This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/04/rhian-brewster-football-racism-abuse
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Forget the football. Rhian Brewster’s story is about racism, plain and simple | Forget the football. Rhian Brewster’s story is about racism, plain and simple |
| (12 days later) | |
| Contact author | |
| Thu 4 Jan 2018 15.43 GMT | |
| Last modified on Thu 4 Jan 2018 15.45 GMT | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| View more sharing options | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Close | |
| Type in Uefa and the word “racism” into Google, and prominent search results tell us the view of European football’s governing body. Uefa wants us to know it says no to racism. In fact, in 2013, its member associations “pledged to step up their efforts to eliminate racism from football” altogether. It’s all rather grand, but what we know is that in recent weeks Uefa’s self-congratulatory stance has been greatly undermined. Revelations from the England Under-17s World Cup-winning forward Rhian Brewster have once again highlighted the perniciousness of the problem. | Type in Uefa and the word “racism” into Google, and prominent search results tell us the view of European football’s governing body. Uefa wants us to know it says no to racism. In fact, in 2013, its member associations “pledged to step up their efforts to eliminate racism from football” altogether. It’s all rather grand, but what we know is that in recent weeks Uefa’s self-congratulatory stance has been greatly undermined. Revelations from the England Under-17s World Cup-winning forward Rhian Brewster have once again highlighted the perniciousness of the problem. |
| Brewster’s experience of racist abuse represents unacceptable treatment of a young man just trying to do his job. The player has been praised for unequivocally relating his experiences, which have been free from the euphemism so many would have preferred the shadow home secretary Diane Abbott to adopt when she shared that, last year, she had been called a “n----- bitch”. | Brewster’s experience of racist abuse represents unacceptable treatment of a young man just trying to do his job. The player has been praised for unequivocally relating his experiences, which have been free from the euphemism so many would have preferred the shadow home secretary Diane Abbott to adopt when she shared that, last year, she had been called a “n----- bitch”. |
| In an interview with my colleague Daniel Taylor for the Guardian, Brewster frankly outlined the racist abuse he both witnessed and suffered while playing for Liverpool in Uefa Youth League matches and for England. Called the N-word and subjected to monkey chants, the 17-year-old has understandably lost faith in Uefa, whose responses to these incidents have been pitiful or nonexistent. | In an interview with my colleague Daniel Taylor for the Guardian, Brewster frankly outlined the racist abuse he both witnessed and suffered while playing for Liverpool in Uefa Youth League matches and for England. Called the N-word and subjected to monkey chants, the 17-year-old has understandably lost faith in Uefa, whose responses to these incidents have been pitiful or nonexistent. |
| Fans shouldn’t allow collective responsibility to be offloaded on to the shoulders of someone yet to be called an adult | Fans shouldn’t allow collective responsibility to be offloaded on to the shoulders of someone yet to be called an adult |
| Uefa says it encourages referees to “stop, suspend or even abandon a game if racist incidents occur”. Players found guilty of racist behaviour can receive a 10-match suspension, and stadiums can face closure if this applies to fans. Uefa recognises the power it has to drastically change the experiences of young black players. However, for now at least, it seems disinclined to use it. It is an obvious dereliction of duty. The hope is that today – the first day its offices have been open since 22 December – the governing body will stir itself into more forceful action. | Uefa says it encourages referees to “stop, suspend or even abandon a game if racist incidents occur”. Players found guilty of racist behaviour can receive a 10-match suspension, and stadiums can face closure if this applies to fans. Uefa recognises the power it has to drastically change the experiences of young black players. However, for now at least, it seems disinclined to use it. It is an obvious dereliction of duty. The hope is that today – the first day its offices have been open since 22 December – the governing body will stir itself into more forceful action. |
| Slogans, though easy to cobble together and flash at millions of people, are empty. Like a sticking plaster for a virus, their flimsiness is obvious when set against the task of healing. It is a lesson the Italian football league painfully learned last October. The president of Lazio football club, Claudio Lotito, had players wearing T-shirts declaring “no to antisemitism” accompanied by a picture of Anne Frank. An excerpt of her diary was read at every Italian league match during the same week. Yet some Lazio fans sang fascist songs while making salutes during the reading. The horrified prime minister, Paolo Gentiloni, called the scenes unacceptable. Quite. The trouble is in how governing bodies, clubs, fellow players and not least the fans act in solidarity to underscore that such behaviour is intolerable. | Slogans, though easy to cobble together and flash at millions of people, are empty. Like a sticking plaster for a virus, their flimsiness is obvious when set against the task of healing. It is a lesson the Italian football league painfully learned last October. The president of Lazio football club, Claudio Lotito, had players wearing T-shirts declaring “no to antisemitism” accompanied by a picture of Anne Frank. An excerpt of her diary was read at every Italian league match during the same week. Yet some Lazio fans sang fascist songs while making salutes during the reading. The horrified prime minister, Paolo Gentiloni, called the scenes unacceptable. Quite. The trouble is in how governing bodies, clubs, fellow players and not least the fans act in solidarity to underscore that such behaviour is intolerable. |
