This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/esther-mcvey-dwp-benefits-welfare-stance-comments-controversial-a8149811.html
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Esther McVey: New DWP minister's statements about people on benefits and the policies she has voted for | |
| (about 13 hours later) | |
| Esther McVey's appointment as Work and Pensions Secretary has been met with a backlash from MPs and campaigners over previous comments she has made in the past about benefit claimants. | Esther McVey's appointment as Work and Pensions Secretary has been met with a backlash from MPs and campaigners over previous comments she has made in the past about benefit claimants. |
| The former TV presenter once claimed that the use of food banks was "right". She also said that benefits sanctions "teach" job seekers to look for work seriously. | The former TV presenter once claimed that the use of food banks was "right". She also said that benefits sanctions "teach" job seekers to look for work seriously. |
| Ms McVey, who has previously served as minister for disabled people and later served as employment minister, was handed her new role after it was turned down by former Education Secretary Justine Greening. | Ms McVey, who has previously served as minister for disabled people and later served as employment minister, was handed her new role after it was turned down by former Education Secretary Justine Greening. |
| The appointment of the Conservative MP for Tatton to her new role has been described as “hugely worrying” for vulnerable people in the UK, with campaigners and MPs saying her track record "does not bode well". | The appointment of the Conservative MP for Tatton to her new role has been described as “hugely worrying” for vulnerable people in the UK, with campaigners and MPs saying her track record "does not bode well". |
| Here are four things Ms McVey has previously said about benefit claimants and policies she has voted for: | |
| During a 2013 House of Common debate, Ms McVey claimed it was “right” that people were using food banks. | During a 2013 House of Common debate, Ms McVey claimed it was “right” that people were using food banks. |
| “It is positive that people are reaching out to support other people - from church groups to community groups, to local supermarkets and other groups,” she said. | “It is positive that people are reaching out to support other people - from church groups to community groups, to local supermarkets and other groups,” she said. |
| “In the UK it is right that more people are... going to food banks because as times are tough, we are all having to pay back this £1.5 trillion debt personally which spiralled under Labour, we are all trying to live within our means, change the gear and make sure that we pay back all our debt which happened under them.” | “In the UK it is right that more people are... going to food banks because as times are tough, we are all having to pay back this £1.5 trillion debt personally which spiralled under Labour, we are all trying to live within our means, change the gear and make sure that we pay back all our debt which happened under them.” |
| Comparing claimants to badly behaved school pupils, Ms McVey, in her role as employment minister, defended the sanctions system for people who fail to attend a meeting with an adviser in a 2013 meeting with the Work and Pensions Committee. | Comparing claimants to badly behaved school pupils, Ms McVey, in her role as employment minister, defended the sanctions system for people who fail to attend a meeting with an adviser in a 2013 meeting with the Work and Pensions Committee. |
| “What does a teacher do in a school? A teacher would tell you off or give you lines or whatever it is, detentions, but at the same times they are wanting your best interests at heart,” she said. | “What does a teacher do in a school? A teacher would tell you off or give you lines or whatever it is, detentions, but at the same times they are wanting your best interests at heart,” she said. |
| “They are teaching you, they are educating you but at the same time they will also have the ability to sanction you.” | “They are teaching you, they are educating you but at the same time they will also have the ability to sanction you.” |
| Replacing the Disability Living Allowance (DLA) with the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) proved hugely controversial. | Replacing the Disability Living Allowance (DLA) with the Personal Independence Payment (PIP) proved hugely controversial. |
| Introducing the new benefit in April 2013, Ms McVey said: “Disability Living Allowance is an outdated benefit introduced over twenty years ago and needs reform to better reflect today’s understanding of disability. | Introducing the new benefit in April 2013, Ms McVey said: “Disability Living Allowance is an outdated benefit introduced over twenty years ago and needs reform to better reflect today’s understanding of disability. |
| “At the moment the vast majority of claimants get the benefit for life without any systematic reassessments and around 50 per cent of decisions are made on the basis of the claim form alone – without any additional corroborating medical evidence. | “At the moment the vast majority of claimants get the benefit for life without any systematic reassessments and around 50 per cent of decisions are made on the basis of the claim form alone – without any additional corroborating medical evidence. |
| “The PIP will include a new face-to-face assessment and regular reviews - something missing in the current system. This will ensure the billions we spend give more targeted support to those who need it most.” | “The PIP will include a new face-to-face assessment and regular reviews - something missing in the current system. This will ensure the billions we spend give more targeted support to those who need it most.” |
| But last March Citizens Advice chief executive Gillian Guy said PIP was the biggest issue people sought advice for through her organisation, with almost 400,000 queries in the year. | But last March Citizens Advice chief executive Gillian Guy said PIP was the biggest issue people sought advice for through her organisation, with almost 400,000 queries in the year. |
| An independent review published in the same month found that claimants had an "inherent distrust" of the system and 65 per cent of those who appealed against rejected claims saw the decision overturned by judges. | An independent review published in the same month found that claimants had an "inherent distrust" of the system and 65 per cent of those who appealed against rejected claims saw the decision overturned by judges. |
| This, along with a lack of transparency in the assessment process, is damaging trust in PIP, the report said. | This, along with a lack of transparency in the assessment process, is damaging trust in PIP, the report said. |
| Parliamentary voting records show Ms McVey has: | Parliamentary voting records show Ms McVey has: |