thought nothing else would bring her offending to an end. |
"She has been given a prison sentence in the past, and it did not deflect her from this kind of behaviour" he said. | "She has been given a prison sentence in the past, and it did not deflect her from this kind of behaviour" he said. |
"She has not learned, and she has had too many chances, and there is to be no repetition. This is the end." | "She has not learned, and she has had too many chances, and there is to be no repetition. This is the end." |
Judge Cooke said if Evans breached the order, she could be jailed for up to five years. | Judge Cooke said if Evans breached the order, she could be jailed for up to five years. |
The judge also restrained Evans from behaving in a threatening, abusive or insulting way to either the Casas or the Staffords. | The judge also restrained Evans from behaving in a threatening, abusive or insulting way to either the Casas or the Staffords. |
Her daughter Mrs Thomas will face a court hearing later this year at which Judge Cooke will decide whether or not to bind her over to keep the peace for her own behaviour towards her neighbours. | Her daughter Mrs Thomas will face a court hearing later this year at which Judge Cooke will decide whether or not to bind her over to keep the peace for her own behaviour towards her neighbours. |
The judge also called a meeting between the Crown Prosecution Service, Wales' Commissioner for Older People and the social services department in Monmouthshire to discuss the case. | The judge also called a meeting between the Crown Prosecution Service, Wales' Commissioner for Older People and the social services department in Monmouthshire to discuss the case. |
He is keen to see "how better it might have been dealt with", he added. | He is keen to see "how better it might have been dealt with", he added. |
Previous version
1
Next version