| One way to do so is by not distancing the English game, run by the FA, from the routine instances of racism experienced by black and minority-ethnic (BAME) players. To focus solely on Uefa’s failings is to miss the point of Brewster’s interventions entirely. Yes, much progress has been made: in Brewster’s interview it is clear he hasn’t experienced in England racist abuse of the kind encountered in matches against Russian and Spanish teams. Still, players continue to walk out on English pitches subjected to such abuse. Anecdotally, others refuse to sign to the youth wings of certain clubs because of the rampant racism associated with their fans. | One way to do so is by not distancing the English game, run by the FA, from the routine instances of racism experienced by black and minority-ethnic (BAME) players. To focus solely on Uefa’s failings is to miss the point of Brewster’s interventions entirely. Yes, much progress has been made: in Brewster’s interview it is clear he hasn’t experienced in England racist abuse of the kind encountered in matches against Russian and Spanish teams. Still, players continue to walk out on English pitches subjected to such abuse. Anecdotally, others refuse to sign to the youth wings of certain clubs because of the rampant racism associated with their fans. |
| BAME players make up a quarter of players in English football’s four divisions yet account for a miserable 4% of senior coaches. It is the same footballing establishment that last October couldn’t admit it had failed in its duty of care to the England player Eniola Aluko. And it is the same leadership that couldn’t quite bring itself to find anything wrong with racist texts sent “privately” between Iain Moody, now Colchester’s head of player resources, and Malky Mackay, currently caretaker manager of Scotland and the performance director of the Scottish Football Association. The controversy eventually blew over, and both white men’s careers in football continued, once the word “banter” was used to explain their seemingly indefensible interactions. | BAME players make up a quarter of players in English football’s four divisions yet account for a miserable 4% of senior coaches. It is the same footballing establishment that last October couldn’t admit it had failed in its duty of care to the England player Eniola Aluko. And it is the same leadership that couldn’t quite bring itself to find anything wrong with racist texts sent “privately” between Iain Moody, now Colchester’s head of player resources, and Malky Mackay, currently caretaker manager of Scotland and the performance director of the Scottish Football Association. The controversy eventually blew over, and both white men’s careers in football continued, once the word “banter” was used to explain their seemingly indefensible interactions. |
| Last year, the sports anti-racism body Kick It Out reported that in the 2016-2017 season, reports of racist abuse rose by 16.7%. That was sadly predictable in the context of a record rise in race and religious hate crime following the Brexit vote. Even if Brewster were to instigate a US-style taking-a-knee stance, as has been rumoured, it leaves racism in football as primarily a problem for players to solve alone. Which isn’t good enough. Soon a backlash will, no doubt, ensue. It will bemoan bringing politics into football. Because, presumably, a much preferable scenario would be to have BAME players reconcile racist abuse and violence as an unfortunate fact of their professional lives. Anything less would be too much of an inconvenience. | Last year, the sports anti-racism body Kick It Out reported that in the 2016-2017 season, reports of racist abuse rose by 16.7%. That was sadly predictable in the context of a record rise in race and religious hate crime following the Brexit vote. Even if Brewster were to instigate a US-style taking-a-knee stance, as has been rumoured, it leaves racism in football as primarily a problem for players to solve alone. Which isn’t good enough. Soon a backlash will, no doubt, ensue. It will bemoan bringing politics into football. Because, presumably, a much preferable scenario would be to have BAME players reconcile racist abuse and violence as an unfortunate fact of their professional lives. Anything less would be too much of an inconvenience. |
| A 17-year-old is bearing the weight of the fight against racism, and needs support from the behemoth that is Uefa. It is an incredibly vulnerable position, one that needs more than mere platitudes about bravery and commendable behaviour to bolster it. Fans shouldn’t allow a collective responsibility to be offloaded on to the shoulders of someone who is not yet an adult. Of course we should be saying no to racism, but now we need the detail as to how this will actually be done. | A 17-year-old is bearing the weight of the fight against racism, and needs support from the behemoth that is Uefa. It is an incredibly vulnerable position, one that needs more than mere platitudes about bravery and commendable behaviour to bolster it. Fans shouldn’t allow a collective responsibility to be offloaded on to the shoulders of someone who is not yet an adult. Of course we should be saying no to racism, but now we need the detail as to how this will actually be done. |
| • Lola Okolosie is an English teacher and freelance journalist | • Lola Okolosie is an English teacher and freelance journalist |
| Race issues | |
| Opinion | |
| Uefa | |
| The FA | |
| Football politics | |
| comment | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Reuse this content |