This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/americas/7583615.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 2 | Version 3 |
---|---|
Brazil delays Indian land ruling | |
(about 12 hours later) | |
Brazil's Supreme Court has delayed a decision on the future of one of the country's biggest indigenous reserves. | |
One of the judges deciding whether the Raposa Serra do Sol reservation should remain a single unbroken territory said he wanted more time. | |
Indian leaders believe the case will set a crucial precedent regarding the protection of their rights and land. | Indian leaders believe the case will set a crucial precedent regarding the protection of their rights and land. |
Non-indigenous farmers demanding to stay in the region say their eviction would harm its economic development. | |
Indigenous groups arrived in the capital, Brasilia, to make their voice heard, staging a traditional protest just across the road from where the Supreme Court judges will reach their decision. | Indigenous groups arrived in the capital, Brasilia, to make their voice heard, staging a traditional protest just across the road from where the Supreme Court judges will reach their decision. |
Inside the courtroom, the BBC's Gary Duffy said the divisions between the two parties could not be clearer - with one side wearing traditional Indian headgear and face paint, and the other side dressed in suits or jeans and short-sleeved shirts. | |
Conflict | Conflict |
The Indian reservation known as Raposa Serra do Sol is home to 19,000 people and was given official status in 2005. | The Indian reservation known as Raposa Serra do Sol is home to 19,000 people and was given official status in 2005. |
Indian leaders want the court to confirm that the reservation, which stretches over 1.7m hectares (4.2m acres), should be preserved as a single unbroken territory. | Indian leaders want the court to confirm that the reservation, which stretches over 1.7m hectares (4.2m acres), should be preserved as a single unbroken territory. |
They say if the court decides against them it will send a signal to land grabbers, prospectors and loggers that it would be acceptable to invade indigenous territory. | They say if the court decides against them it will send a signal to land grabbers, prospectors and loggers that it would be acceptable to invade indigenous territory. |
However, about 200 non-indigenous farmers who live and work in the area say if the court upholds the reservation's status they will be forced to leave, harming Roraima's economy. | However, about 200 non-indigenous farmers who live and work in the area say if the court upholds the reservation's status they will be forced to leave, harming Roraima's economy. |
The judge overseeing the case was only able to deliver his conclusion that Raposa Serra do Sol should be preserved as a continuous territory before a colleague asked for the hearing to be suspended to allow more time for deliberation. | |
Our correspondent said the delay seemed to be just another indication of the sensitivity of the case. | |
The issue has been the subject of growing tension and conflict between the two sides. | The issue has been the subject of growing tension and conflict between the two sides. |
Indigenous lawyer Joenia Batista de Carvalho says the ruling will be crucial for her community. | |
"This judgement is the most historic for indigenous people. It is the most important moment after the constitution of 1988," she said. | |
"It is a situation that reaffirms what has been approved by the national congress and reinforces the application of our rights. It is fundamental, because they are discussing our lives." | |
'Flag bearers' | |
But rice farmer and local mayor Paulo Quartiero says the farmers are a vital part of the economy in the state of Roraima. | |
"We are the flag bearers of our state's calling to be a great agricultural producer - a great food producer not only for the Amazon but also for the world," he said. "So this represents a seed which if it is suffocated will cause extraordinary damage." | |
Mr Qaurtiero has been jailed twice for resisting eviction from the reservation - on one occasion when his employees shot and wounded 10 Indians. | |
There are more than 100 similar cases before the Supreme Court but it is thought this ruling will establish an important legal precedent. | There are more than 100 similar cases before the Supreme Court but it is thought this ruling will establish an important legal precedent. |
There has also been concern among military leaders that a large Indian reservation on Brazil's border undermines the country's sovereignty - a claim strongly contested by indigenous communities who say it would remain Brazilian territory. | There has also been concern among military leaders that a large Indian reservation on Brazil's border undermines the country's sovereignty - a claim strongly contested by indigenous communities who say it would remain Brazilian territory. |
There is only one issue on which all sides in this argument are agreed, and that is over the importance of this judgement and its longer-term implications. | There is only one issue on which all sides in this argument are agreed, and that is over the importance of this judgement and its longer-term implications. |